The white one feels a bit "looser" than the orange one I was really excited to get these, but after getting them, I'm kind of "meh" about them. They should have made the sides MUCH more rigid. They move/separate from the phone incredibly easy and contribute to a general "loose" feeling. *edit* Also, let me add - one reason I wanted the bumpers was to hopefully protect the stainless steel from scratches. I don't have reception issues so I don't care about that. But, the bumpers are definitely "loose" enough so as to allow dirt/debris to get in between the bumper and phone and scratch it all up. Kind of like those cheapo silicone covers on the older iphones that scratched up the back due to dirt/debris.