I think they are trying to get extra sales instead of warrantying products. The manager apologized to me for a THIRD TIME. I personally called him today after receiving my new AirPort Extreme Wireless Base Station.
According to the "Genius" they do NOT service the AirPort Extreme Wireless Base Station.
I have had several bad experiences at this store. I fear they are not looking out for customers and trying to pad their own pockets by selling discounted items instead of warrantying them as required.
BTW, I had to fight to get a new Logic Board in my MBP v 2,2. And they just gave me a there's no problem with your SuperDrive even though it doesn't work half the time; cause it worked then.
Although, to be fair, the "Genius" told me my battery was "BAD" and I am assuming that means I do not have to PAY for a new one. We will see when I pick it up on Monday. As they are keeping it til then. Thank GOD I bought the new MB $1599 Aluminum. Otherwise I would be typing this from my iPhone.
One last BTW, the "Genius" that replaced my AirPort Extreme today asked if I use a Windows computer with it... I said yep... he started to say something, and I blerted out "IN BOOT CAMP!" Not another word was asked of me. HA HA.
Your post seems a bit extreme. If all the geniuses said it wouldn't be covered because it wasn't on the same receipt, it seems to me they were not trained properly. They made an error.
One of the Assistant Managers said it was a lesson learned for him too. Just beware before doing business or expecting good service there. I will go back to the store, but every time I go there, I will expect them to be disingenuous and not looking out for my interests. Even when I paid $349 for them to cover my products. THERE IS NO EXCUSE! You must be one of them. Ha ha ha.
The $350 of AppleCare is meant for them to look out for customer just like an insurance policy. They need to know that they accept liability and not try to sell me something I bought the right to when I bought the AppleCare for $349!
One last thing.
A few of the salespeople are really good and polite. But three out of five are really good. Is that good enough? Or do the two duds ruin the Apple Store's reputation and the Apple Experience for the customers.
But, I have also had one treat me like crap when I was spending $1599 on a new MB. I warned him ahead of time about the battery cover issue. The guy told me that it doesn't affect it at all and no more dirt gets in even if could see the battery. In addition he said he would gladly buy the one with a bad battery cover anyways for FULL PRICE. Guy could not admit that three out of six on display had a problem. Later told me not to buy the MB if I thought there was a problem with the battery cover. I asked to work with someone else and he walked away and let me stand there for fifteen minutes and I had to go find my own help. Luckily the manager got involved. Let me open the case, and my MB was fine and did not have the battery cover problem.
I bought a headset for my iPhone which I later returned without a problem. Was nothing but static. Also bought software and a case one day and the guy helped me choose the right software for what I wanted to do. Excellent for certain.
I NEVER HAD A PROBLEM AT THE BILTMORE OR CHANDLER STORES. Those people were always EXCELLENT and actually acted like they cared about me as a customer. In fact, when I bought the AirPort Extreme Base Station it was at the Biltmore store. The salesperson was excellent and informed me that the AppleCare from my MBP covered it if I used the MBP with the AirPort Extreme base station.
The manager and some of the staff are from the Biltmore store, so I will admit this may be just isolated incidents. However, being a corporation, I think we should all beware of the incidents that happen to others, like me, to ensure they do not happen to you.
All I want is for people to be 100% certain there product is NOT covered by AppleCare before accepting the Genius's discounted product. That is a problem.