Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

MacRumors

macrumors bot
Original poster
Apr 12, 2001
67,892
38,596


A federal court has ruled that President Donald Trump exceeded his authority in attempting to impose sweeping tariffs on imported goods, including Apple products, halting plans that could have dramatically raised iPhone prices across the United States (via CNET).

Apple-iPhone-16-family-lineup.jpg

The U.S. Court of International Trade yesterday issued a unanimous decision blocking a series of tariff orders that the Trump administration attempted to implement using emergency executive powers. The panel of three judges determined that the International Emergency Economic Powers Act (IEEPA) of 1977 does not permit the president to unilaterally impose duties on foreign goods without Congressional approval. The case specifically affects tariff proposals that would have significantly impacted Apple.

The Trump administration threatened to apply a 25% tariff on all iPhones produced outside the United States. The administration cited IEEPA as justification for imposing these and other related tariffs in recent times. In its opinion, the court found that such an interpretation would constitute "an improper abdication of legislative power" and would render the president's trade authority effectively unlimited.

An unlimited delegation of tariff authority would constitute an improper abdication of legislative power to another branch of government. Regardless of whether the court views the president's actions through the nondelegation doctrine, through the major questions doctrine, or simply with separation of powers in mind, any interpretation of IEEPA that delegates unlimited tariff authority is unconstitutional.

The decision invalidates a set of executive tariff orders issued in April as part of the Trump administration's "Liberation Day" initiative, which intended to reset the balance of trade through a broad set of import duties. The full set of proposed tariffs had not yet gone into full effect but had already introduced substantial market uncertainty, particularly for Apple, which depends heavily on international manufacturing.

The tariffs could have raised the retail price of the most expensive iPhone model—the iPhone 16 Pro Max with 1TB of storage—from $1,599 to more than $4,300 in a worst-case scenario, according to CNET. Similarly, the base iPhone 16E with 128GB of storage could have reached $1,617 under the most aggressive tariff schedule.

The projections were based on a combination of existing and proposed tariffs: a 30% duty on Chinese goods rising to 145% in August, along with a separate 25% Apple-specific tariff proposed by the administration. CNET estimates that a price increase of $50 to $130 was already likely for the iPhone 17 lineup, regardless of the tariff issue; Apple has not raised iPhone prices since 2020.

The U.S. Court of International Trade ruling came in response to two lawsuits filed by the Liberty Justice Center on behalf of five U.S. businesses and another filed by a coalition of 12 states led by Oregon.

Note: Due to the political or social nature of the discussion regarding this topic, the discussion thread is located in our Political News forum. All forum members and site visitors are welcome to read and follow the thread, but posting is limited to forum members with at least 100 posts.

Article Link: Federal Court Blocks Trump Tariffs That Could Have Pushed iPhone Prices to Over $4,000
 
This isn’t over yet. What I’ve learned over the last few months with the little research I’ve done is that tariff law in the U.S. is confusing. Congress has passed a number of laws giving the executive broad-ranging powers to implement tariffs. This will most likely end up in the Supreme Court before it’s all over.
 
Listen, I don't think anyone thought $4000+ iphone was a possibility.

Trump certainly didn’t, he thought “they’ll just start making it in USA!”

But the reality was - that could lead to an $4000 iPhone. The reason this didn’t happen is that USA still has a functioning system: one that Trump is actively trying to bypass or destroy. So, watch as the impossible slowly becomes possible, or even likely - unless something changes.
 
This isn’t over yet. What I’ve learned over the last few months with the little research I’ve done is that tariff law in the U.S. is confusing. Congress has passed a number of laws giving the executive broad-ranging powers to implement tariffs. This will most likely end up in the Supreme Court before it’s all over.
SCOTUS has an easy sideways slide on this one. As pointed out by the lower court panel (two of whom are Republicans), the law cited by Trump does not give the Executive Branch (Trump or anyone else) to impose Tariffs. It doesn't even mention Tariffs. All SCOTUS needs to say in affirming this decision is, "if Congress intended to give this power to the executive, it could have included the word "Tariff" or "import tax or duties" in the law cited by the President and it did not. So, if the executive branch believes it needs this power, it can now go to Congress and ask for it. Whether Congress has the right to grant this authority is a question we need not address in this case."
 
The rest of the world had to be scratching their heads, wondering, "how did we ever let ourselves trust such a crazy Government like the US" which allows a single person to completely upend the trade relationships between the largest economy in the world and every other nation. Now, we know the truth. That single person never had the authority in the first place, but like so many things Trump, he just assumed he had it, or didn't care that he didn't. He's a criminal, after all. Lines don't matter to him.

Now, I am sure they are asking, how could the most powerful country in the world be so stupid they'd elect someone who is so stupid he thought he could destroy their own economy and the world economy just because he said so?
 
The rest of the world had to be scratching their heads, wondering, "how did we ever let ourselves trust such a crazy Government like the US" which allows a single person to completely upend the trade relationships between the largest economy in the world and every other nation. Now, we know the truth. That single person never had the authority in the first place, but like so many things Trump, he just assumed he had it, or didn't care that he didn't. He's a criminal, after all. Lines don't matter to him.

Now, I am sure they are asking, how could the most powerful country in the world be so stupid they'd elect someone who is so stupid he thought he could destroy their own economy and the world economy just because he said so?
HALF of our country "would be so stupid". So there is hope. But that half was continually brainwashed by targeted lies telling them our country was bad. Very Bad. It's never been so bad. And that he could fix it. Why they would vote for a convicted felon, though? That requires some reading about how the brainwashed mind works.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.