Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Any women here? I think those of you yelling about "personal responsibility" might be men like my husband with those generous pockets alotted to men's clothing. At least going by the comments here.

Yes, I admit it is far more rare for my husband to lose or misplace things than it is for me. They're all either in his pocket or on the kitchen counter or a shelf in his home office or his nightstand. Whenever he strays and puts something somewhere other than those places, all hell breaks loose and we become search and rescue squad members, because if his things aren't in their designated places, OMG, someome must have summoned a poltergeist who stole them. My meticulous husband could not have possibly misplaced something! :rolleyes:

For women, it's often a different story. Our clothes have vestigial pockets that are just there for appearances...unless we opt to wear the dreaded "mom jeans" that make our butts look huge and dumpy even if we are skinny. I'm not skinny anymore, so I only wear those jeans when I'm working in the yard.

Even so, I can barely fit my iPhone SE comfortably into the pockets. I find myself often in the middle of chores and having to stop everything to tend to some kid initiated disaster or emergency and often just leave my stuff wherever, with my mind on what could be inducing the bloodcurdling shrieks now. :eek:

So we leave our things on various work surfaces throughout the house and the kids and grandkids borrow them and they end up far from where we remember leaving them. Yes, you can train your kids to put things back from where they borrowed them, but even the most well intentioned kids get distracted. Or you need something back before the kids get a chance to return them.

I can't of course speak for all women, but I know from looking around at my peers that I can speak for many of us. We have to stuff our iPhones and earbuds in purses. We often coordinate our purses to our clothes. Sometimes it's easy to leave a set of earbuds in one purse if we are in a hurry and then forget which purse we left it in. I did that with my neon green Beats wireless earbuds...which are so glaringly green you'd think they would be immune from loss. But they remained MIA for months. :(

Yes, our possessions are somewhere in the house...but where exactly? Not everyone is living in a minimalist modern apartment. I live in a rambling three story country house with a family for whom I am always finding lost socks, sports equipment, school supplies that can be hiding in any of a number of rooms.

I am all for personal responsibility and do my utmost to both practice and preach it. But life happens. Life is messy and chaotic at times. I would therefore not presume that everyone lives the same as I do, and in turn, presume to say their needs are inferior to mine.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PizzaBoxStyle
What is with all these absolutely nonsensical holier than thou attitudes in this thread?

Can people please just take a minute after typing their moaning, little elitist rants before hitting the 'Post Reply' button. Take some deep breaths (just like your watch will periodically advise you to do) then re-read your post. If it's something you honestly think you'd say to a stranger in person, then go ahead and hit that button, if it's not, maybe delete the message and pat yourself on the back for preventing yourself from losing some dignity and having some self control.

I like Apple products just as much as anyone here, I have owned every single iPhone model on launch day, I've owned numerous Macs, MacBooks, iPads, iPods, Apple Watches, Apple TVs etc. I love a lot of what the company does, but please people stop having some bizarre sworn allegiance to a brand (not a physical entity) that has no loyalty to yourself, and is just a business. You don't need to defend every decision they make, in fact if you honestly love the company and their products as much as you seem to think you do; then be vocal about the poor decisions as much as you sing their praises. The only way Apple will learn from any mistakes they make and improve products and policies based on consumer feedback is if you actually provide that constructive criticism, rather than just lick their posteriors regardless of the insane decisions they make.

Removing this app from the App Store is not a good business move, it's not consumer friendly and the reason given is pathetic. Don't try and defend it by acting like you're some sort of elite race who could never make a mistake or misplace/lose an item in your possession. Don't act like you're part of an elite group that Apple specifically design it's products for and anyone lower than you shouldn't buy their products. You sound ridiculous and no-one takes a word you say seriously.

People lose products, small little airpods, larger more expensive iPhones, even iPads. Anyone can be in a rush and leave a bag at home containing some of their items without remembering, you could easily be distracted with much more important matters and leave an item on a table. You could have the responsibility of children who misplace items for you without you even knowing.

"If you can lose an $800+ phone you shouldn't own it" if we all lived by that mantra we should extend the same mindset to everything in life, don't drive expensive cars because you could crash it, don't play sports because you could injure yourself etc etc. Why not just sit at home wrapped in bubble wrap until you die?

This app was a great idea, I have no plans on losing one of my airpods but I'll be ever so grateful of having this option if I did ever lose one! It doesn't mean I don't look after my products, mistakes happen, they're a part of life. If you think you're absolutely perfect, I can already point out a flaw in your person, and it's a sense of self entitlement, an inability to measure yourself on a realistic scale and just a real bitterness to your personality that you feel you need to look down on people.

