Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Can you please test for VM environments (Parrallel or VMFusion)? Would be interested whether 16gb ram is sufficient to run Windows and MS Office products (mainly excel) smoothly using the base configuration or whether 32gb is needed. Thanks!
 
Straight up, if you’re complaining about this computer and don’t think it’s amazing, nitpicking over little things, then you’re not a professional. Period. This computer is for professionals and this computer helps me and the like make money. It’s a tool to create and and get work done. There’s nothing about this computer that shouldn’t be getting work done for 99.9 percent of us. If you can’t make this machine work for you, then you’re an idiot.
 
What are you going to use on your lap or in an aeroplane that needs to be plugged in but having to use a dongle will cause you anxiety? If a dongle negates portability then surely anything you need to plug in will do the same?
Read the posts before you respond to them. An SD card reader means you can plug the card directly into the computer. It’s simple and clean. No annoying dangly crap. This is great for portability.
[automerge]1573858329[/automerge]
Haven't held an SD card in my hand for at least 2 years now. Ever since the iPhone replaced the digital camera there is no need for most people to have an SD slot. And if you're a photographer you carry around so much weight a dongle is irrelevant. You're in the tiny minority here I would think.
Sounds like you’re not a professional photographer, so you probably shouldn’t be giving an opinion on the matter. I’m certainly not in the minority. Most people want the SD card reader back. It’s nice to have it. You can’t argue that it’s better not to have it. It’s just not true.
 
Last edited:
What happens when the SSD gets damaged how much does it cost to replace? What if you purchased the MBP with only 16-32GB of ram and you want to update to 64GB??
 
  • Like
Reactions: Already in use
Can you please test for VM environments (Parrallel or VMFusion)? Would be interested whether 16gb ram is sufficient to run Windows and MS Office products (mainly excel) smoothly using the base configuration or whether 32gb is needed. Thanks!

I ordered my 2013 one with 8GB RAM. Biggest mistake, 2 years later it was a $3000 brick. Completely unusable for anything but browsing. And I fear 16GB today is the same as 8GB was back then. It depends what you're doing, but if you're running more than one VM, I fear it's not going to cut it. Maybe Linux in a VM, but not Windows 10 or Server 2019 for sure. Windows itself needs 16GB of RAM, if your host machine has that much it won't be pretty.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Marekul
What are you going to use on your lap or in an aeroplane that needs to be plugged in but having to use a dongle will cause you anxiety? If a dongle negates portability then surely anything you need to plug in will do the same?
Why is nobody reading the posts before responding to them?

An SD card that plugs into the computer is clean and simple. No dangly nonsense.
 
Read the posts before you respond to them. An SD card reader means you can plug the card directly into the computer. It’s simple and clean. No annoying dangly crap. This is great for portability.

I don't need to read it again, you made no mention of an SD card reader. Would also help if you stopped editing your posts after people reply.
 
I don't need to read it again, you made no mention of an SD card reader. Would also help if you stopped editing your posts after people reply.
Yes I did. This is a conversation thread. That was the very first point I made about dongles.

You had read the reply to a reply, but not the original post. So your entire view of the conversation is skewed if you’re only reading and reacting to an out-of-context reply.
 
  • Like
Reactions: heffsf
Read my post again.

Yes, dongles do indeed negate portability. The point of having something that's portable is to have something that doesn't need to be tied down to a bunch of dangly crap that makes it annoying to use on a lap or on an airplane.

And sure, I don't "need to use the Touch Bar" but you know what I do need to use? The function keys.

And even if I liked the Touch Bar, the problem is that it exists only on the MacBooks, and not on any of the desktop Macs. So there's no sense in even getting used to using it while I'm on the go if I can't use it when I'm back using my desktop at the office. It causes too much disparity between my portable Macs and my desktop Macs, so it ultimately just gets in the way.

I’ve taken many 2016+ MacBook Pros on many airplanes, never required ”dangly crap”.

Function keys are available and can be “locked” to be available at all times, same with the traditional Mac-specific keys. i.e. brightness/volume.

Do you also complain that the seat in your car feels different than the one at your kitchen table?
 
