Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
AT&T already lost me as a customer. Too bad. I pay only $5 more then what I paid at AT&T over at T-Mobile and got unlimited data with no throttling for 2 lines instead of one and I added my iPad too. Way cheaper then AT&T and service works just as well here.
 
I want to be compensated for the undue stress throttling (or the threat of)has place on my life.

I have paid for unlimited and if at any time I did not receive unlimited then ATT is in breach and I want to be compensated.

I'll settle for $1000 or a free phone of my choosing at my next upgrade and $500.
 
Not this old argument again...
You are paying for unlimited data, not unlimited speeds.
Your plan is not data capped at all.

This is why I switched to T-Mobile.
They still offer an actual unlimited data plan with NO speed reductions.
Sure it's $30 a month on top of my base family plan rate, but it is unlimited in every way that matters. I even get 5GB of tethering per month with it.

EXACTLY! You are getting unlimited data. They are allowing folks to keep the plan but they are not allowing folks to use it for 10TB a month at the expense of everyone else. So I just say, cancel the plan and make the leeches find a new one.
 
I have no problem being throttled if I'm using excessive amounts of data (which is not 2, 5, or even 10 gigs) but don't slow my speed down so much that I can't even send a MMS message. Throttled speeds for me have been .01 Mbps upload and download. That's as good as having data turned off.

Unlimited means unlimited. Data isn't going to run out, it doesn't need to be conserved.
 
If T-Mobile service wasn't so bad id switch. I took my att 6+ throttled and my T-Mobile iPad mini on vacation the Ipad was good for pandora streaming since t mobile offers free music streaming but I can't even count on all fingers and toes how many times it dropped to no service edge or gprs and the music stopped. They need to get their act together and I'll gladly pay them for true unlimited on my phone
 
I want to be compensated for the undue stress throttling (or the threat of)has place on my life.

I have paid for unlimited and if at any time I did not receive unlimited then ATT is in breach and I want to be compensated.

I'll settle for $1000 or a free phone of my choosing at my next upgrade and $500.

Seems extreme.

Personally I'd be happy if ATT is no longer allowed to throttle unlimited plans.
 
The problem is that the grandfathered plans are protected by law, at least in California and it may be a nationwide thing.

Basically they are not allowed to change your plan without your express permission.

Sorry, but AT&T can certainly cancel the plan and not allow it. They just likely need to provide a legal notice and a date.
 
If T-Mobile service wasn't so bad id switch. I took my att 6+ throttled and my T-Mobile iPad mini on vacation the Ipad was good for pandora streaming since t mobile offers free music streaming but I can't even count on all fingers and toes how many times it dropped to no service edge or gprs and the music stopped. They need to get their act together and I'll gladly pay them for true unlimited on my phone
Agreed... this is where T-Mobile falls short.
Coverage outside of larger cities is weak.
Fortunately I've only had to suffer through EDGE service with them on one trip. Every where else has been decent.
 
I have unlimited, been throttled almost every month about 2/3 the way through, and never been notified by text once. Thanks AT&T
 
Awesome!! Maybe this ends in AT&T giving us grandfathered in the plan real unlimited data without throttling.

I think they will cancel the plan and let you buy an unlimited plan or they could provided tiered unlimited. If you think they will just let you have unthrottled data at $30 a month, you are out of your mind. Data speeds in 2007 would allow someone to use maybe 4-5GB a month at unlimited. Nowadays on AT&T LTE, you can use 10-20TB. They have BY FAR the fastest network and can't jeopardize it for a few.

Now that the leeches have pushed this issue, they will loose the unlimited plan at the grandfathered rate. There is no legal way to force a carrier to offer a service at a specific rate.

Finally this will be over..

----------

I want to be compensated for the undue stress throttling (or the threat of)has place on my life.

I have paid for unlimited and if at any time I did not receive unlimited then ATT is in breach and I want to be compensated.

I'll settle for $1000 or a free phone of my choosing at my next upgrade and $500.

LOL, I hope you are being sarcastic. This is the entitlement attitude that has carried this issue for years.
 
Last edited:
To continue and beat to death the unlimited breadsticks analogy, I see it as the restaurant offers unlimited breadsticks 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. Customers who want this unlimited breadsticks have to pay a little bit more than those who don't want to eat that much.

Some times during the day the restaurant is very busy, and some times it may only have a few customers. But for the most part the restaurant has enough servers to serve breadsticks as fast as each customer can consume them--although parts of the day the servers can barely keep up, and sometimes they are a little short staffed.

Customers love the unlimited breadsticks. In fact there are customers who come in and order like 25 breadsticks each day--after all, they are paying a bit more for the privilege of unlimited breadsticks, so why not take advantage of it?