However the worst comment was the one about how (and I'm paraphrasing here) Apple owners shouldn't lose things or need apps like this, that's what Android owners would do. Seriously, what is this? Some modern form of apartheid? Based on tech purchases? I worry about the human race sometimes, we can make tiny little wireless and individual ear phones, but we still can't just have a tiny modicum of decency and tolerance towards others.
 
Last edited:
seems they should have a find mode where all earpods paired with the device whistle when you press a button. I am sure you would be able to hear it if you are anywhere nearby.
 
seems they should have a find mode where all earpods paired with the device whistle when you press a button. I am sure you would be able to hear it if you are anywhere nearby.
Technically you can just play some loud music, really loudly and get the same result.
 
  • Like
Reactions: groovyd
Technically you can just play some loud music, really loudly and get the same result.

from https://www.apple.com/airpods/

Knows when you’re listening.
Optical sensors and motion accelerometers work with the W1 chip to automatically control the audio and engage the microphone, giving you the ability to use one or both AirPods. They also enable AirPods to play sound as soon as they’re in your ears.
 
from https://www.apple.com/airpods/

Knows when you’re listening.
Optical sensors and motion accelerometers work with the W1 chip to automatically control the audio and engage the microphone, giving you the ability to use one or both AirPods. They also enable AirPods to play sound as soon as they’re in your ears.

Good point, it would have to override the built-in sensors. I stand corrected. Wonder if Apple allows access to that via the API?
 
  • Like
Reactions: 5105973
They also enable AirPods to play sound as soon as they’re in your ears.

Yes, they will start and pause, but they won't prevent you from playing sounds through them even when out of the ears. Try it, it works. The Glass alert tone seems quite piercing and suitable for finding a lost AirPod.
 
Removed?! Wow, way to screw over a small developer making money with a cool app. This is some 90s-Microsoft-level injustice.

A few years ago I found a REALLY old article or blog post that outlined that 90s-Microsoft-level injustice you mentioned. The writer illustrated it all by making a comparison between developers developing against Win32, to the sharecroppers of the early 20th century. I think they went on to then say something about how the web and AJAX (gives you an idea of the date of this article) were promising because it allowed developers to put all of their business logic on the server and go cross platform, escaping the horrible possibility that MS could steal your idea and implement it better using private or hidden API calls and system priviledges.

Man, if only I could find that article again... it seems like we're right back to where we were... only, worse?
 
800€ is $800+

I am not questioning the need for a Find my Phone app, I'm questioning how many people use it because they misplaced their phone somewhere in their home and if that use could be replaced by trying to be a bit more careful with ones 800€ possessions.
I'm young and have razor sharp memory too. However, I also know that apps to find devices are just good customer service. They should use it to find a misplaced phone. Even people with great memory misplace things. People make mistakes all the time. Yes they will probably agree that they should be more careful. However, things happen and you sometimes aren't. You aren't going to be perfect 100% of the time. It's a user experience thing to be able to find your iPhone or other devices when you misplace them. I don't see how that is wrong or that people are less than just because they misplace something.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 5105973
Happened to me, I just put the one bud in the case and played music really loudly through the lost bud. I found it in no time! Also taught the trick to a friend and worked for him too!
 
  • Like
Reactions: 5105973
They did give a reason. But it's pretty pathetic:

"Apple did not like the ‘concept’ of people finding their Airpods and deemed it ‘not appropriate for the App Store’."
Apple didn't say that, the creator of the app did. Apple hasn't commented on the reason.

My god this place is a dumpster fire. Apple won't create a 'find my AirPods app' because they want you to loose them and have to buy another pair? Do people realize how ridiculous they sound? And once again I'll bet most of the people complaining about this don't even own AirPods and have no intention of buying them. :rolleyes:
 
Maybe. But that is not the reason apple gave.

In fact if that were the reason, it could be easily fixed and re-released. But that isn't happening either.

We don't know Apple's reason. We only have the developer's version of events. The developer didn't mention the copyright violation which is pretty evident from the screen captures. Maybe the developer is embarrassed by being caught, and is playing for sympathy... Big mean corporation picking on innocent little developer.
 
Apple didn't say that, the creator of the app did. Apple hasn't commented on the reason.

My god this place is a dumpster fire. Apple won't create a 'find my AirPods app' because they want you to loose them and have to buy another pair? Do people realize how ridiculous they sound? And once again I'll bet most of the people complaining about this don't even own AirPods and have no intention of buying them. :rolleyes:
I actually think Apple is right in its assessment. However I think their communication is whats wrong here.
 
