Google Announces Major Push Into NFC Payments With Google Wallet

Don't really know how I feel about this. Yes, it will increase convenience, but it will also spawn a new kind of thief - one who puts an NFC receiver in his pocket, brushes up against your pocket with your cell phone in it, and steals your money without having to pickpocket you. A wireless robber.

Also, if you lose your phone like I often do, does that mean that people who pick it up can use it as a limitless credit card? Sounds scary.

this is the cool part you will have to put in a pin code for every transaction. so instead of giving the person at starbucks your iphone starbucks card app or a credit card you will have to open the NFC app, wait for it to sync with the POS machine, put in code, wait
 
It just seems that to get an offer, you don't need to be logged in to your wallet. One more step to the Minority Report future.
 
Great so when my phone dies I'm completely screwed.

That's what I was thinking. Plus, if you lose your phone, how would you call to cancel transactions on your phone? At least if I lose my wallet I still have my phone. There are some disadvantages to having your entire life stored on a single device.

and there will be no fees on transactions to top up the card until at least the end of 2011

... and after that, you will be shafted.
 
Wirelessly posted (Mozilla/5.0 (iPhone; U; CPU iPhone OS 4_3_3 like Mac OS X; en-us) AppleWebKit/533.17.9 (KHTML, like Gecko) Version/5.0.2 Mobile/8J2 Safari/6533.18.5)

Hurry Apple. Google will screw this up. And Visa and MC have sat idle for years while fraud has grown. They deserve to b toppled.

You have that right and Apple. Well Steve, it has been said, is waiting for people to screw this up and the iPhone NFC will "do it right." Those with the NFC, smartphone-based transaction IP was kicked to the curb in Cupertino after the "social trails."

There supposedly was a few hired models with RFID chips embedded in jewelry and fingernails and storing Facebook URLs going to clubs and bars for the past few months over select parts of the bay. Results were too "social freak" and the technology is considered immature for mainstream.

It was inevitable that Google is going to give it a try. If they don't take it, I'm sure Microsoft would do anything to get a leg up.
 
Great so when my phone dies I'm completely screwed.

Haha, yeah if your phone is busted you can't get a new one because your wallet is inside of your phone :D

Don't really know how I feel about this. Yes, it will increase convenience, but it will also spawn a new kind of thief - one who puts an NFC receiver in his pocket, brushes up against your pocket with your cell phone in it, and steals your money without having to pickpocket you. A wireless robber.

Also, if you lose your phone like I often do, does that mean that people who pick it up can use it as a limitless credit card? Sounds scary.

I saw in the presentation that the NFC chip is only active when the screen is on, so they would have to do it while you are using the phone.
 
Don't really know how I feel about this. Yes, it will increase convenience, but it will also spawn a new kind of thief - one who puts an NFC receiver in his pocket, brushes up against your pocket with your cell phone in it, and steals your money without having to pickpocket you. A wireless robber.

Also, if you lose your phone like I often do, does that mean that people who pick it up can use it as a limitless credit card? Sounds scary.

They had mentioned that NFC chip is not powered if the display is turned off, and the display has to be unlocked for NFC to work.
 
New malware target

..."Google Wallet will be able to store users' credit card, loyalty card, and gift card information electronically"...

I expect a huge bump in the number of apps on the droid market. Now there's new data to harvest.
 
If I lost my phone, how quickly can I remotely disable this service? Also, most vendors still lack NFC capabilities and I would still need to keep plastic around if I wanted to pay with credit.

I like the idea a lot, though.

In the Q/A session, they mentioned "If you lose your phone, a bad guy can't pull your card information off it -- even if they've got the PIN."

That's from thisismynext.com
 
Unless the card companies do something to sort small retailers out this wont change a thing in the UK, most wont accept a card payment below £10 or they charge a fee for the low transaction, last week a garrage tolb me that any transaction below £10 gets a £1.50 charge :eek:, i just walked out and kleft my stuff on the counter, how is this going to change with NF???, the handler is still going to charge the shop of the transaction.

unless they drop fees for low value transactions it wont change a thing in the uk.
 