  • Like
Reactions: NickName99
Yes I did. This is a conversation thread. That was the very first point I made about dongles. My goodness.

You read the reply to a reply, but not the original post. So your entire view of the conversation is skewed if you’re only reading and reacting to an out-of-context reply.
Dude I'm not even a part of this conversation and you are being annoying as hell.

Dongles don't "negate portability". It’s just not true. Goodness.
 
I’ve taken many 2016+ MacBook Pros on many airplanes, never required ”dangly crap”.

Function keys are available and can be “locked” to be available at all times, same with the traditional Mac-specific keys.

Do you also complain that the seat in your car feels different than the one at your kitchen table?
Man, you people have no vision. And that’s an absurd analogy.

A tool (in this case, the Touch Bar) is utterly useless if it causes disparity among workflows. For example, if I’m a Photoshop user, the Touch Bar has some cool controls that allow me to manipulate photos. But if I’m working from a desktop, those controls aren’t available. So I go back to using the controls within the GUI when in a desktop. The problem is, using different methods on desktop vs. laptop is very, very dumb. It destroys muscle memory and all around efficiency. So most people result to just using the GUI on the laptop so as to not create inefficiency. In other words, the Touch Bar is a pretty cool concept, but it ultimately becomes useless and just gets in the way. If Apple would make it available in desktop, that could fix the disparity. But Apple isn’t doing that. So the best thing is to just get rid of the Touch Bar altogether.
 
What happens when the SSD gets damaged how much does it cost to replace? What if you purchased the MBP with only 16-32GB of ram and you want to update to 64GB??
That is why you have AppleCare So you do not worry about it. And what happens when you run out of storage on a iPhone oh you buy a new iPhone and you sell the old one.
 
Last edited:
You had read the reply to a reply, but not the original post. So your entire view of the conversation is skewed if you’re only reading and reacting to an out-of-context reply.

Well here is the answer for you, work with it or stop buying Apple (assuming you are in the first place), things like SD card readers are not coming back.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: PeterZwegat
I've so far heard three different reviewers (including Dan) using the built-in mic for their reviews, and I'm underwhelmed. Like most electret systems, it picks up a lot of ambient room noise and slapback. There's also some noticeable distortion. The frequency response seems a bit on the warm side, which suits podcasts. But you'd still get way better vocal audio with an external mic, whether a desktop or lavalier.
 
Read my post again.

Yes, dongles do indeed negate portability. The point of having something that's portable is to have something that doesn't need to be tied down to a bunch of dangly crap that makes it annoying to use on a lap or on an airplane.

And sure, I don't "need to use the Touch Bar" but you know what I do need to use? The function keys.

And even if I liked the Touch Bar, the problem is that it exists only on the MacBooks, and not on any of the desktop Macs. So there's no sense in even getting used to using it while I'm on the go if I can't use it when I'm back using my desktop at the office. It causes too much disparity between my portable Macs and my desktop Macs, so it ultimately just gets in the way.



You can make it so that the function keys are permanently displayed in whatever app you need.

And it's 2019, deal with the dongles already. You're a professional photographer, do you complain about having to lug around multiple lenses, extra SD cards, batteries, etc.?

You may need an SD card reader, others need a headphone jack, some need HDMI, VGA, DVI, USB, Thunderbolt, etc. etc. etc. If Apple pleased every "pro" with their ULTRA LIGHT AND PORTABLE top of the line computer, the thing would weigh about 20 lbs.

Or go buy a PC and stop complaining here.
 
I've so far heard three different reviewers (including Dan) using the built-in mic for their reviews, and I'm underwhelmed. Like most electret systems, it picks up a lot of ambient room noise and slapback. There's also some noticeable distortion. The frequency response seems a bit on the warm side, which suits podcasts. But you'd still get way better vocal audio with an external mic, whether a desktop or lavalier.

A built in mic is best for FaceTime communications not for pristine audio recording use a lavalier or studio mic, I agree.
 
