I have zero lag on mine. Just saying. QuickTime and Safari works flawlessly. Maybe it is another application not working well?
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
How to Use Two HomePods With a Mac for Stereo Audio Output
- Thread starter MacRumors
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
It’s works great on my Mac. No lag at all. I seriously believe that either people are having a problem with third party software or they are creating a false narrative
What are you talking about. My HomePods and HomePods mini work fine. 1). Your wifi crowded or experiencing interference? 2) Third party software written poorly?
I’d look at your wifi first, too many devices? Band interference. When people are using wifi to support video calls, other devices get stutter. Overall my experience is superb, that says to me, what is not working in your setup?
You can play to an AirPlay device from a Mac running Big Sur without a 2-second lag?
I am very curious. What OS version and Safari version are you using ?
Did you try youtube for instance ? I would be very happy if it is possible to fix this!
What I meant it uses airplay 1 as main output so there is a delay using it and you also can’t use multiple outputs like homepods and other speakers at same time
Well I thought the latest HomePod mini Home app. update would fix the M1 MacMini lag with my stereo HomePodMini set up. At first it seemed it did, but I was wrong. As reported I have to re-boot my computer and quickly choose the HomePodMini's with Safari for videos. Otherwise the actors lips won't synch with the sound.
I love the rich sound of these things for music, and of course the Siri thing. But issues with video via Safari (Hulu/HBOMAX/AppleTV+) is really a deal breaker! I should just install my old Bowers & Wilkins MM1 computer speakers and be done with it.
If anyone has a solution please speak out. Many thanks!!!
I love the rich sound of these things for music, and of course the Siri thing. But issues with video via Safari (Hulu/HBOMAX/AppleTV+) is really a deal breaker! I should just install my old Bowers & Wilkins MM1 computer speakers and be done with it.
If anyone has a solution please speak out. Many thanks!!!
Has this issue been fixed, namely the delay when playing YouTube videos? Either in Big Sur or in Monterey? https://www.macrumors.com/2021/06/15/macos-monterey-airplay-2-demo/
Maybe you don't understand the issue, but are fast to make your own conclusions about other people making false narrative. The issue lies with system wide settings. When you select HomePod as your sound output like this:
Go ahead, try it. And then play anything, you can even play video in QuickTime and sound will lag behind video when skipping ahead or when you pause it sound will continue for another 2 seconds or so.
But when you select HomePod directly inside for example Music app, the aforementioned lag is not there.
I have Mac Mini M1. And no, wi-fi is not really an issue as it works with my iPhone without any issues (i.e. sending sound from Safari to my HomePod works without any lag whatsoever).
It's a longstanding macOS issue. And it's a known fact that macOS uses AirPlay 1 for system wide sound output but was said to move to AirPlay 2 (lag free) in Monterey (or was it Big Sur even?), but hasn't done so as it's still broken in macOS 12.0.1.
Besides, unless I'm missing something, Control Center on macOS doesn't let you join multiple devices, another telltale sign that this isn't AirPlay 2.
To be pedantic, AirPlay 2 isn't lag-free. AirPlay 1 had a constant lag of exactly 2 seconds. AirPlay 2 instead negotiates the minimum viable lag between all connected devices (which is typically way below 2s), then uses that.
To be pedantic, AirPlay 2 isn't lag-free. AirPlay 1 had a constant lag of exactly 2 seconds. AirPlay 2 instead negotiates the minimum viable lag between all connected devices (which is typically way below 2s), then uses that.
Well, select the stereo pair as the output options. works everywhere. Select stereo pair from Apple Music. works great (although why use airplay, when you can just control the stereo pair and play direct, but it does work). I am running Ventura developer Beta, don't remember when it started working, but some time ago
"
Maybe you don't understand the issue, but are fast to make your own conclusions about other people making false narrative. The issue lies with system wide settings. When you select HomePod as your sound output like this:"
No I do understand, thanks for condescension though.
I select stereo pair in system settings. Maybe your problem is your settings are only showing 1 mini, not a stereo pair.
I'm at the latest OS for everything. If the "Stereo Pair" doesn't work properly for everything that outputs audio (Zoom, FT, System sounds, etc) not just a small subset of streaming apps where a "delay" doesn't matter - then it's not really "fixed" and they aren't truly 100% usable as Mac speakers. A sad state after all these years.
Still an issue. Just received my HomePod (2nd Generation) yesterday and was surprised about this lag, which occurs only when the macOS system output is set to the HomePod.
If the content itself (eg. Youtube player in Safari) is set to airplay to the HomePod - it works without a lag.
In general, that works for me, however i'm annoyed by the fact that i can't control the volume from my keyboard - currently trying to figure out some workaround. So far I've found an open source app called Volume Control, but it does not work for Safari. Essentially i would like to bind the system volume to the HomePod volume (eg. via automation, scripting, program or whatever) so when i change the macOS volume or mute/unmute it - it would adjust the HomePod volume respectively.
If the content itself (eg. Youtube player in Safari) is set to airplay to the HomePod - it works without a lag.
In general, that works for me, however i'm annoyed by the fact that i can't control the volume from my keyboard - currently trying to figure out some workaround. So far I've found an open source app called Volume Control, but it does not work for Safari. Essentially i would like to bind the system volume to the HomePod volume (eg. via automation, scripting, program or whatever) so when i change the macOS volume or mute/unmute it - it would adjust the HomePod volume respectively.
Might worth reporting here. I finally got HomePod minis work as my Mac speaker without of any lag in any applications!!!
I happen to use a TV with eARC support (LG C2 42) as my main monitor for my Mac, and I'm having an Apple TV 4k sit on my desk for over a year.
Since apple releases the eARC support for Apple TV, I'm able to add my HomePods as the default speakers and passing all audio from my TV through ATV.
This works smoothly without any noticeable lag, movies, YouTube, zoom, etc. Everything works!
Give it a go if you have similar setup.
I happen to use a TV with eARC support (LG C2 42) as my main monitor for my Mac, and I'm having an Apple TV 4k sit on my desk for over a year.
Since apple releases the eARC support for Apple TV, I'm able to add my HomePods as the default speakers and passing all audio from my TV through ATV.
This works smoothly without any noticeable lag, movies, YouTube, zoom, etc. Everything works!
Give it a go if you have similar setup.
Does it work for "system sounds" too? If so, glad you have it working, but you have to admit it's a pretty specialized setup to make it work.
My beloved Bose companion 5 set up from 2009 have just broken and I'm gutted! Does anyone still recommend the home pods as a computer speaker option? its annoying it doesn't play any computer sounds through them although a minor issue I suppose.