Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
the beauty of Lutron is it always works. ALWAYS. I can't say that about a single other HomeKit device
Good to know and I can attest that the Belkin Wemo bridge is absolute garbage (I had to stop using it as even using an outlet to automate restarting it every night wasn’t enough to make it reliable) and accessories I hooked up through it did always have problems. If you setup the switches directly to HomeKit with no bridge they are pretty reliable. Definitely not 100%, but maybe 90%+? I suppose in the run it is worth it to spend a lot for better dependability but hard to stomach…
 
At least for me, those Wemo switches have been terrible. They are constantly dropping off of HomeKit for reasons I don’t understand and then I can only control them using the Wemo app instead. It’s very annoying.
If you are using the wemo bridge definitely toss that and just link to HomeKit directly… For me I’d say the HomeKit integration is 90% reliable and at least the switch itself always works to turn on the lights for light switches replaced… One thing I have found too is that with my Hue bridge (extremely reliable) to plug that in directly to your router and not, say, through an Orbi satellite or through switches. I only mention that because I have Wemo controlling Hue stuff through HomeKit…
 
HomeBridge is totally worth checking out. I have a lot of non-homekit devices working with Home. I run it on a MacMini.
Yep, homebridge is awesome. I use it to control all my Wemo lights through homekit as Belkin seem to have pretty much abandoned Wemo in the UK so the official Wemo homekit bridge has never been available here.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SigEp265
I keep wondering where the dimming glass windows are. Are they that expensive, that hard to manufacture, that hard to find, that unreliable?

I remember watching someone pushing a remote control button, and the glass went opaque. Loved it... Is that technology out there somewhere? It wouldn't be 'darkout' type shading, but is a start...
In order:
Yes
No
No
Yes
You are paying big bucks for old tech. Had you bought them. Yesterday's "dimming windows" work on b or g wifi, not ac or ax.
 
I use the RadioRA+ version of the dimmers, which I expect are the same. I don't have this issue, but I did have to choose carefully. The bulbs that work are expensive, and they still don't have the low end that you get with halogen.

Exactly and the reason I went with the Hue bulbs, since if I was going to pay a premium on a light bulb I wanted color/temp control and the ability to dim low.

I do have their ELV+ dimmer on some recessed LED kitchen lights that I'm not ready to replace yet, it is a bit quieter and the humming not as noticeable during normal kitchen activity.

Luckily the Caseta Plug in adapters can be switched to on/off mode and are great for things like Christmas lights and LED cabinet lighting.
 
Hate to break it to you, but it is. And has been around for years.


There are also versions that are like Transitions lenses that change tint from clear to grey/smokey
Pretty cool stuff. Maybe we're a few years away from windows that can double as a computer/tv display. Imagine turning your windows into a view of the Grand Canyon or Andromeda... fun stuff.

edit: to be on topic, I have only a few HomeKit items (HomePod) but rely on the Hue Hub for a 6 lights (color/normal), 5 smart switches, and a Neato robot vacuum.

I think the real star here is Shortcuts - once you figure this out you can link multiple things together even if they're not designed for HomeKit. :cool:
 
Last edited:
Good to know and I can attest that the Belkin Wemo bridge is absolute garbage (I had to stop using it as even using an outlet to automate restarting it every night wasn’t enough to make it reliable) and accessories I hooked up through it did always have problems. If you setup the switches directly to HomeKit with no bridge they are pretty reliable. Definitely not 100%, but maybe 90%+? I suppose in the run it is worth it to spend a lot for better dependability but hard to stomach…
one things that's true is ya wind up spending more down the line replacing the stuff that doesn't work... I currently just ordered another Lutron lamp dimmer cus the idevices switch I previously used for my Christmas tree flat out won't connect to HomeKit at all suddenly
 
one things that's true is ya wind up spending more down the line replacing the stuff that doesn't work... I currently just ordered another Lutron lamp dimmer cus the idevices switch I previously used for my Christmas tree flat out won't connect to HomeKit at all suddenly
I have a drawer full of iHome and iDevices Wi-Fi smart switches that stopped working or would randomly drop out starting 2 years ago. I gave up on support from both companies because they blamed Apple for changes in homekit and Apple blamed them for not updating their firmware.