  • Like
Reactions: FairlyKors
Dongles don't "negate portability". It’s just not true. Goodness.
But they do though. Portability is about having something that's clean, simple, and doesn't require additional components in order for it to function.
[automerge]1573860342[/automerge]
Things like SD card readers are not coming back.
That's what's so annoying though. Why? Why are they not coming back? The SD card is the most modern and common storage medium for image acquisition. Pro photographers aren't taking pictures with their iPhones and AirDropping them to their Macs. So if Apple's going to slap a "Pro" moniker on their products, then they ought to actually make them tailored for real pros, not just hipster iPhone photographers.
 
I'm typing this on a MBP 16 at an Apple store. The keyboard is definitely much improved. Even though the 1mm of travel is still on the low side it provides enough cushion so that typing doesn't feel like banging on concrete.

I was close to pulling the trigger on a near maxed out config but decided to wait. For close to $6K I plan on using this laptop for 6+ years. I can't imagine using a laptop without wifi 6 in 2026. I consider it a given that Apple will do a refresh with Intel's 10th gen Comet Lake CPU the summer which includes wifi 6 and LPDDR4. A config with 64GB, or even 32GB, of RAM will definitely have improved battery life using LPDDR4 compared to the current DDR4. Given the high cost of my config and the length of time I plan to keep it it's definitely worth waiting another 6 to 7 months. Also, this will give Apple enough time to iron out the inevitable bugs from the near first gen product.

This is absolutely correct. Let the superfans test it. Then when the few missing items are added in the refresh, a 4-6 year commitment can be made. Wifi6 is my personal deal breaker. My entire array of computers at home (desktops) are running 100Mb to 240Mb a second over wifi. With occasional hits to 700Mb. I don’t want to give that up. I love the option of portability and massive wireless speeds for big data. I also have gigabit internet hitting an easy 800Mb to 980Mb over wifi!
 
  • Like
Reactions: turbineseaplane
Picking up the i9/16GB/1TB SG version from Best Buy this afternoon to supplement my 13" MBP. The 13" is just too small as a desktop computer for me, so that smaller MBP will be my on-the-go laptop. Looking forward to the more immersive 16" screen (and the improved speakers/mic).
Buying a good 27”+ 2K/4K monitor might be a better experience than a 16” MBP. I’ve had my 13” MBP for 5 years connected to a 27” monitor (sometimes 2) along with an Apple keyboard and trackpad, and it’s easy to quickly carry my laptop if I require it, which is mostly daily.
 
What do you think of the 16-inch MacBook Pro? Are you upgrading? Let us know in the comments.

I think it's great. I already ordered one. I'm looking forward to the larger screen having loved my multiple 17" PowerBook's and MacBook Pro's over the years.
 
  • Like
Reactions: gp313 and jlocker
But they do though. Portability is about having something that's clean, simple, and doesn't require additional components in order for it to function.
[automerge]1573860342[/automerge]

That's what's so annoying though. Why? Why are they not coming back? The SD card is the most modern format for image acquisition. Pro photographers aren't taking pictures with their iPhones and AirDropping them to their Macs. So if Apple's going to slap a "Pro" moniker on their products, then they ought to actually make them tailored for real pros, not iPhone photographers.

Oh my god the MacBook Pro old 17in is so big, I do not like it, has every thing because it is big. Oh the 16in MacBook Pro does not have a ton of different ports but it run on batteries for 11 hours not 3. You have to make compromises to make a system for a majority of what users want.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: FairlyKors
This is absolutely correct. Let the superfans test it. Then when the few missing items are added in the refresh, a 4-6 year commitment can be made. Wifi6 is my personal deal breaker. My entire array of computers at home (desktops) are running 100Mb to 240Mb a second over wifi. I don’t want to give that up. I love the option of portability and massive wireless speeds for big data.

Is it really?

LPDDR4/WiFi 6 are pretty meh when you consider that after next summers refresh, the refresh after that which is likely to come within 6-12 months is potentially a lot bigger: 10nm, new screen options (miniled/OLED/10bit HDR/4K+/120hz?), FaceID etc

Something better is always around the corner but what you’ll be getting is summer is really not items which are worth waiting for for a long term commitment, it is not often so little is around the corner - this is a golden purchase opportunity imo.
 
  • Like
Reactions: HouseofG
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.