You haven't owned an android device before have you? You don't even have to login with your gmail account when you first set it up...Its basically the same procedure you get with a iPhone running iOS 5 or 6, cept its with your gmail account instead of your Apple ID.
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
First Reviews of Samsung Galaxy S4: Great Screen, Gimmick Features, Bad Plastic Design
- Thread starter MacRumors
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
You haven't owned an android device before have you? You don't even have to login with your gmail account when you first set it up...Its basically the same procedure you get with a iPhone running iOS 5 or 6, cept its with your gmail account instead of your Apple ID.
Or let Apple buy HTC and really cause a stir in the android world by offering an Apple Android phone to beat Samsung on its own turf
(Not going to happen but hey).....
In my ideal world, I'd love the HTC One design and screen and performance to be mixed with iOS 7 and Apple's great camera hardware & software...
Instead we get a finger print scanner on the same old iPhone and same old iOS (user apathy/boredom after 5 years of iPhone ownership) or a the inconsistent at best 4 megapixel/ultrapixel camera on the HTC.
No such thing as a perfect device I guess.
------------------
However back on topic. I think it all boils down to reviewer & geek apathy at this stage. Let me explain if I can...
The Samsung S4 has the same issue that reviewers will inevitably lambast the iPhone 5S for. A few new features and upgraded tech wrapped in almost identical clothing meaning that the reviewers are just a little bored and looking for change.
The 5S will likely suffer the same review critisms due to being near identical to iPhone 5 (if rumours are true) but with gimmicky hardware slapped on (fingerprint scanner - come on is ths some 1990's spy movie apple are now using as inspiration) and same old iOS but with more new software gimmicks that rarely work outside of USA (passbook - Siri for an entire year etc..).
The thing to remember though is that consumers love these devices regardless of their gimmicks or sometimes perceived as long in the tooth / over familiar software.
The S4 will be the main goto phone people who don't buy iPhones will go for and likewise the iPhone 5S despite all the critisms from reviewers and geeks on forums will sell an absolute load of devices beating sales records once again.
So yes whilst there is a lot of reviewer apathy / boredom out there. Don't think that it will make too much difference at the end of the day sales wise. These phones S4 & 5S will sell by the bucketload regardless of the inevitable critics and critism of the devices.
Last edited:
That was your phone. But it is undeniable that you have more experience than I do; I have never set up an Android
Then why would you make the comment "Google wants you to sign up with a gazillion accounts when you first turn it on."
That's just pure FUD.
Yup, I said that in an earlier post mate
Common dude. Then don't bash on stuff that you don't really know about...its kinda what separates us from fandroids that are out there bashing the hell out of Apple, without knowing what they're talking bout yeah?
All four reviews complain about the plastic design. And if you don't have time to read the reviews, maybe you should wait until you do before accusing MR of dishonesty.
All things D: "the plastic body felt a bit insubstantial to me"
Gizmodo: "a slippery, finger-print-trapping plastic back that looks like it belongs on a far more downmarket phone."
Engadget: " If you were a critic of the GS3's plastic construction, you'll be disappointed with its successor -- the company's continuing its long-standing tradition of keeping metal out of the assembly lines, building the frame, back cover and faux-chrome edges with polycarbonate. It's a similar -- though lower-grade and not machined -- type of plastic you'd enjoy on flagships like the Nokia Lumia 920 or even the HTC One X+, so it's nothing out of the ordinary for Samsung."
The verge: "Where Apple and HTC have both made beautiful, well-made, high-quality phones, the GS4 has Samsung back in the land of cheap, plasticky handsets...I don't like holding this phone, and I can't overstate how much that informs the experience of using it. It makes an awful first impression, slippery and slimy and simply unpleasant in your hand. My white review unit is completely smooth and glossy, with a subtle checkered pattern that looks textured but is neither grippy nor textured anywhere on its body. Even the silver band around the sides, which is obviously supposed to look like metal, is plastic. Everyone I showed the GS4 to frowned and wrinkled their nose as if it smelled bad, before rubbing their fingers on the back of the phone and then handing it back to me that's the opposite of the standard reaction to HTCs One, which everyone wants to ogle and hold. That's going to be a huge problem for Samsung, because the GS4 and One are likely to be next to each other on store shelves, and at least on first impression there's absolutely no contest between the two."
I didn't accuse MR of dishonesty. I asked a question. I can see how you can confuse the two
You talk about implying that all articles say "bad plastic design" when only one does...which MR didn't do. And I don't really understand asking what articles say when they are right there for you to click on. If you don't have time to read them all in full, it took just seconds to open all four and search for "plastic" - went right to what you were asking about.
The HTC One has a much nicer design. Too bad the camera sucks on it. The best overall phone still seems to be the iPhone.
It has just occurred to me that on the current release schedule, by late 2015 Apple and Samsung's flagship phones will be the 6S and S6.
No scope for consumer confusion there.
No scope for consumer confusion there.
In this case it seems like the problem isn't just that it's plastic, it's poorly done plastic. I don't mind plastic either, but only when it's done right.
Well that is a fair point, plastic can be good or bad. No excuse to do it badly on a flagship product like this.
People should frist see qhat the fingerprint scanner can do, and then comment on it. Up to now, it just looks ridiculous to comment on rumours.
So it's pretty much a slightly updated S3 with better hardware inside but still using the same cheap plastic exterior. HTC One seems to be the better option for those who prefer Android. Prett sure the S4 will sell more though.
Favorite part from the quoted articles/reviews
...the part about the iPhone 5 being "nearly a year old".
That's pretty loose, isn't it? It's only seven months old! I'd say 10 months + is the minimum for "nearly a year".
...the part about the iPhone 5 being "nearly a year old".
That's pretty loose, isn't it? It's only seven months old! I'd say 10 months + is the minimum for "nearly a year".
too bad the One suffers from mediocre battery life just like it's predecessor the One X.
Which is why I asked. In turn - instead of insinuating ill-will - you could have just answered the question by saying "yes - the other review mention the plastic design as well."
See how that works?
Has the author of this article actually seen an S4? Or are they just taking other peoples opinions and using them to determine their own view of the S4?
If thy have had personal experience of the S4 why not just voice their own concerns.
Arn, this is piss poor journalism.
If thy have had personal experience of the S4 why not just voice their own concerns.
Arn, this is piss poor journalism.
To me the S4 looks like a brilliant phone. Great screen, great camera, snappy etc. I also think the HTC One is stunning, and could very well be my next phone.
Unless Apple steps it up, one of these two phones will be my next smartphone (and first Android).
The competition has me excited for the future of smartphones!
Unless Apple steps it up, one of these two phones will be my next smartphone (and first Android).
The competition has me excited for the future of smartphones!
