Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

MacRumors

macrumors bot
Original poster
Apr 12, 2001
68,257
39,059


When introducing the new Pixel 9 models today, Google didn't miss an opportunity to denigrate Apple Intelligence. All of the new Pixel 9 devices are integrated with Google's AI technology, Gemini, and there are a host of new AI features that Google introduced.


Like Apple Intelligence, Gemini works using on-device processing power, but Google made sure to point out that Gemini is capable enough to answer complex queries without handing a task off to another AI service. The comment was a dig at Apple's plan to add ChatGPT integration to Siri, as ChatGPT will be able to do things that Siri can't. From Google:
Gemini is deeply integrated with Google apps and Android and can handle complex queries without hand-off to third-party AI providers you may not know or trust.
Apple will use ChatGPT for things like generating text from scratch, something that Apple Intelligence doesn't do. Apple did add Writing Tools, but it is limited to rewriting content that you've already written to change the tone or style. ChatGPT will also be able to generate images that Image Playground cannot, such as photorealistic content, and it will handle requests like generating meal recipes.

When a user asks Siri something that Siri cannot handle, the personal assistant will ask for permission to hand it over to ChatGPT. ChatGPT integration is entirely optional, and OpenAI is partnering with Apple to bring it to iPhone users for free.

Rumors suggest that Apple also plans to add Gemini integration to the iPhone, allowing iPhone users to choose their preferred AI service. It's not quite clear if Apple Intelligence is incapable of handling full text generation and photorealistic image creation, or if these are capabilities that Apple feels are a little too questionable to touch given the sentiment about AI-created content.

Google's new Pixel devices have several interesting AI features, including Pixel Studio, a new image generator that uses an on-device diffusion model. It will generate stickers and images using text prompts, similar to Image Playground.

AI will be able to edit photos to add objects that weren't originally in the image, plus Google plans to use it for custom weather reports. The camera app has an option to merge two photos together so that the person taking a group photo can be in the picture, and it can catalog and remember information from screenshots. There's also a feature called Call Notes, which mimics Apple's call recording feature by recording and summarizing phone calls.

Google has also added Gemini Live to the Pixel 9 devices and accompanying earbuds, with Gemini Live allowing users to have full free-flowing conversations with Gemini.

Article Link: Google Touts Pixel 9's Gemini AI Capabilities That Don't Require 'Hand-off to AI Providers You May Not Know or Trust'
 


When introducing the new Pixel 9 models today, Google didn't miss an opportunity to denigrate Apple Intelligence. All of the new Pixel 9 devices are integrated with Google's AI technology, Gemini, and there are a host of new AI features that Google introduced.


Like Apple Intelligence, Gemini works using on-device processing power, but Google made sure to point out that Gemini is capable enough to answer complex queries without handing a task off to another AI service. The comment was a dig at Apple's plan to add ChatGPT integration to Siri, as ChatGPT will be able to do things that Siri can't. From Google:

Apple will use ChatGPT for things like generating text from scratch, something that Apple Intelligence doesn't do. Apple did add Writing Tools, but it is limited to rewriting content that you've already written to change the tone or style. ChatGPT will also be able to generate images that Image Playground cannot, such as photorealistic content, and it will handle requests like generating meal recipes.

When a user asks Siri something that Siri cannot handle, the personal assistant will ask for permission to hand it over to ChatGPT. ChatGPT integration is entirely optional, and OpenAI is partnering with Apple to bring it to iPhone users for free.

Rumors suggest that Apple also plans to add Gemini integration to the iPhone, allowing iPhone users to choose their preferred AI service. It's not quite clear if Apple Intelligence is incapable of handling full text generation and photorealistic image creation, or if these are capabilities that Apple feels are a little too questionable to touch given the sentiment about AI-created content.

Google's new Pixel devices have several interesting AI features, including Pixel Studio, a new image generator that uses an on-device diffusion model. It will generate stickers and images using text prompts, similar to Image Playground.

AI will be able to edit photos to add objects that weren't originally in the image, plus Google plans to use it for custom weather reports. The camera app has an option to merge two photos together so that the person taking a group photo can be in the picture, and it can catalog and remember information from screenshots. There's also a feature called Call Notes, which mimics Apple's call recording feature by recording and summarizing phone calls.

Google has also added Gemini Live to the Pixel 9 devices and accompanying earbuds, with Gemini Live allowing users to have full free-flowing conversations with Gemini.

Article Link: Google Touts Pixel 9's Gemini AI Capabilities That Don't Require 'Hand-off to AI Providers You May Not Know or Trust'
"Hey Siri, self-diagnose the reason the computer isn't connecting to the printer and fix it?" Too much to ask for, I'm sure. Thanks, Tim Apple.
 
Makes sense. Apple is forcing a 3rd party service onto its users. When people buy a Google phone, they know what they are getting.

Pixel users chose Google. Apple users never chose OpenAI
you haven't paid attention, it's optional, you have to click in order to use that 3rd party service

and yes, people who buy a Google phone know that they are the product
 
Apple is forcing a 3rd party service onto its users.
No, if your iPhone is going to talk to OpenAI, it asks for consent. Does an Android phone ask for consent before it sends data to an off-device AI?

Case in point: Google's flashy ad shows a use case of "...embarass my sister at her wedding, but respectfully...". Well, that pretty much says it all: First, I don't trust any AI to navigate such tricky social waters, and it says that Gemini is for people who would consider potentially messing up somebody's already-stressful once-in-a-lifetime day. The answer is also not shown. (ChatGPT, in all fairness, went along with the idea and made suggestions...)
 
With Apple and AI do you? I don’t even trust Apple with the data, no matter what they say. People are giving too much away to tech companies now
On device is better than sending it to servers. Apple has on device AI, and needs user to consent to send data to cloud. Google doesn’t provide on device option, everything is up for grabs.
 
With Apple and AI do you? I don’t even trust Apple with the data, no matter what they say. People are giving too much away to tech companies now
Apple is the sort of company that if they were using our data to sell or harvest information, they’d be found out and have the weight of the media world on them. I trust Apple more than any other company. They make more than enough money, that they don’t need to lie about privacy, privacy is the product.
 
…and Google thinks that people trust them..?
Of course they do. Google has a long list of services/products that are most popular in their respective categories, for example, GMail, YouTube, Android, Google Maps, Chrome Browser, Google Search, YouTube TV, Chromebooks/software for schools etc. Based on this, it looks like Google might be the most trusted service/software provider out there.
 
Makes sense. Apple is forcing a 3rd party service onto its users. When people buy a Google phone, they know what they are getting.

Pixel users chose Google. Apple users never chose OpenAI
I’m an Apple user who chose OpenAI. I subscribe because it’s useful for me and much better than Gemini in my trials.

Also, the OpenAI features in iOS will be opt in. This means you will specifically have to choose to use it.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.