I think you are one step further because you allready have the controller recognized by Windows. I believe that the other guy did not have his AHCI driver recognized on loading with Windows.
What is your Windows drive called internally in disk utility, do you know that?
Also which partition table did you use on it, MBR?
no, I tried before but it always failed, cannot modify MBR, I think this is because I have formatted the drive as GUID, do you think this is the problem?
no, I tried before but it always failed, cannot modify MBR, I think this is because I have formatted the drive as GUID, do you think this is the problem?
Scanning drives...
Windows partition found on /dev/disk8
Do you want to use this drive? (Y/N)n
Enter drive to use: Disk2s2
Backing up MBR from Disk2s2 to ./backup.mbr
ERROR: Unable to read MBR
bash-3.2#