Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
That last point about trusted reviewers is interesting. I’ve posted a number of critical opinions online and often times get nothing but hate, downvotes and name calling, so I’ve chosen to stop doing it. The hive mindset is what drives those trusted reviewers away, so as long as people continue to groupthink, those real reviews will be hard to come by. Ridicule people enough and eventually they stop caring to help, but some people are too ignorant and selfish to understand that.
It's hard to do for sure. Think about how you actually read through reviews when buying something though - do you start with all the 5 star reviews?

Not me - I always start with the 1 to 3 star reviews to find the product flaws, and then look at the overall picture. I also do a quick glance to make sure on the histogram of ratings that the 1 & 2 star reviews combined don't exceed around 10% or so, or it's almost certainly a bad product.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mariusignorello
If an app accepts authentication info from another service, there's no guarantee it won't steal those accounts and do bad things with it. However, if they genuinely and effectively only detect fake reviews, it would be a wise thing for Amazon to acquire this app instead. Apparently AMZ itself has been struggling to identify and remove fake reviews on its own.
 
Safari isn’t on the App Store in any real capacity, so no need to follow the rules.

And yes, browsers serve websites. The fakespot used a Safari web view to “serve” amazon.com, just with their additional overlay. Do you use an ad blocker? Same concept. Modifying a website against the will of the original creator. Chrome on iOS intercepts user account details to store in its password manager. Is that a security concern? Yes, but hand waved away because it is google. iOS 15 is bringing full browser extensions to iOS, so this is really all moot because fakespot will have their full safari extension available on iOS.

So my point is, why block it on the App Store?
Less publicity
 
That's why you never look on the best reviews of a product. They have a very high likelihood of being fake. Look mainly at the bad reviews and try to get a picture of the product in question.
Nah, I just look at the number of reviews, good or bad. If that many people bought it, it can't be that bad. So far that's worked.

Like, how often are the bad reviews actually for relevant reasons? When I was looking for a landlord, I picked one with a terrible rating. All the 1-star reviews were from people who didn't pay rent and got evicted.
 
Yeah, that didn't happen.
Yeah, that did happen. I was charged for a piece of crap wireless charger and a package of Hallowe’en lights. I didn’t notice the charges because it was on a card I didn’t often use and wasn’t really watching. But I was absolutely charged for that crap and Amazon confirmed the number it was charged against was mine, as did my financial institution.

And please show me where I said it was purchased on my account or where I could change the review that I didn’t write and that wasn’t on my account.

So you don’t know what you’re talking about. You assumed a bunch of facts not in evidence and just made crap up.
 
Last edited:
My purchases on Amazon are a fraction of what they were 2 years ago. B&H for cameras. Apple & B&H for computing. Manufacturers online sales for a surprisingly wide variety of purchases. I now get out and visit the Home Depots and shopping malls I had abandoned. I’m sick and tired of cheap junk sold on Amazon, at times wildly inflated prices, fake products, fake reviews and crappy marketplace vendors.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mkldev
LOL. Of course it didn't happen to him. My wife was a "target" (definitely NOT a "victim") of the unwanted product/fake review scam, and that's not how it works at all. The target doesn't get charged at all, they just use an Amazon account with your name (maybe an old abandoned account), and legitimately pay for the stuff. We ended up with tons of free, useless crap on our doorstep before we got Amazon to halt it. The only "cost" to us was the effort we put in to tear the packaging apart, before we disposed of everything, as we recycle religiously.
Congratulations. Your wife was a target of a *different* scam so her experience tells you precisely nothing about mine. You’ll notice I didn’t say that *I* left a review. The (now cancelled) account that made the purchase using my credit card and shipped it to me made the review and purchase. I thought it was a standard “brushing” scam (which is what you dealt with) at first, but it wasn’t. Amazing, I know, that your experience does not describe the sum of human existence.

I don’t normally get pissy, but try reading what I said, not what you imagine I said.

The shipping it to me was simply to avoid the additional scrutiny that comes from putting in a new address with a credit card.

So of course it happened, unless I have an alternative personality registering Amazon accounts using *my* credit card to buy crap I don’t want and ship it to me.
 
