Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
I really liked this app but lately development seem to have been slow on it and now this.
Is it time to change? Any recommendations ?
 
More secure...than what?
A windows box? sure, maybe.
A hardened Linux or BSD machine? No, chance.
OS X doesn't even ship with its firewall switched on and it's UNIX/GNU packages are woefully out of date.
It's not really fair to compare a standard OS X setup with anything hardened.

Here are some links relating to hardening of OS X (albeit a bit old, did a quick search to find them):

https://techwiki.uwm.edu/display/SecOfficeStandGuide/Mac+Hardening+Guidelines

https://isc.sans.edu/forums/diary/The+Ultimate+OS+X+Hardening+Guide+Collection/12616/

what can I do to prevent such virus/malware/ransomware attacks from ever hitting my Mac?
Educate yourself, understand the risks of doing different things on the net. Check the guides posted above and apply what you think is relevant.

Always have an offline weekly or monthly backup, plus TimeMachine of course. There is always a chance you will be hit by something. Prepare for that in advance. Practice safe sex.

Condemning bittorrent because it's used by pirates is like condemning POP3 because it's used by spammers. Yeah, there's a significant number of people using the protocol for that purpose, but it's far from its only use.
Or condemning roads because robbers use them to flee. Or condemning Privacy because some people commit crime and don't tell others about it.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: dmnc and mrxak
This really has nothing at all to do with Apple.
I disagree. The optics of "the first Mac ransomware" has made this all about Apple and quite possibly may be something that affects the reputation of the Mac brand for quite awhile.

Regardless, my response was simply saying "that's not likely" to the question "what if the 'fixed' version of Transmission was hacked like the 'bad' version?"
 
to be expected when people use BitTorrent, I have zero sympathy for people who pirate stuff!

You do realise many linux distributions, and lots of open source software provide the bittorrent option, and encourage it, in order to take significant load off their servers (i.e. save on hosting costs).
 
  • Like
Reactions: mrxak
Maybe we can stop hearing some blindly preach about fast updates. Fast updates is like first ones to cross a minefield. I make it a habit to wait a few days to let others be the guinea pig.
Its's also true that through the update you might get important security fixes, so waiting might end up being counterproductive.
 
Do a lot of people with Macs download Linux?

Probably not. I do all the time. Just grabbed linuxcnc (via the mac) two nights ago to install natively on another pc. Also grabbed solus and void linux, in order to see what direction some newer distros are taking. Gotta keep an Apple exit plan handy just incase!
 
  • Like
Reactions: mrxak
Ah. I didn't think of that.
The encryption works if someone from outside try to decode your drive. But if your user run a server to serve all your HD, even if this one is encrypted, the virus / mal ware uses your user who is allowed to decrypt files to read an re encrypt them... So encrypting stuff will not help in this case. The best thing to do is avoid clicking on weird stuff and in that case, wait few weeks before doing updates...
 
  • Like
Reactions: Chazz08
I've been using transmission since July 1/14. No issues?? Does Malwarebytes work on this? Just looked, and I'm using version 2.84(14306).
 
Is it only a problem if you make use of dodgy torrent sites?

Is there any risk to people that don't go to dodgy sites or download stupid stuff?

Any risk through any safari/web type attack?
 
A quick off topic interjection. I have an older version of Mint that I run on a flash drive. I have used it to get files off of a messed up hdd. I haven't played with Linux for several years now. You're giving me the urge to try it again.

I recommend your do. I changed my mom to Mint from WinXP a few years ago, and I follow it's development and play around with in in virtual machines quite often. Windows 8.1 is the last Windows version I'm going to run. Trying to decide if I want to go full OSX (already have a MacBook for laptop), or go to Mint for my next desktop OS. The main thing that keeps me from wanting to go to OSX is I like being able to build my own PCs.
[doublepost=1457338625][/doublepost]
what can I do to prevent such virus/malware/ransomware attacks from ever hitting my Mac? do anti-virus or internet security software make any difference? such as paid software from Norton or Kaspersky... I don't mind paying for peace of mind, if they offer noticeable defence.

thanks!

