Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

8CoreWhore

macrumors 68030
Original poster
Jan 17, 2008
2,670
1,225
Tejas

Attachments

  • Screen Shot 2018-02-10 at 10.53.57 PM.png
    Screen Shot 2018-02-10 at 10.53.57 PM.png
    1.1 MB · Views: 656
  • Screen Shot 2018-02-10 at 10.54.07 PM.png
    Screen Shot 2018-02-10 at 10.54.07 PM.png
    633.7 KB · Views: 593
Explanation before anyone gets hurt:
I needs to have a way to be plugged in so that factory workers can assemble it.

Case A:
- user is told cable is removable
- user pulls hard and removes cable
- user potentially damages the wires inside since it's a tiny bit of plastic withstanding that much force
- user does not see visible damage
- user plugs it back in
- after some time the wires may short and cause a fire
- apple is sued for not preventing etc bla bla

Case B:
- user is told cable is not removable
- Apple service center remove it by pulling hard
- Apple service center makes sure to dispose of the potentially damaged cable
- Apple service center plugs in a new cable

Because we live in 2018 where people eat detergent pods while knowing full well they are not safe for a human body, a user can not be trusted to respect a warning to dispose of old calbes.

Edit: btw this movie is really turning into a documentary :)
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0387808/
 
Last edited:
So it is, but then seeing that video and the amount of force to pull it, I'm not comfortable even attempting it. I was at the apple store and I gave the display model a decent amount of force on the cord to see if the cable would come out and it wouldn't. Now that I see the video, I was not giving the attempt anywhere near the amount of effort needed to remove it. Yikes, at least this one question has been answered.
 
Explanation before anyone gets hurt:
I needs to have a way to be plugged in so that factory workers can assemble it.

Case A:
- user is told cable is removable
- user pulls hard and removes cable
- user potentially damages the wires inside since it's a tiny bit of plastic withstanding that much force
- user does not see visible damage
- user plugs it back in
- after some time the wires may short and cause a fire
- apple is sued for not preventing etc bla bla

Case B:
- user is told cable is not removable
- Apple service center remove it by pulling hard
- Apple service center makes sure to dispose of the potentially damaged cable
- Apple service center plugs in a new cable

Because we live in 2018 where people eat detergent pods while knowing full well they are not safe for a human body, a user can not be trusted to respect a warning to dispose of old calbes.

Edit: btw this movie is really turning into a documentary :)
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0387808/
Case C - Apple provides a cable so people can remove it easily to
- make it easy to do cable management (need a big hole in furniture for EU plugs and even bigger for UK plugs )
- easy fo change from EU to UK and visa versa when people move countries without having to use adapter plugs
- easy to buy cables of different (optimum) lengths with pre fitted plugs.
 
I think the device would become obsolete before the power cord needs to be replaced. I've had 30 year old audio gear with a fully functioning power cord. Thats usually the last thing to go. It would only be replaced if it becomes brittle. So what's all the chatter about? Never seen a forum so excited just to unplug a power cord.
 
Last edited:
I think the devise would become obsolete before the power cord needs to be replaced. I've had 30 year old audio gear with a fully functioning power cord. Thats usually the last thing to go. It would only be replaced if it becomes brittle. So what's all the chatter about? Never seen a forum so excited just to unplug a power cord.
Removable cord means 3rd party battery power ;)
 
I think the devise would become obsolete before the power cord needs to be replaced. I've had 30 year old audio gear with a fully functioning power cord. Thats usually the last thing to go. It would only be replaced if it becomes brittle. So what's all the chatter about? Never seen a forum so excited just to unplug a power cord.

How about, like in my situation, I have purchased one from the U.K. (where I’m from), to be used in Spain (where I live).
Once the EU start getting these there is a chance I can swap it out for an EU cord.

Or

I can have multiple cords plugged in various location in my house and simply unplug from the HomePod, move, plug back in, making HomePod a bit more portable for the home (especially if plugged in to awkward to reach sockets, such as behind furniture)

Just some thoughts.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bopajuice
My wife and I foster dogs, and I have replaced may MacBook power adapter 3x from dogs chewing on it. A removal cable would be a plus for me.
 
  • Like
Reactions: bopajuice
Aside from puppies chewing cords (done that); and purchasing additional cords to keep plugged in so that just the device can be moved around (laptop charger cords plugged in at the ready in the kitchen, office, and master bedroom);
I have several countertop areas where we have installed grommets for cords to go down to the outlet inside the cabinet to keep it looking nice and clutter free, e.g., lamp cords. Since I will use a HP in the kitchen on a countertop, I would not want to run a cord down the front of a cabinet, or take up the outlet used for cooking appliances behind the counter. Having a removable Home Pod cord means I can use the outlet inside the cabinet, then run the HP Cord up through the grommet. If I move that same HP to the office area, the kitchen cord can stay down inside the cabinet while I move only the HP to the office where I have an identical cord waiting with the same set up.
 
  • Like
Reactions: sassenach74
While the cord is removable, we don't yet know how robust the connector inside is. It's not designed for thousands of cycles. Maybe it can handle it but I'd keep it to a minimum.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Arran
While the cord is removable, we don't yet know how robust the connector inside is. It's not designed for thousands of cycles. Maybe it can handle it but I'd keep it to a minimum.

Apple is advising to NOT remove the cord from the back of the HomePod.

https://forums.macrumors.com/thread...but-warns-they-should-not-be-removed.2105697/

The HomePod includes a built-in power cable that should not be removed.

In the rare instance that the cable is detached or damaged, do not attempt to remove or plug it back into HomePod. If the cable is removed or impaired, damage could have occurred to the cable or the internal components of HomePod.”
 
While the cord is removable, we don't yet know how robust the connector inside is. It's not designed for thousands of cycles. Maybe it can handle it but I'd keep it to a minimum.
Apple is advising to NOT remove the cord from the back of the HomePod.

https://forums.macrumors.com/thread...but-warns-they-should-not-be-removed.2105697/

The HomePod includes a built-in power cable that should not be removed.

In the rare instance that the cable is detached or damaged, do not attempt to remove or plug it back into HomePod. If the cable is removed or impaired, damage could have occurred to the cable or the internal components of HomePod.”
[doublepost=1518441197][/doublepost]Thanks 8Core and Relentless for the heads up! Back to Plan B. I may gently remove the cord one time to get it through the grommet but then leave the speaker in the same place.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 44267547
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.