Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
I like my gadgets and new tech from any brand, but this has to be the worst design flop ever.

Who even needs a folding phone?

except:
pass
Those that want the screen space of a small tablet, yet want to carry it like and use it like a phone?

I actually like the flip concept of folding phones better and have one of the recent motorola razr. Fits in smaller pockets and doesn't take up near as much space and the screen is protected as well.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: 5105973
Pockets are thin and broad, modern smartphones are thin and broad, they do a good job of fitting in pockets. Things that are small but thick stand out like a sore thumb and are awkward to slide in and out of a pocket. Folding phones don’t fold like paper, they’re considerably thicker when folded. Generally, I have no issue with fitting my phone in my pocket, even on my jeans pockets, but I would have more of an issue hauling an Altoids tin around.

Again, I suggested implementation is key. So, if it's thick, it's a non-starter.

It works for you, but I'm guessing many would not be able to sit down comfortably with an XR in the front pocket of a pair of jeans? Nor would women like to carry a large slab vs say an easier to carry makeup-like compact phone.

My point is not to discount the possible benefits of a foldable phone. Why dismiss it before you try it? Without innovation, we'd still be using iPhones with 3.5" displays.
 
Honest question. Who is actually asking for folding phones?
I like the Samsung one that looks like my old Nintendo Gameboy clamshell. But realistically, it wouldn’t survive my pocket lint, which is why I don’t buy one. Maybe in a few years if they make these things more durable and get the costs down a bit, I’ll get one. Until then, I’m enjoying my iPhone mini.

I do think there’s merit in having a device that folds down to a nice pocket size but can unfold to offer a more generous display.

Now this Google one, it’s not exactly pocket friendly when folded, so I personally have no interest in it. I am not a big user of tablets. So I don’t need one that folds down to the size of an especially large phablet. But some road warriors might have an appreciation for it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SteveJUAE
Well Samsung has supposedly sold at least 400,0000-500,000 of them so obviously those people.

I love people who think what they want or don’t want represents everyone. There is obviously a market for these as they keep being made, yet this same inane question is being asked. These are very obviously for people that want a large screen in a smaller package. I’m not sure why this is so hard for people to comprehend.

Some of you think it’s a stupid idea, we get it. But acting like you don’t comprehend it’s purpose or who would want it is disingenuous at best.

This. Samsung is ramping up for 6-7 million this time around, that's getting close to Note sales. Granted it's still a niche product, and may always be a niche product like the Note series, but still enough to garner a profit and also advance a stale market.

What really bothers me are the Darwin award winners who espouse the same tired "This is a solution in search of a problem" If they put just a bit of thought into such a short sighted answer they would see that the problem is clear; people like larger screens but larger screens are less portable. There, that wasn't particularly difficult was it? For my personal use this frees me from having to stick my iPad mini into my back pocket, now I only have to carry around one device, sync one device, charge one device, etc., and it's footprint is very similar to a traditional smartphone.

Now with that said we have to look at the paradigm as a whole, and not just lump all these phones as "foldables" The foldable phone is only one way to achieve the desired results, that of a larger screen that can be made smaller and thus more portable. One other option that is promising are rollable displays, just as one example. Personally I think the entire paradigm will be huge and will supplant today's phones, just as "phablets" supplanted smaller smartphones (regardless of the same naysayers with the same inane "who wants a phablet" commentary). Between 1) consumers wanting larger screens and 2) more consumers using their mobile devices as their primary method of work, play, internet access, etc., it's just a no brainer that a paradigm which gives them larger screens will become dominant. Whether it's foldable tech, or some other tech is moot because the market will advance towards the best solution naturally.

While I'm not necessarily defending foldable technology by itself, once again preferring to see it as a larger paradigm of shrinking phones regardless of method, I still get miffed when it's called half baked. I've been using a Fold 2 as a daily driver for months now and there is nothing half baked about it at all. Are there things I would like to see changed or improved, of course there are, but there are things about vanilla smartphones I'd like to see changed and/or improved as well. The "perfect" device doesn't exist, and in many senses I can turn around and compared to my Fold 2 call non shrinking phones the half baked devices because they don't satisfy my needs.

Anyhoo I hope everyone takes a couple of deep breaths and lets the oxygen seep into their brain before they just wantonly blurt out how half baked and useless it is to have a larger screened device with the same portability as your current phone. The paradigm may not be for YOU, but the paradigm does make sense and does solve a problem for those of us who do want a larger screen.
 
Ever since I said who the hell wants a full sized iPhone (early iPad rumors) and realized how wrong I was I learned to wait and see until the product comes out. If Apple makes one something tells me I’ll want it
 
I like my gadgets and new tech from any brand, but this has to be the worst design flop ever.

Who even needs a folding phone?

except:
pass
When Apple does it, the forums will be gushing it's perfect, magical, can't live without it...
 