I actually think Apple is right in its assessment. However I think their communication is whats wrong here.
What communication? Once again you have a dev doing something that any idiot can see would get their app removed from the AppStore and then counting on rumor sites and the tech press to make Apple out to be the bad guy....to the point where people are actually saying Apple wants customers to lose their AirPods so they have to buy another pair. Seriously?!? I don't see anyone saying Bragi or Samsung designed wireless earbuds for the purpose of people losing them so they have to buy another pair. And both their offerings are smaller than AirPods. The outrage over this is stupid.
 
What communication? Once again you have a dev doing something that any idiot can see would get their app removed from the AppStore and then counting on rumor sites and the tech press to make Apple out to be the bad guy....to the point where people are actually saying Apple wants customers to lose their AirPods so they have to buy another pair. Seriously?!? I don't see anyone saying Bragi or Samsung designed wireless earbuds for the purpose of people losing them so they have to buy another pair. And both their offerings are smaller than AirPods. The outrage over this is stupid.
You have a good point.
 
Just play loud music on them?
Lol!

I'd leave it at that, but short posts like "lol" risk getting modded for violating posting rules due to brevity and not meaningfully contributing to the thread, so I'd add the additional comment that in addition to thinking your comment is humorous, it's also wryly indirectly indicative of the AirPods' ability to project satisfactory audio at a substantial sound pressure levels. Well done.
 
use an iOS device that's already been paired with the AirPods to begin searching for the missing headphone.​

I think I have found the reason apple don't like the concept.

This quote from the macrumors article is incorrect. I unpaired my airpods to see if the app would still work with the airpods and discovered that it does.

And that's bad. It is a security issue.

It means the app could assist a thief to find somebody else's airpods.

So I can see why apple may deem selling apps on thier app store to assist thieves to be inappropriate.

Until I did this experiment I assumed the airpods had to be paired in order for the app to work. But they don't.

So although I am annoyed whenever there is a loss of functionality, such as the banning of this app, nevertheless security comes first. And until someone makes an airpod finder app which ONLY works if the airpods are paired, then it is probably better that such an app not be available on the app store.

The criticism of apple in this thread would be mild compared to criticism resulting from airpods stolen by a thief who was able to do it by using an app provided by apple on their app store.
 
Last edited:
Update: Finder for AirPods has been removed from the App Store by Apple. According to the creator of the app, Apple reportedly did not like the idea of people locating their AirPods and thus the app was deemed "not appropriate for the App Store."

Selling replacements for lost earpods is going to be a major revenue source for Apple. It's projected to surpass the mac division by 2018. We can't have anything interfere with that.
 
I think I have found the reason apple don't like the concept.

This quote from the macrumors article is incorrect. I unpaired my airpods to see if the app would still work with the airpods and discovered that it does.

And that's bad. It is a security issue.

It means the app could assist a thief to find somebody else's airpods.

So I can see why apple may deem selling apps on thier app store to assist thieves to be inappropriate.

Until I did this experiment I assumed the airpods had to be paired in order for the app to work. But they don't.

So although I am annoyed whenever there is a loss of functionality, such as the banning of this app, nevertheless security comes first. And until someone makes an airpod finder app which ONLY works if the airpods are paired, then it is probably better that such an app not be available on the app store.

The criticism of apple in this thread would be mild compared to criticism resulting from airpods stolen by a thief who was able to do it by using an app provided by apple on their app store.

Interesting. If that's true, then yes, a perfectly valid reason. Someone else wrote "any idiot could see this app would be banned", which makes no sense, as it was initially approved.
 
Selling replacements for lost earpods is going to be a major revenue source for Apple. It's projected to surpass the mac division by 2018. We can't have anything interfere with that.
If this was an attempt at wit you failed.
 
A few years ago I found a REALLY old article or blog post that outlined that 90s-Microsoft-level injustice you mentioned. The writer illustrated it all by making a comparison between developers developing against Win32, to the sharecroppers of the early 20th century. I think they went on to then say something about how the web and AJAX (gives you an idea of the date of this article) were promising because it allowed developers to put all of their business logic on the server and go cross platform, escaping the horrible possibility that MS could steal your idea and implement it better using private or hidden API calls and system priviledges.

Man, if only I could find that article again... it seems like we're right back to where we were... only, worse?
Sounds about right. If only the web were truly safe on the front-end too. Back then, MSFT was deliberately breaking standards with Internet Explorer to coax devs into making "IE only" sites. Now, I've been encountering some "Google Chrome only" sites like Megaupload for whatever reason, but it's nowhere near as bad as it was with IE around 2002 (and probably earlier, but I didn't use the web back then).
 
  • Like
Reactions: PizzaBoxStyle
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.