This is great as long as we can do one thing.

Can we transfer money between phones?
That way we won't need cash really, if I can come round your home and you can sell me your old TV, and I can move $500 from my phone onto your phone then it's a winner.

Paypal? :)
 
Don't really know how I feel about this. Yes, it will increase convenience, but it will also spawn a new kind of thief - one who puts an NFC receiver in his pocket, brushes up against your pocket with your cell phone in it, and steals your money without having to pickpocket you. A wireless robber.

A co-worker already had this happen with his credit card that has the built in chip- a number of his neighbors got their information stolen from a van that drove through the neighborhood at night and gathered data from cards (anyone have an American Express Blue), while people slept.

This is only going to make identity theft much much easier.

Stupid idea on behalf of Google and if Apple does it, same with them, unless they can absolutely positively guarantee all the information is secure and protected.
 
Great so when my phone dies I'm completely screwed.

I suspect any vendor accepting NFC payment would have a universal cable allowing you to give your dead phone just enough juice to make the transaction.

If you already need to take your phone out, launch the app, enter your PIN and accept the transaction, then it shouldn't be that much of an effort to plug your phone in at their terminal in case your battery is dead.
 
Apple-Google love returns? I love all things i, but Google really knocked it out of the park with this one. Gift card, deal, coupon, loyalty card and payment options in one. Not just one app, but one tap.

C'mon Steve, just admit defeat on this one and put it in iPhone 4GS/5
 
A co-worker already had this happen with his credit card that has the built in chip- a number of his neighbors got their information stolen from a van that drove through the neighborhood at night and gathered data from cards (anyone have an American Express Blue), while people slept.

This is only going to make identity theft much much easier.

Stupid idea on behalf of Google and if Apple does it, same with them, unless they can absolutely positively guarantee all the information is secure and protected.

Can you explain me how can it be done when NFC has a reach of moreless 25-30 cm?
 
Pay attention here. This is where you'll get pinched. Can you say convenience fee? Expect to see bank fees, credit card fees and carrier fees attached to these NFC purchases in the future. Everyone is going to want a piece of that pie!

You are going to regret all the additional charges. This is no Freebee folks.
 
Nice idea in theory, but I'm going to need my wallet anyways for my drivers license, school ID, etc. so this really isn't going to save me from having to grab it too.
 
Apple-Google love returns? I love all things i, but Google really knocked it out of the park with this one. Gift card, deal, coupon, loyalty card and payment options in one. Not just one app, but one tap.

Honestly, this is the LAST THING any sane and aware person should want.

Google fooled some people with bribes, that's clear and sad at the same time.
 
LOL, I can picture Google looking at what you've been buying, and then targeting ads at you for the related products.
 
Last edited:
Agreed. I especially like the point where they knew exactly where you are at all times. I would be ok if there was NFC from say a stand and your phone picked up on it, but then I would be walking around with my phone on all the time looking at that instead of where i was going. If it used location based stuff via cell towers like everything does today, I say i'll pass.

As for the theft part, I think this would help curve it towards a positive (as in good) direction. Unlike the PayPass cards implemented now, it is not activated until POS or when you tell it to turn on. The ones right now embedded in your wallet are always on.

What? I'm still trying to figure out why you would be looking at your phone all the time because of an NFC payment system.
 
Unless the card companies do something to sort small retailers out this wont change a thing in the UK, most wont accept a card payment below £10 or they charge a fee for the low transaction, last week a garrage tolb me that any transaction below £10 gets a £1.50 charge :eek:, i just walked out and kleft my stuff on the counter, how is this going to change with NF???, the handler is still going to charge the shop of the transaction.

unless they drop fees for low value transactions it wont change a thing in the uk.

Just FYI, the card agreement that vendors sign with the card companies in the US specifically rules this sort of behavior out. If you take Visa (for example), there's no minimum charge amount that you can charge.

But yes, many vendors have signs up that request minimum payment levels, but if a rep from Visa or Mastercard would walk in an see that sign, the vendor could lose their ability to take CCs altogether.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.
Back
Top