Oh dear oh dear.
Apple have finally realised they need to provide a platform for discovering, manipulating and sharing data across their sandboxed OS to make the iPAD a credible data management and editing device. This was good timing having released 512GB iPAD Pro.
Sadly, their first attempt is a lot worse than just useless. I say this because it promises enough to get people excited and wanting to try it but then fails to deliver in almost all areas. I'm flabergasted it can be this bad.
The objective was to provide a flat interface onto all files stored on the device (across all apps) and stored in the major cloud collaboration services. Beyond that it would should enable search and drag / drop across all of these.
So, what does it offer ?
Firstly, even though I have the latest office 365 suite installed and have docs / spreadsheets / presentations / notes, under 'On My iPAD' there is nothing at all shown.
As it stands, beyond this in the productivity area, I have Pixelmator, PhatPad, NotesPlus, AwesomeNote, Voice Recorder and iProjectViewer. Under Pixelmator, there is just the Pixelmator folder (I have created nothing there yet so no surprise). There are no entries for any of these other apps.
Furthermore, as everyone who was honest would agree, the ability to share pictures, videos and audio files has always been weak to the point of impossible. You need iTunes that only runs on certain devices and it's management is awful. Where is the Photos folder, the Videos folder, the Music folder, the Voice Recorder folder ? These are just jpg, png, mp4, m4a, mp3 files. Why wouldn't you want to see them all in one place, browse them, drag and drop them to other apps ? Of course you would - that is the whole point of a creativity device and I understood (perhaps wrongly) the whole point of finally enabling a files capability.
We are not talking about full file management. I knew we wouldn't get that because of the OS architecture, but there is no reason on earth why a flattened view of all On My iPAD files with basic meta data and full drag and drop shouldn't be possible on day one. Even if it worked for a few key apps like Office, that would be something, although without consistency, it would prove very irritating. Apple have access (like no one else) to the Sandbox for all apps. Unless a app developer did something proprietary encryption or created a db using non standard methods to store it's local files, Apple should have access to it.
That's just the On My iPAD piece. Now let's look at cloud.
I have personal Dropbox. That just pops up the Dropbox viewer over files, so there is no apparent integration. It doesn't even let you drag and drop a file from that Dropbox window to the other folders (cloud and On My iPAD) under files. What is the point - you get people excited, waste time and offer nothing - as I said, actually a lot worse that useless.
I have corporate Box. This is via single sign on like most would have for business use. Every time I click the Box location, it says Authentication Required. When I do that sign in, it gives a full window Box display with an arrow to take me back to Files - again, it just launches with no integration and no drag and drop ability. As I say, each time I try box again, it says I'm not authenticated. Worse than useless.
Filebrowser. Fantastic app, just like GoodReader. When you select this it says either Share with Apps or Network Folders. For the former a pop up comes up saying there are no files in the Share with Apps location and asks me to use FileBrowser to copy files to that location. The whole point here is that you should be creating dozens of staging copies to share files. Apple should enforce this as a basic capability unless there is a security focus with certain apps that have a good reason to block sharing otherwise, Files isn't of any use. For the latter (Network Folders) you pushed to buy an upgrade to FileBrowser. I assume, like the cloud apps, this will just be a launch of FileBrowser and therefore not a flat searchable view of all my files - so of no use to anyone.
Why can't Apple have an option that enables viewing of all repositories across all apps. They've forced people to move to 64 bit apps so why not force all apps to use storage repositories compatible with Files ? There really isn't any excuse. This would also mean app providers didn't need to register with Files - it would just work - i.e. consistency. It doesn't.
I'm sorry, but this is utterly indefensible. Part of the reason for getting my 10.5" Pro was because I thought Apple had finally woken up. Clearly they haven't.
Paul
[doublepost=1506083588][/doublepost]And this is the whole point. Word etc is the defacto standard whether Apple like it or not. If you can't search, display and drag drop all files types using Files it renders the iPAD (of which I have 7 in the family inc the 10.5 Pro) as next to useless. You shouldn't have different ways of doing the same thing with different apps. It shoudn't matter if it's a just taken photo roll picture, an audio recording, a music file, a note, a drawing or a productivity file - it should just work. This is why contrary to what people like to say, Apple iOS devices are actually very hard to use for anything other than basic Apple owned app media viewing. Very disappointed.
