To not clutter up the Mario Galaxy thread, what do you folk think the GOTY will be? Or what the shortlist would be? I'd put my money on- Orange Box, though I'm not sure where GOTY stands for compilations. Mario Galaxy, the highest rated game this gen. Bioshock, a massive hit with players. Metacritic shows it's currently 2nd of next gen games. Halo 3, the press seems to love it. And they govern all.