Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

brojan

macrumors member
Original poster
Sep 13, 2016
77
22
throw all your vents in here! Every change will end up in people complaining and then accepting it.

1. I don't think it feels like a button. It sure does feel like the trackpad. Almost like the whole case back is clicking up into the phone.

2. And this one is big... can't click with fingernail! So if your thumb is sideways and too much nail and not enough skin... no click :(
 
  • Like
Reactions: BlueAquarian
I stopped by AT&T right before dinner since it was right next door. Basically just wanted to check out the new home button.

I don't like it at all. The trackpad in the new MacBooks feels almost the same as the old trackpad, but this feels nothing like the old home button.
 
I actually really like the taptic feedback. It feels like a button and it works (I have it on option 1). But... it's doing it too often. The thing vibrates on nearly every possible thing it can. Scrolling down a drop-down list, for example, I don't need this button vibrating for every option that zooms by. Rubber-band refreshing a screen? Don't need it, bruh. I just don't need it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: chrislutes
3. Also feels weird/terrible clicking when phone is on hard surface I.e. Desk. Seems to take more effort to push.

But yes we'll all accept it and get used to it.

Just saying!
 
I like it, but it has one negative effect - I find myself pressing down on the app icons expecting to get the same sensation and all it does is activate the 3d screen options.
 
Felt totally weird to me at first, now it's weird that it doesn't. When I don't think about it, feels just like a button.
Clever stuff.

This. I still don't think it feels like a button, but its odd how quick i got accustomed to it.
 
My son has some touchscreen compatible gloves. They work with the screen but not on the home button! Unbelievable.

He said "that's what happens when it's designed in California ".
 
throw all your vents in here! Every change will end up in people complaining and then accepting it.

1. I don't think it feels like a button. It sure does feel like the trackpad. Almost like the whole case back is clicking up into the phone.

2. And this one is big... can't click with fingernail! So if your thumb is sideways and too much nail and not enough skin... no click :(
I dropped in the Apple Store today to have a look at the 7's. I just picked them up and started playing around with them, checking out new iOS 10 features, the new cameras, etc... After several minutes I realized that I hadn't even been aware of the new home button (i.e. As I had just picked the phones up and dived right in). So, I guess it felt very natural to me. I actually liked it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bryan Bowler
I took to I straight away, I think it's fantastic. Personally I think it feels a lot like the click on the remote of the ATV4 - very similar, even though that's a phisical click. Very happy.
 
I really like it. I've got mine set too three and it sort of feels like a real click!

I will be interested the see the developers taking advantage of the new button with notifications etc as Phil mentioned at the keynote.
 
Yeah I felt it to be very odd at first. I hated it!! Now I am used to it after a few hours use. It actually feels odd to me when I press down on the home button of my 6s plus and don't get that feedback from it now. You get used to it quickly.
 
I like it when holding the phone on hand. -- But I really cannot get used to when the phone is laying on the table. I just don't feel the click.
 
I really like it pressing the old style button feels really squishy and out dated.

People going on about not being able to press the home button with touch screen gloves.

Couple of work arounds

Press power button swipe left and launch an app from there to bring up pass keypad.

Or

Press power button press home button with nose to bring up key pad

Just tested my gloves and the work fine!
 
Wouldn't say I love it but it doesn't bother me, either. Still better than the vibration feedback some other phones have
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.