Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

MacRumors

macrumors bot
Original poster


Apple has added a new entry to its Machine Learning Journal with in-depth technical details about how it uses differential privacy to gather anonymous usage insights from devices like iPhones, iPads, and Macs.

ios-differential-privacy-copy.jpg
 
Their ML blog is always interesting to read, and differential privacy is a good idea.
I always check the box for sharing info with Apple and with developers, it helps a lot

I wonder if they'll publish an chart for the most popular animoji character in the future, I bet on the poop
 
Probably because there are a small group of ill-informed people who think Apple is spying on them (tin foil hats ready) 🙄

Apple’s stance on privacy is one of the (many reasons) I like and continue to use Apple products.

I believe the answer is it helps to attract talent. Top researchers want to be published in their findings, so an atmosphere of secrecy would work against them here.

Aww man, I was going for a High Sierra root privileges joke here. Evidence suggests, I have failed this forum.
 
I think the privacy campaign is all apple has left in the tank. When things go to @**t, apple marketing pulls out the privacy card and plays it hard.
Be confident that this information will be more than routinely scrambled and dissected (...) before it reaches Apple servers.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kris28
Probably because there are a small group of ill-informed people who think Apple is spying on them (tin foil hats ready)

Apple’s stance on privacy is one of the (many reasons) I like and continue to use Apple products.
Apples stance on privacy is one of the (many reasons) I am getting sick of Apple products.

"User Experience" has always been what kept me in my happy little Apple bubble. But the more Apple tries using "Privacy" as their unique marketing angle, the more I see other products improve by "exploiting" user data while Apple stuff hits some hard limitations.

Of course Privacy is important. But people act as if Google is selling our childrens social security numbers and trading our bank accounts to China. But the reality of it is that its just a two way street. I give up secrets about my browsing habits (OMG, they found out I'm shopping for a new Fridge!) and they give me info and results that I actually can use (Hey. Fridge review. Win Win. (Unless you have your Tin Foil hat inside out)
 
"User Experience" has always been what kept me in my happy little Apple bubble. But the more Apple tries using "Privacy" as their unique marketing angle, the more I see other products improve by "exploiting" user data while Apple stuff hits some hard limitations.

Did you actually read the article? It's about how Apple is exploiting user data, with their consent, while retaining privacy.
 
I allow my Mac Analytics to be sent, but every now and then it gets disabled by itself and I have to turn it back on.

Anyone had similar issues?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kris28
I do wonder how quickly Apple could advance their AI if they had some kind of opt-in feature in iOS and macOS that let users share even more data so that Apple could get more granular data about their users. I think lots of people would give their data to Apple provided an appropriate opt-out method was in place.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kris28
Apples stance on privacy is one of the (many reasons) I am getting sick of Apple products.

"User Experience" has always been what kept me in my happy little Apple bubble. But the more Apple tries using "Privacy" as their unique marketing angle, the more I see other products improve by "exploiting" user data while Apple stuff hits some hard limitations.

Of course Privacy is important. But people act as if Google is selling our childrens social security numbers and trading our bank accounts to China. But the reality of it is that its just a two way street. I give up secrets about my browsing habits (OMG, they found out I'm shopping for a new Fridge!) and they give me info and results that I actually can use (Hey. Fridge review. Win Win. (Unless you have your Tin Foil hat inside out)

You are totally right about the use of user data being a two-way street and I totally get both sides of this. I think the whole differential privacy thing is Apple's attempt to "exploit" user data while still respecting privacy. Whether that will be as effective as Google's approach, I would guess not, but I don't really have the expertise to say. There are definitely things I like about both Apple and Google, and I have annoyances with both as well.
 
I do wonder how quickly Apple could advance their AI if they had some kind of opt-in feature in iOS and macOS that let users share even more data so that Apple could get more granular data about their users. I think lots of people would give their data to Apple provided an appropriate opt-out method was in place.
I think that, while it is definitely not as powerful as data mining, differential privacy not only protects user information but justifies Apple's position in services. They are not as good at AI as Google, but they are getting better. This acts as a technological and marketing shield.
 
  • Like
Reactions: AirunJae
Of course Privacy is important. But people act as if Google is selling our childrens social security numbers and trading our bank accounts to China. But the reality of it is that its just a two way street. I give up secrets about my browsing habits (OMG, they found out I'm shopping for a new Fridge!) and they give me info and results that I actually can use (Hey. Fridge review. Win Win. (Unless you have your Tin Foil hat inside out)

Google literally makes almost 90% of their revenue off data. Apple makes practically nothing off our data (they make money on hardware).

Which company do you think is more likely to abuse your data for their own gain?

Here’s a hint: it’s the company that was fined for intentionally writing code to exploit Safari to bypass do-not-track in order to serve ads.
 
As someone who works in the field of machine learning, my problem with the optional setting for data collection is that it distorts/skews the sample. Instead of getting a good sample of all users, you're simply getting a sample of the types of users that don't turn off the privacy setting, which may lead you to some bad conclusions and will distort the algorithms.

It's like in recent elections where traditional pollsters can only call landline telephones due to regulatory constraints. It skews your sample in a large, hard-to-account for way.
 
  • Like
Reactions: AirunJae
It would be more interesting to have them talk about differential privacy and Siri's development, since Siri is widely perceived to be lagging the other companies' smart assistants.
 
Aww man, I was going for a High Sierra root privileges joke here. Evidence suggests, I have failed this forum.
It was such low hanging fruit too. The failed realizations made it actually funnier than it would have been if everyone had gotten the joke. 10-1 somebody's gonna give you 5 paragraphs of righteous indignation remaining completely oblivious.
Next time, try a fire/explode joke.😉 😀
 
  • Like
Reactions: AirunJae and Gorms
Why does my quick type auto correct always screw up and misspell normal words I’ve misspelled in the past then?
Is there anyway to reset your keyboard auto correct words? Been like that for years
 
  • Like
Reactions: DeepIn2U
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.