Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
How do you think you will use Stage Manager after launch?
- Thread starter Melan
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
I tried it for a couple days and it doesn't make any sense to me on Mac. I much prefer Spaces over Stage Manager if I want to focus on one app but most of the time, I just don't work that way and like to have multiple windows showing.
I'm a big fan and user of Spaces/Desktops.
I tried SM during the first two betas but it had quite a few bugs. They've probably been fixed now but I've yet to retry. I'll give it another go at some point after go-live, but there's nothing in my workflow I'm looking to improve so I'll probably end up not using it. But who knows.
I tried SM during the first two betas but it had quite a few bugs. They've probably been fixed now but I've yet to retry. I'll give it another go at some point after go-live, but there's nothing in my workflow I'm looking to improve so I'll probably end up not using it. But who knows.
Don't see what problems it solves, if anything it gets more in the way of getting things done
Probably won’t.
The last version improved. You can now open multiple windows in an app without the previous ones automatically flying off to the side thing whatever it is called.
But the whole experience is just iffy and works even worse on multiple monitors.
The last version improved. You can now open multiple windows in an app without the previous ones automatically flying off to the side thing whatever it is called.
But the whole experience is just iffy and works even worse on multiple monitors.
I just prefer Spaces. It's easy enough to flick between them using the keyboard shortcut or trackpad gesture, each one has its own desktop wallpaper to make it unique, and I can have all the said apps already open in their spaces.
To me Stage Manager makes some sort of sense for iOS (though a lot of work needs to be done; specifically with the amount of dead space wasted due to the lack of freely sizeable windows), and the only reason they've brought it over is for continuity.
Still think they should have designed it into the Dock as well, which would make sense given that is already the area for apps and minimised windows.
To me Stage Manager makes some sort of sense for iOS (though a lot of work needs to be done; specifically with the amount of dead space wasted due to the lack of freely sizeable windows), and the only reason they've brought it over is for continuity.
Still think they should have designed it into the Dock as well, which would make sense given that is already the area for apps and minimised windows.
I've taken to it as a way to subdivide spaces. I have three main spaces on my Mac, which I think of (I wish Apple would let us assign actual names to them) as Personal, Work and A/V.
Personal has a TARDIS blue background and has a couple of different Safari windows, each with a different tab group, and a Stage Manager grouping of Craft and Messages.
My Work space has Outlook, Teams, Firefox and whatever remote desktop sessions I have open, all more of less maximized via Rectangle (which I've configured to leave 100px open on the left so I can see the other apps "offstage."
A/V has Podcasts, Endel and a Safari window with my Media tab group containing Netflix, YouTube, Disney+, HBOmax, Kindle, etc. Sometimes News as well.
The great thing about Stage Manager here is for each space, I can easily see the other apps in just that space off to the left as I work and switch back and forth between them.
The choice isn't Stage Manager or Spaces/Mission Control. They work really well together.
Between Rectangle, Spaces and Mission Control, I honestly can't see why it exists.
I think there was a reason old Apple decided to scrap the idea in 2006.
I think there was a reason old Apple decided to scrap the idea in 2006.
Disclaimer : I have not tried it yet.
If they removed the zoom button and made it a maximize button, and copied Aero Snap from Windows, I'd be much happier about window management in macOS. At least with Magnet I can accomplish the latter.
I might try Stage Manager, but don't think I will use it. The Dock already takes a lot of space, the Menu Bar up a little bit too, adding Stage Manager will not help screen estate optimization at all.
If they removed the zoom button and made it a maximize button, and copied Aero Snap from Windows, I'd be much happier about window management in macOS. At least with Magnet I can accomplish the latter.
I might try Stage Manager, but don't think I will use it. The Dock already takes a lot of space, the Menu Bar up a little bit too, adding Stage Manager will not help screen estate optimization at all.
It’s literally useless to me. It only makes the OS unnecessary more complex and confusing. The idea behind it is probably good but the execution is not great. And you have a button for that when mission control and other stuff is gesture based? Apple needs to think twice before they push something.
Depends on my use case.
I have the 14" Mac Book Pro (M1 Pro) and I disabled it when I'm mobile. I'm usually just focusing on one task at a time in a coffee shop. Be that responding to emails. Online shopping. Social Networking. Creating Music.
However, in clamshell mode at home, I can't live without Stage Manager now. It's a god send for multitasking. Didn't think it would be. But then I didn't go into with any preconceptions. Just switched it on and it got out of my way.
It does help with the fact I have an ultra wide monitor. If I owned a standard 16:9, 16:10 monitor, then I most likely would feel the same as I did when I'm using the 14" screen on the MacBook.
But even if you cover up the icons on the left, you can still see them, exactly the same way you see the dock (if you have auto hide enabled).
So I don't see the issue that people are having with it. To be honest, it's much quicker than going down to the dock, or using a keyboard shortcut because it's much more visual, and so the brain is able to go to exactly what it wants without the mental load.
Just my opinion, by the way, and I'm a bit of a nutcase in life. So, there's that to consider before you get angry at me about my views.
I have the 14" Mac Book Pro (M1 Pro) and I disabled it when I'm mobile. I'm usually just focusing on one task at a time in a coffee shop. Be that responding to emails. Online shopping. Social Networking. Creating Music.
However, in clamshell mode at home, I can't live without Stage Manager now. It's a god send for multitasking. Didn't think it would be. But then I didn't go into with any preconceptions. Just switched it on and it got out of my way.
It does help with the fact I have an ultra wide monitor. If I owned a standard 16:9, 16:10 monitor, then I most likely would feel the same as I did when I'm using the 14" screen on the MacBook.
But even if you cover up the icons on the left, you can still see them, exactly the same way you see the dock (if you have auto hide enabled).
So I don't see the issue that people are having with it. To be honest, it's much quicker than going down to the dock, or using a keyboard shortcut because it's much more visual, and so the brain is able to go to exactly what it wants without the mental load.
Just my opinion, by the way, and I'm a bit of a nutcase in life. So, there's that to consider before you get angry at me about my views.
Thanks for your input. I'm use apps maximized on my MBA 13 so I'm looking forward to having stage manage auto hidden
I like it and will use it any time I'm working on something where I have to move between various apps.