Sure. Unwanted stuff starts showing up at your house and the first thing you do is log in to Amazon and leave a positive review. And it keeps showing up because you never report fraud or cancel the card. Riiiiiiight. We believe you. No, really.
Did I say I did that? Please show me where I did. No, the scam account that ordered it did that. And I know about it because I *did* report the fraud and cancel the card, which was part of the “spot of work” to get it straightened out.
 
Last edited:
Hmm.. that’s a great excuse to tell my wife. Honey, I didn’t order all these gadgets… someone hacked my Amazon account and ordered them and had them sent to me… :)
Didn’t hack my account in this case, but instead registered an account with a throw-away mobile and my credit card. I only wish they were sending me stuff I wanted. Instead I received a crappy wireless charger and some overpriced purple LED Hallowe’en lights. If they’d been ordering me good stuff and I got my money back as well, then I might have to convince my wife. “No, honest, I didn’t order that Apple Watch and a new 3D printer. You gotta believe me.”
 
Something similar happened to me. But then I did receive a decent product, although I have very little hair to straighten. Couldn't understand what the perp got out of it, but perhaps this is it? Seems a lot of effort.The perp did not use my amazon account, and amazon claimed that no one at amazon charged my credit card. I dunno, it was delivered by an amazon truck. Does anyone want a $75 value hair straightener/curler combo? :)

You always had to take reviews with a grain of salt and use some common sense, but years ago it seemed to be much easier to sift through reviews by looking at the lower rated ones. My spouse has been burned by Facebook marketplace, which is worse than amazon, if you can believe anything can be worse. Now I tend to buy from more trusted sources.
 
Last edited:
Good. It’s a trash company. They are marking my product reviews as fake. Never in my life have I bought a fake review and they ignore all inquiries about this. I know of many people who’s experienced the exact same thing.
 
Something similar happened to me. But then I did receive a decent product, although I have very little hair to straighten. Couldn't understand what the perp got out of it, but perhaps this is it? Seems a lot of effort.The perp did not use my amazon account, and amazon claimed that no one at amazon charged my credit card. I dunno, it was delivered by an amazon truck. Does anyone want a $75 value hair straightener/curler combo? :)

You always had to take reviews with a grain of salt and use some common sense, but years ago it seemed to be much easier to sift through reviews by looking at the lower rated ones. My spouse has been burned by Facebook marketplace, which is worse than amazon, if you can believe anything can be worse. Now I tend to buy from more trusted sources.
This is a scam called “brushing” (no pun intended given what you got) and is what I thought happened to me until I realized I’d been charged for the crap I got. Brushing is used to manipulate sales numbers. What I was hit with was worse because it pushed the cost to me.
 
Not me - I always start with the 1 to 3 star reviews to find the product flaws, and then look at the overall picture. I also do a quick glance to make sure on the histogram of ratings that the 1 & 2 star reviews combined don't exceed around 10% or so, or it's almost certainly a bad product.
I do something similar - I look for reviews that actually have more than "this is great / this is terrible" in them. Because what someone dislikes may be something I like, and vice versa.

I do look at the overall amount of reviews and the overall star rating, but in and of itself these aren't enough for me without some good comments in the review explaining why the reviewer gave the rating.
 
This is a scam called “brushing” (no pun intended given what you got) and is what I thought happened to me until I realized I’d been charged for the crap I got. Brushing is used to manipulate sales numbers. What I was hit with was worse because it pushed the cost to me.
Maybe I'm confused but Amazon charged my credit card and if I didn't complain to the bank I would have paid the cost. At first I thought it was an Amazon screw up but they denied charging the card and sending the product, but then it was delivered by amazon :)
 
I got nailed by a scammer that stole my credit card details and started ordering crap I didn’t want and sending it to me. It’s part of a scam to boost order number and be able to get “verified purchaser” reviews for crap. It was a spot of work to get it straightened out. Amazon’s got a real problem with these sorts of things and I don’t know how they’d solve it. I can imagine that they don’t want apps like this to highlight the problem.
This is a reason not use apps or browser extensions on amazon, best buy etc. At least not while logged in. I tried out the fakespot browser extension in a linux virtual machine, not logged into Amazon, and couldn't really tell what the veracity of it was.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.