There is a 1400+ post thread on Rachio's support channel for the same issue. https://community.rachio.com/t/rachio-3-not-responding-in-homekit-again/17689/1462

In my experience you are better off in Homekit using devices that work via another hub - If you are already in the Philips Hue ecosystem their smart plugs are rock solid, albeit more expensive.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SalisburySam
granted i only scrubbed through the video, but why is there a nest cam on the thumbnail? my understanding is this is not even working via homebridge as of now
 
I wired my entire house with fiber and CAT7 only to discover that all home automation products are wireless and therefore much less reliable on the network. And God forbid if I ever need to change my WiFi SSID.
Sounds like you're all set for some wireless access points though. Wish I had that set up.
 
$600 per window is pricy. I cant wait for the price to come down or another option to become available. I like the concept and use Lutron around the house just cant commit at this time to shades that cost this much. Those that can, I think you will enjoy the automation you can add with instillation.
If you want low-end, the Ikea roller blinds are very reasonable, very easy to install (physically) and fairly reliable.
The main downside is that they're still not Thread, rather Ikea's particular implementation of zigbee with all the weirdness surrounding a dedicated controller and a pairing model that will make no sense to you when you have to re-pair them again in a year after something goes wrong.

Bottom line
- smart shades are REALLY nice if you live in a place like LA or Phoenix
- Ikea are priced low enough to fit most budgets BUT
- wait till Ikea ship a Thread version that (hopefully) dispenses with the Ikea-specific controller weirdness.
 
  • Like
Reactions: gsmornot
I wired my entire house with fiber and CAT7 only to discover that all home automation products are wireless and therefore much less reliable on the network. And God forbid if I ever need to change my WiFi SSID.
In theory Thread will fix this
- based (at the lowest level) on BT rather than WiFi, so doesn't depend on your SSID (or other nonsense like 2.4 vs 5 vs 6GHz)
- mesh-based so, once you install a critical mass of just a few devices, each subsequent device makes the network more reliable.

Thread, like all new HW, is taking its sweet time to become universal -- and we probably lost two years or more of transition time to Covid and the chip shortage :-(
One simply has to be patient...
The essentials are available: base station (aTV or HomePod mini), smart sockets (Eve), lightbulbs (Nanoleaf Essentials), but anything fancier, not yet.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ChromeAce
I have a real espresso machine, linked to HomeKit by being plugged into a smart power outlet. It needs 20 minutes to get up to temperature, so I can set it to start up 20min before I need it and these can be automated (ie. geofence triggers, time triggers and of course Siri).
 
$600 per window is pricy. I cant wait for the price to come down or another option to become available. I like the concept and use Lutron around the house just cant commit at this time to shades that cost this much. Those that can, I think you will enjoy the automation you can add with instillation.

$600? I was quoted $747.00!!!
 
Surprised they didn’t mention the Logitech Circle View smart doorbell, with HomeKit Secure video. Good camera and peace of mind knowing Jeff Bezos isn’t leering at your guests every time they arrive.
 
What a horrible experience, *it automatically sends me to the EU site without the good link, no way to check which
model it is.

*Nope, back does not work either.
Use a VPN to access the US-American site (try Opera for example).

Anyhow:
HunterFan used to have a SmartFan Site where they announced their SimpleConnect fans for Europe a while ago, but they’ve since removed it ?

https://hunterfan.de/en/pages/smart-fan-simpleconnect®

Unfortunately the WayBack Machine on archive.org has no copy of this site. I did capture a screenshot back in October:

1637802444975.jpg


I wonder what happened. I‘ve sent hunter an inquiry, but they never answered.
 
  • Like
Reactions: justperry
Use a VPN to access the US-American site (try Opera for example).

Anyhow:
HunterFan used to have a SmartFan Site where they announced their SimpleConnect fans for Europe a while ago, but they’ve since removed it ?

https://hunterfan.de/en/pages/smart-fan-simpleconnect®

Unfortunately the WayBack Machine on archive.org has no copy of this site. I did capture a screenshot back in October:

View attachment 1917700

I wonder what happened. I‘ve sent hunter an inquiry, but they never answered.
Goddamn, why didn't I think of myself.
 
That was CGI. Its not technically possible to make glass turn opaque.

Companies have been making glass turn opaque at a push of a button for a very long time. The first time I saw it, was about 20 years ago (in person, not some random video). But that was for commercial use, not the consumer. Car manufactures have been able to turn the windows on cars go opaque for years, Maybach was the first one.
 
  • Like
Reactions: macguru212
What a horrible experience, *it automatically sends me to the EU site without the good link, no way to check which
model it is.

*Nope, back does not work either.
I connected with a VPN, wow...those ridiculous prices.

Same here though, my girl will buy me a top of the line 60" Panasonic (Asia) for about the same price as the cheapest Hunter connected fan.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.