Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

How well does Face ID work for you?

  • Better than Touch ID

    Votes: 36 49.3%
  • About the same as Touch ID

    Votes: 23 31.5%
  • Worse than Touch ID - but good enough

    Votes: 13 17.8%
  • Bad

    Votes: 1 1.4%

  • Total voters
    73

familyman

macrumors newbie
Original poster
Feb 10, 2011
7
1
As a non iPhone X owner, I want some real world feedback on how Face ID has worked in the real world. Is it a pleasant surprise? Is it good enough for you considering the entire package? Are there times that it frustrates you?
 
  • Like
Reactions: dolphin2421
LOVE Face ID when purchasing content from iTunes that require my Credit Card, it will prompt you to double click the power button and it will scan for your face. Very quick and effortless.

As for unlocking the phone. It has been great for the most part. Sometimes it stumbles in poor lighting and certain angles. I re-did my Face ID yesterday as I shaved my beard since Friday, just wanted a more accurate reading of my face programmed in to the phone. But I do hear Face ID learns your face over time, we'll see.

I can't wait to use Face ID for Apple Pay. With the Touch ID my finger would be sweaty sometimes when checking out at the register (Florida life) and Apple Pay would fail. Shouldn't have that problem anymore with Face ID!
 
Face ID is really neat! It has worked great for me so far, a few mess ups but nothing too crazy. Touch ID failed when I didn't have my thumb positioned correctly sometimes so it's about the same.

It's so quick I really don't even notice it happening. By the time I look at the lock at the top of the screen it is already unlocked. Can't wait to see what all we will be able to do with Face ID in the near future. :)
 
My phone came out a real “winner”. The front camera overheated the phone, Face ID didn’t work, but Apple being Apple, gave me a new phone and I must say that Face ID is a real game changer. I feel good knowing that the five tap on the side button disables it.
 
FaceID works really well for me, much better than TouchID ever did. I have however found an issue with getting it to work with my Wayfarer Polarized RayBans. The phone cannot verify me with these sunglasses on. I wonder if it has something to do with the technology and the polarized lense. I have a pair of polarized Oakleys as well that I tried this morning, and that one failed a few times as well at first, but then started to work. I will have to do more testing.
 
I said it was better than Touch ID only because it’s so seamless most of the time.

My experience with Touch ID was great, I didn’t have a lot of fails, and it was pretty instantaneous.

But Face ID is even better. It works very quickly almost every single time, and automatic logging into apps like 1Password is phenomenal. I also love the way it hides and then shows notifications on the lock screen.

And Apple Pay is better, IMO. I ran errands yesterday, and used it in several stores. I much prefer preloading it and then tapping it to the POS system to holding my finger over the home button, which was sometimes awkward.
 
As a non iPhone X owner, I want some real world feedback on how Face ID has worked in the real world. Is it a pleasant surprise? Is it good enough for you considering the entire package? Are there times that it frustrates you?
It is tremendous. Exceeds all expectations. Never frustrates. Way better than touch ID. More leeway with faceID. No more lining up your finger/thumb on the little circle. Just wake phone - swipe up - Bang, you're in. Even better is apps and websites that use it. Just look at your phone on your app that has a login requirement (which you are doing anyway), and it logs you in. It is very sweet and smooth. Goodbye touch ID.
 
  • Like
Reactions: dolphin2421
Prefer it over TouchID vastly. Perfectly happy with never having to use TouchID again.
 
LOVE Face ID when purchasing content from iTunes that require my Credit Card, it will prompt you to double click the power button and it will scan for your face. Very quick and effortless.

As for unlocking the phone. It has been great for the most part. Sometimes it stumbles in poor lighting and certain angles. I re-did my Face ID yesterday as I shaved my beard since Friday, just wanted a more accurate reading of my face programmed in to the phone. But I do hear Face ID learns your face over time, we'll see.

I can't wait to use Face ID for Apple Pay. With the Touch ID my finger would be sweaty sometimes when checking out at the register (Florida life) and Apple Pay would fail. Shouldn't have that problem anymore with Face ID!

Just as an FYI, you don't need to redo FaceID in this situation. If shaving your beard is so dramatic that FaceID won't unlock, it will prompt you for your passcode. Once you enter it correctly the system will know that the new "faceprint" is actually you and will incorporate that into its model. Ideally hahaha
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ntombi
I didn’t think I would prefer it over Touch ID. But I do. Who knew

Also it doesn’t work with one of my pairs of Revo sunglasses but the other pair of Revo is fine lol the other ones are darker that don’t work
 
  • Like
Reactions: dolphin2421
FaceID works really well for me, much better than TouchID ever did. I have however found an issue with getting it to work with my Wayfarer Polarized RayBans. The phone cannot verify me with these sunglasses on. I wonder if it has something to do with the technology and the polarized lense. I have a pair of polarized Oakleys as well that I tried this morning, and that one failed a few times as well at first, but then started to work. I will have to do more testing.

Have you tried turning off "Require Attention for Face ID"? The sunglasses are probably blocking the IR so the system thinks you aren't looking at the screen.

I didn't have any issues with my sunglasses but turned the setting off anyway because I found it annoying to have to look at the screen to unlock. You can still use attention-aware features like screen dimming and notification privacy!
 
  • Like
Reactions: SigEp265
I had a problem with it wearing sunglasses but I think just changing this setting will help that. The attention setting. Probably late to the game but I thought I’d share
 

Attachments

  • 2A81A877-1A9B-413F-A0C7-C3A575FB2A9F.png
    2A81A877-1A9B-413F-A0C7-C3A575FB2A9F.png
    584.9 KB · Views: 108
Just wondering what everyone's experience is with the speed of unlocking with Face ID.

I pick my phone up, swipe up immediately and I see the Face ID text and full pad lock unlock animation before it fully unlocks.

Is that normal or is that slow?
 
I’ve found Face ID to work in only about 75% of the scenarios where Touch ID would always work.

It’s most frustrating in the car where I have my phone in a mount. I’m constantly using Waze and Google Maps, as well as taking pictures while driving for my job (real estate). The phone is just far enough away for Face ID to not register my face. I was used to unlocking with my fingerprint and not having to take my eyes off the road while doing so. Face ID is causing a major distraction for me and making my job more difficult.

I’m considering going back to my 7 for this reason alone.
 
  • Like
Reactions: terandle
Love it. I was reluctant going into the X, because I really liked TID. I don’t think I’ve had a failed FID login. Feels faster to me. The phone feels like it doesn’t have a passcode/lock.
 
For me it’s worked so much better than expected. So far the only miss has been when I tried to unlock and I was yawning.
I think the biggest adjustment has been no home button. 10 years of undoing that learned behavior will take some time.
 
It works as much as touchID with a few exceptions

1. Laying down in bed / waking up
2. Bathroom is steamy from shower (this one isn’t really a factor since I could never use touchID right after a shower)
3. Really bright sun on my face in the car
 
It is slower than Touch ID when unlocking from black screen. But it is more convenient, as you can privatize notifications so only it shows when you look at it. It also does output sound for notification when someone is looking at it, which is nice. Also, since only one Face can be stored, people can't ask to add their face to your phone. It totally your privacy.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.