There's a free version of Avira antivius for Mac.

I'd say that thing to remember most is pay attention when you're online. People go to the wrong places, or run the wrong app and catch this stuff.
 
That's worrying. You're encouraged to constantly keep your applications and OS updated, but recently that's becoming troublesome. First with Apple's silent security update disabling wired networks and now this! Worrying year for security this.

The disabling of ethernet is the first ever mistake with XProtect and certainly easy to fix. WiFi or phone tethering and you're back in business.

The ransomware issue with Transmission highlights the importance of sandboxing, the Mac App Store, and developer certificates. If Transmissions was in the Mac AppStore and sandbox'd it wouldn't be able to encrypt anything but its own data making it a rather boring bit of ransomware.
 
Apple should really introduce a feature to show certificate of a program installer, just like Windows Vista and above does when popping up UAC control window.

I'm pretty sure there is for installers - when you go to install an app, there should be a lock icon up near the top of the window. Clicking on that shows the certificate.

Granted that won't work for apps that you copy from a DMG rather than _installing_ it, which I believe is how Transmission works.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Blujelly
If only Apple had a way to prevent compromised apps from affecting the rest of the system.

Oh, wait...
 
I love the irony of this one. The majority of people who use Torrent on a Mac do so in order to steal data, now they are risking all stolen data being encrypted beyond repair. Format your drives boys and go and fill your boots with more data that you were too mean to pay for, I am sure your savings are worth the costs.

I am sure there are a few legitimate reasons to use file sharing tools on a Mac, as a videographer and coder I just can't think of any right now.
 
Last edited:
Do we now agree with Apple wanting everything sand boxed on the mac app store?
Now that this vulnerability is public you can bet that every hacker will be looking to break into servers and inject code somehow into software that people download on the mac.

There are lots of apps that contain open source components, what if those components have bad code added in as well?

I'm not sure why an app like Transmission needs root access or access beyond it's own set of files and a download area. It could operate fine being sand boxed. That would be the best protection. That's why you never hear about anything like that happening on iOS, it just cant.
 
  • Like
Reactions: orbital~debris
More secure...than what?

A windows box? sure, maybe.

A hardened Linux or BSD machine? No, chance.

OS X doesn't even ship with its firewall switched on and it's UNIX/GNU packages are woefully out of date.

I thought Apple had gotten rid of most GNU stuff.

A quick off topic interjection. I have an older version of Mint that I run on a flash drive. I have used it to get files off of a messed up hdd. I haven't played with Linux for several years now. You're giving me the urge to try it again.

Give it go it can be fun.

===

I didn't know that the MAS didn't have torrent clients. Iwas going to ask why people weren't downloading from the MAS since it's in essence simply a SW repo. I know the MAS has issues that it shouldn't but repos are pretty much always better than various websites. Good luck to those infected but please don't pay it just leads to more of this.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Osty
Apple has become so huge and popular, it was a matter of time before it became a target.

Previously the notion of someone buying a mac, involved $$$$$, while a windows machine was dirt cheap. These days you can pick up a mac for very little, and to be fair a lot of the mac community still believe they are completely safe just by owning a mac.... times change.

interesting times ahead, the one year release cycle on os x is not helping things, I wish we could go back to 2 years.
[doublepost=1457347696][/doublepost]
Do we now agree with Apple wanting everything sand boxed on the mac app store?
Now that this vulnerability is public you can bet that every hacker will be looking to break into servers and inject code somehow into software that people download on the mac.

There are lots of apps that contain open source components, what if those components have bad code added in as well?

I'm not sure why an app like Transmission needs root access or access beyond it's own set of files and a download area. It could operate fine being sand boxed. That would be the best protection. That's why you never hear about anything like that happening on iOS, it just cant.

Nope. Ill keep OS X as is, and take my chances. For me the iPad pro, was nothing more than a large iPad, and I chose the new Macbook over it.
 
Has anyone read how the official release dowloaded from the developers site included this?
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.