Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

MacRumors

macrumors bot
Original poster


Apple today released Final Cut Pro version 10.4.1, the latest update to its professional video editing software that it previewed last week.

final-cut-pro-x-10-4-1-prores-raw-800x471.jpg
 
I’m glad they are still updating Motion but I wish they would REALLY work on Motion to make it compete with After Effects. I know AE is the industry standard but I’m only competing with myself and I personally find Motion better/faster in many ways. If Apple added only a few more features and Trapcode found it worthwhile to support with their plugins, I wouldn’t need to use After Effects at all.
 
I’m glad they are still updating Motion but I wish they would REALLY work on Motion to make it compete with After Effects. I know AE is the industry standard but I’m only competing with myself and I personally find Motion better/faster in many ways. If Apple added only a few more features and Trapcode found it worthwhile to support with their plugins, I wouldn’t need to use After Effects at all.
Are you able to open Motion files in Final Cut Pro yet? Prior to FCPX you were able to open Motion files directly into Final Cut Pro 7, so adding things like lower thirds was incredibly easy but they took this functionally away when they upgraded to X.
 
Nice update. It’s great to see Apple committed to its Pro customers.

Makes me sad they decided to abandon Aperture.

Me too! 🙁 AP was/is a great app. I'm still using it, but its days for me are numbered because I went with a Sony mirrorless and AP doesn't recognize the files. I'm evaluating Capture Pro One 11. It feels very similar to AP, but I don't like how I can't write the keywords to the original file. I don't run a business so my shots are purely family & wildlife. You can write the keywords to files you output however.

As for FCX, it's nice to see the updates! I hope they keep it alive.
 
Did anybody experience problems with optical flow in the last update? If so have they been fixed with this one? I’ll try when I get home.
 
Are you able to open Motion files in Final Cut Pro yet? Prior to FCPX you were able to open Motion files directly into Final Cut Pro 7, so adding things like lower thirds was incredibly easy but they took this functionally away when they upgraded to X.
Final Cut isn’t part of my workflow so I’m not the person to ask. AFAIK, it’s more of a round tripping action where Motion opens for editing when you click on an asset in FCP. If the Motion asset is designed correctly, you should be able to edit pertinent parts like the text right in FCP because that aspect was set to Publish to FCP. The only reason you would open Motion is to change the design.
 
I am hoping this update to compressor allows me to open mp4's created with my 4K Sony video recorders.
Still currently having to use Adobe Media Encoder just to encode from 4K to 1080.


Preview can open them, iMovie, FCPX, everything can play the ole natively on the Mac but Compressor can't open them.
 
Timing, as they say, is everything. I spent the day yesterday downgrading to 10.12.6, partly to overcome FCPX issues, though also to address a consistent "crash in the morning" problem. I suspect the latter was more likely due to accumulated cruft, and a clean install should do it. And as of this morning I now see that FCP/Compressor/iMovie are available, but "incompatible Updates."
 
For me, the caption thing is far more interesting than ProRes RAW. ProRes RAW sounds fantastic, but it seems like it will only factor in for those who use Blackmagic, RED, or Arri when they release new cameras or firmware updates. I just shoot 4k 100mbps xavcs so even prores LT is overkill for me lol
 
I’m glad they are still updating Motion but I wish they would REALLY work on Motion to make it compete with After Effects. I know AE is the industry standard but I’m only competing with myself and I personally find Motion better/faster in many ways. If Apple added only a few more features and Trapcode found it worthwhile to support with their plugins, I wouldn’t need to use After Effects at all.

That'd certainly be nice, although that would be an expensive and long process. I think the bigger problem is that you don't just have to compete with After Effects, you have to compete with the synergy of Adobe CC.

As someone who makes their living in After Effects, though, I'd be happy to switch if I had the same tools but with FCPX's speed. Multiprocessor rendering has been MIA in After Effects for more than three years now, and it's clear the lack of competition has not compelled them to do much more than GPU-accelerate a few panels of the program at a time.
 
Do you think Apple will release a major update to Motion at some point?

Motion 5 was released in 2011...
 
  • Like
Reactions: laurim
Avid Media Composer is my favourite NLE, its also the industry standard; but Final Cut Pro X is quickly becoming my go to for smaller projects!
 
Has Apple not heard of RED? I am sure that RED use a form of RAW, and this RED R3D files are a nightmare to edit if you have less than a $100 000 imac pro and plenty of external gpu units...Why was it RAW and not RED?? Sadly this was not a great update, the closed caption function is great.

Still no audio mixer slider function, more bloatware for the 2 people that wanted VR/360...The same bugs and irritations from 10.0.0 still alive and well...

You cannot zoom into the clip in the browser when in listview...
 
  • Like
Reactions: foliovision
I bet it would be a cool trick if compressor was able to convert CR2 image sequences into Prores RAW. A Canon 5D3 with Magic Lantern shooting Raw video would give REDs a run for their money. (just a wild thought 😛)
 
Has Apple not heard of RED? I am sure that RED use a form of RAW, and this RED R3D files are a nightmare to edit if you have less than a $100 000 imac pro and plenty of external gpu units...

I have edited Red R3d files (4K 5K 6K) on MacPros, iMacs and MBPs several times on Premiere/Mac and it is all fine. Sure you'd want to turn down preview quality to 1/16 or 1/8 for a smooth playback but hardly a nightmare. You won't need maxed out iMac Pros, neither external GPUs. Of course, this performance comes with decent/recent Macs and thunderbolt/ssd usb drives. Is it that bad to edit/playback 3rd files on FCP X? In Premiere these things are all native, one doesn't even need to install anything else apart from the editing software itself.
 
  • Like
Reactions: sos47
Is it that bad to edit/playback 3rd files on FCP X?
No, not at all. You just have to download the plug in from RED for FCPX and then everything is native. I've had no trouble editing R3Ds for a short film shot in 4.5K, straight from a Scarlet, on a 2012 cMBP, just by using a fast hard drive just to have enough bandwidth for real time playback. I guess the more modern Macs can handle without a problem even higher resolutions. If R3Ds needed a 100,000 dollars computer to be edited, then Apple wouldn't have offered RED Raven as a filmmaker's "starting kit" bundled with FCPX. https://www.apple.com/us_smb_78313/shop/product/HK8Q2ZM/A/red-raven-camera-kit-final-cut-pro-x
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.