Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
What value brings the new “buttons” to the users?.
What problems/difficulties do they bring to the users?.
For me the balance is negative. I prefer 10000 times a simple, reliable mute switch over a software solution that requires my full attention to activate vs the “no need to think” convenience of the switch.
But since Apple Has run out of good ideas or the capability to listen to people with good ideas, then, we will have this “improvement”.
 
What’s it going to take for Apple to bring back this volume button design? I miss simpler times!

6246869175_f03c82f27a_b.jpg
I actually much prefer the longer pill-shaped buttons we have today. These felt harder to press accurately since they were smaller.
 
  • Like
  • Disagree
Reactions: klasma and JM
How about bringing back 3D Touch with the Haptic Buttons?

Not sure how widely used 3D touch was. I found it finicky but maybe that was just my particular phone or me in general not figuring out how to use it right :p.

I'm guessing the cost and retail increase to bring it back would be fairly unwelcome considering how expensive smartphones have gotten and current inflation won't help either.
 
Im looking at this as a good thing less moving parts = less failures
you obviously have never repaired a iphone. a physical button will last longer. just ask my iphone 2g.
a haptic button might be paired with a logic board=if your button breaks, no way to replace it!
also i bet it is expensive to repair, or even refurbish one of these buttons
 
What’s it going to take for Apple to bring back this volume button design? I miss simpler times!

6246869175_f03c82f27a_b.jpg

That was my favorite iPhone Volume Up/Down design to date. Easier to accurately detect, by touch, the different buttons upon which my finger was resting. Why? The larger space between the round buttons made all the difference. The current space between buttons is so minuscule that, at times, the two buttons can feel like one long button.
Said another way... I've had more volume misfires since they moved to the longer/closer buttons. Of course YMMV.
 
Last edited:
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.