So, the restaurant realizes that their breadsticks are real popular and they love all the business they are getting, but they really don't want to keep so many servers on staff--or add servers to account for the customer demand. The restaurant decides that, once a particular customer has ordered 500 breadsticks in any given month the servers are directed to slow down the delivery of breadsticks to that customer so that the customer is only able to get one or two a day. For those customers who eat 25 breadsticks a day they notice their servers start getting real slow around the 20th day of the month--in fact, for the last 10 days of every month service really sucks!

Now, the restaurant's original purpose for implementing the plan was to reign in the amount of money it's paying for its servers, but the restriction of breadsticks to these particular customers is carried out regardless of the time of day or how busy the restaurant is. It doesn't matter whether they have plenty of servers to serve a particular customer, if that customer has already eaten 500 breadsticks that month, service to them needs to slow down.

So, if one does the math, for those customers who normally eat 25 breadsticks a day and who pay a bit more for the privilege to do so, if the policy was truly unlimited they would be able to eat 750 breadsticks a month. But, once the restaurant implemented the new restriction (4 years after it started offering the promotion) those customers are now only allowed to eat 520.

It seems then that the number of breadsticks the customer is allowed to eat, and the speed by which the breadstricts are served to these customers are restricted--so, is that really unlimited? I don't think so, but I'm fully aware and respect those who believe otherwise.

Z
 
Could someone explain why AT&T grandfathers some plans? Are they legally obligated to do so? What is preventing them from simply forcing anyone who upgrades a phone to use one of the new data plans?

Nothing is forcing them to keep us on Unlimited plans when we upgrade. They have just chosen to do so.


Until......this.....situation. If this ends up being a huge deal they probably will force unlimited data plan customers off of them the next time we upgrade.
 
That's entirely true. What irks me is the fact that they will throttle an "unlimited" user after 5GB because they claim it puts a strain on the network. However, they'll sell you a 100GB/mo data plan that will not be throttled at all.

its about time perhaps we should take this time to remember the definition of the term UNLIMITED

un·lim·it·ed
ˌənˈlimidəd/
adjective
not limited or restricted in terms of number, quantity, or extent.

Both of these are outstanding insights!

Bryan
 
My husband called AT&T about our bill that was wrong.We have had the unlimited plan for years and was grandfathered in and we plan to keep it,she told him I would have unlimited Data but when I looked at it they had tricked him I only had 2 gb.this is not right to be treated like this! Our contract is not up until Nov. I am a very unhappy AT&T customber !!!
 
If only 3% of customers are affected. Why even bother throttling. Waste of time for AT&T and the customer
 
its about time perhaps we should take this time to remember the definition of the term UNLIMITED

un·lim·it·ed
ˌənˈlimidəd/
adjective
not limited or restricted in terms of number, quantity, or extent.
You are being offered unlimited DATA, not unlimited data speeds.
The amount of data you can use is not set.
The rate at which you can consume the data however, is restricted and clearly stated in the agreement.
 
I want to be compensated for the undue stress throttling (or the threat of)has place on my life.

I have paid for unlimited and if at any time I did not receive unlimited then ATT is in breach and I want to be compensated.

I'll settle for $1000 or a free phone of my choosing at my next upgrade and $500.

Wow. If you're not joking then just wow. I'm sad to say this is a symptom of the entitlement society we now live in.
 
"We have been completely transparent with customers since the very beginning. We informed all unlimited data-plan customers via bill notices and anational press release that resulted in nearly 2,000 news stories, well before the program was implemented. In addition, this program has affected only about 3% of our customers, and before any customer is affected, they are also notified by text message."


Thats B.S ATT I have never Received a text for when i was about to be trotted
 
My husband called AT&T about our bill that was wrong.We have had the unlimited plan for years and was grandfathered in and we plan to keep it,she told him I would have unlimited Data but when I looked at it they had tricked him I only had 2 gb.this is not right to be treated like this! Our contract is not up until Nov. I am a very unhappy AT&T customber !!!

Good thing it's almost November. T-minus-4.
 
Thats B.S ATT I have never Received a text for when i was about to be trotted
I was probably notified the first time they throttled me. And that was a few years back. Have been throttled plenty of times since but no notification each time.

I'll be fine if AT&T is forced to stop throttling and nothing more. It would be nice to offer an optional tethering option like Verizon (can be data capped if they want) or build it into the regular unlimited plan like T-Mobile. For me it would be just in case kind of deal for power outages and such so if they don't offer it I won't complain.
 
Thats B.S ATT I have never Received a text for when i was about to be trotted

Of course you didn't. That would be too inconvenient for AT&T to actually have texted you. I guess most others got their text messages but you didn't. Okay.

Would you have had a different attitude if you "did receive" your text message? LOL, I love these threads... People just want it all for free.
 
Last edited:
All this talk about breadsticks is giving me a hankerin' for the Olive Garden.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.