WRONG...
Nowhere in your warranty or otherwise does it indicate you are owed a "new" product if yours fails for any reason...
Apple owes you a FIX. You aren't giving them a brand new phone, you are giving them a USED one for warranty work. If it's within 30 days you can just return it, if not, get over the "I need a new one because I can't have a refurb... Apple owes me a new one because mine had a problem... wah wahhhh".
It's absolutely hillarious when people start these "is mine a refurb?" threads... if you can't tell, why care in the first place??? I would understand if it had a big gouge in it, or functioned differently... but come on, even you can't tell (and obviously you are anal if you are asking in the first place... not a bad thing, just pointing that out lol).
Sheesh people. You don't get a whole new car if your alternator fails... you get a new alternator and the same USED car you drove in with.
If there are ANY issues with the refurb, Apple will gladly give you another...
Exactly, I don't get someone else's repaired car with a new alternator. If they, say, replaced the battery if my IPhone had a faulty one, then that would be fine by me but I don't want to get an iPhone that some one else has had before, was defective then repaired and then sent to me. Warranty or no warranty, it's more about the moral to me and then maybe they should change their warranty policies(or rather just respect the legal ones here in Europe as everybody should since it's the LAW[refering to AppleCare in particular]).
How's that for anal?