  • Sad
Reactions: NetMage
I like the Samsung one that looks like my old Nintendo Gameboy clamshell. But realistically, it wouldn’t survive my pocket lint, which is why I don’t buy one. Maybe in a few years if they make these things more durable and get the costs down a bit, I’ll get one. Until then, I’m enjoying my iPhone mini.

I do think there’s merit in having a device that folds down to a nice pocket size but can unfold to offer a more generous display.

Now this Google one, it’s not exactly pocket friendly when folded, so I personally have no interest in it. I am not a big user of tablets. So I don’t need one that folds down to the size of an especially large phablet. But some road warriors might have an appreciation for it.

But how do you know it wouldn't survive? Many are making assumptions not based on experience. I have had my Fold 2 for months, if I'm not using it it's always in my pocket with tons of lint and other stuff that gets stuffed in there. There is zero damage to it. I'm not saying you in particular, but I hear this all the time on how fragile it is, but from people who have never even laid a finger on one, much less used it as a daily driver for months. These phones are far from fragile. No they aren't as sturdy as a regular smartphone, and no I would not put it into my pocket if the larger screen were exposed, but if you think about it the larger screen is actually safer because it is folded closed.
 
When Apple does it, the forums will be gushing it's perfect, magical, can't live without it...

It's a weird thing.... it happens across all industries. "If I don't want it, no one else should". I think it's cool that there are differences across products to fit different needs. I don't own a tablet, a touchscreen laptop and a folding phone work for me.
 
  • Like
Reactions: burgman
It's a weird thing.... it happens across all industries. "If I don't want it, no one else should". I think it's cool that there are differences across products to fit different needs. I don't own a tablet, a touchscreen laptop and a folding phone work for me.
Can we just skip to this please...
The-Expanse-Season-5-Naomi.jpg
 
I’m still struggling to see what problem these foldable phones is solving. Is its goal to create cellular tablets that can fit in our pockets? Use it as a phone on the go and as a tablet if you need that bigger screen? That’s something that sounds cool and I’d definitely use it, but idk if that’s why these things are really being made. And they’re super thick when folded, yuck. Maybe in five years they’ll be revolutionary.
 
I’m still struggling to see what problem these foldable phones is solving. Is its goal to create cellular tablets that can fit in our pockets? Use it as a phone on the go and as a tablet if you need that bigger screen? That’s something that sounds cool and I’d definitely use it, but idk if that’s why these things are really being made. And they’re super thick when folded, yuck. Maybe in five years they’ll be revolutionary.

For folks like me, they just want a phone and a laptop and not a dedicated tablet but does find use in a larger pocketable screen. Also being older with decreasing optical performance. :) The size isn't a problem either and it looks like Samsung is shrinking the footprint of the Z fold 3. It's really no more cumbersome than a regular smartphone with an Otter Box. YMMV
 
I’m still struggling to see what problem these foldable phones is solving. Is its goal to create cellular tablets that can fit in our pockets? Use it as a phone on the go and as a tablet if you need that bigger screen? That’s something that sounds cool and I’d definitely use it, but idk if that’s why these things are really being made. And they’re super thick when folded, yuck. Maybe in five years they’ll be revolutionary.

You just answered you own question as to the "why" shrinking phones are a thing, it's really not that hard of a mental stretch to want a larger tablet when in use, but a smaller footprint when being transported. The thickness can certainly be an issue for some. Personally I feel it fits better into my pocket (and in my hand when using it closes) because it's narrow so I don't know how I'll feel when we get a full width shrinking device such as the rollable displays. But this will improve over time as any technology does. I think of it this way, how thick were my iPhone and iPad mini when put together, because this is the combination I used to use to get the same functionality.
 
  • Like
Reactions: NetMage
Literally no one. These companies are completely out of ideas.

This is literally a new and evolving product category. Samsung has done it 3 times and they have sold relatively well. Huawei has done it. Microsoft has done their own version of it, albeit not as well as one would have hoped. However, Microsoft is pretty good at improving products from one generation to the next, Surface Duo XBox anyone? :)

Apple will do this one day, and one of Apple's strengths is that they always seem to have the best first generation of a product, while others take a few iterations to really nail down the idea.
 
Honest question. Who is actually asking for folding phones?
Good question. I don't understand this one at all. If you get a lot of messages, having to open something up to just to see if the notification is important would be a total pain. I'd also be afraid of getting one due to the failure rates of the constant folding.
 
  • Angry
Reactions: NetMage
Well, they're just starting, maybe in 10 years we ask ourselves how we could live with nonfoldable phones :p .
Also the same question could have been asked with smartwatches:
Who wants a smartwatch when you have already a screen on your phone?

Or tablets:
Who wants a tablet? They're just big phones.

And the same with every new tech/product

hilariously it's almost always the same naysayers "who would ever want that!". and they always come out of the woodworks to say that when ever it's a non-apple product.

The Second apple announces the same thing

"Greatest invention ever!"


these forums are so fun to watch the flip flopping hypocritical comments by people who clearly don't evidence any critical thinking skills
 
  • Like
Reactions: NetMage
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.