I'm still sorta wondering why you would need a dual core processor to run a file server, unless you're setting it up as a processing farm for graphics, etc.
Still, it both looks and sounds pretty awesome.
They say they are taking "pre-orders" now, anyone know when this is going to ship?
HP EX49x seem like nice products, but like others have said, I want Apple's product. I am hoping Time Capsule is Apple's way of testing the water. With many households having multiple computers, I think the time is right for home server. My list of features:
- iTunes Home Sharing server
- iCal Server (CalDAV) for centralizing calendar events
- Address Book Server (CardDAV) for centralizing address book
- Time Machine backup
- AirPort disk
- Printer sharing
- MobileMe integration
- 4 hotswappable internal SATA drive bays
- 2 USB ports, 802.11n, gigabit ethernet
- Streaming to Apple TV
Apple sells that. It's called an XServe.
Well I have had both in the house and the Thecus N5200 Pro just was not a good fit at all.
Price wise vs hardware I have to argue with you a bit.
The hardware is much better in the HP media 490 series even the 48x series is much better.
For functions like encoding when not backing up that 1.5 Ghz celeron M is just too slow. Take that and pair it to 512K ram and you have a really slow machine. Now I know you don't need power in your server rig but it is nice to have a little more power when you need it. I would even forgive this horrible setup if it was a silent machine but it was about twice as loud as my HP mediasmart 485.
The internet interface was horrible in my opinion and nothing close to the ease of the hp interface.
Price: well I will just use newegg as a standard
Thecus pro= $649.99 no hard drive
HP Mediasmart 490=$549.99 with 1 TB
In addition for any redundancy in the NAS you need at least 2 Hard drives.
I like to come to the forum and help people make an informed decision as well.
I see your point, but the HP 47x series is really old hardware. Sure it is easy to upgrade the software side but the server is going to run like a pig. The hp 48x series has a faster processor (celeron 2 Ghz) and 2 gb of memory. It can handle the new software and functions much better. The hp 47x series was a first attempt at backing up people's computers with relative ease. It worked very well for that function. Software update 2.5 brought video encoding and streaming into the server. The old 512K of ram and 1.8 Ghz sempron processor just can't cut it. HP should have come out and stated they will not be upgrading the software due to hardware limitations. I mean the new 490 only has the celeron 2.2Ghz 64bit processor and everything else is the same. There is no reason to not allow the 48x customers to update.
A purpose build home storage server is still a very much of a niche product. Between the Time Capsule and Mini, Apple has the bases covered.
A combined TC/Mini type product is unlikely to sell in large numbers, and I just don't see Apple making anything like that in the foreseeable future.
Hi
Does anyone have experience yet of how well this server works with AppleTV? Like many others I would like to export all my iLife media to this server and then consume it seemlessly from iTunes & iPhoto "client" on my main Mac, from an AppleTV box, from an Airport Express (for audio of course, using iTunes client on Mac or iPod Touch Remote control) etc.
Can anyone advise if this box is the magic bullet?
Also I would like to ensure that any iTunes Account purchases (my wife and I have our own iTunes Store accounts and seperate user accounts on the main Mac) are all sync/copied over to the server and freely accessable on my max. five Apple consuming devices.
Hope someone can clarify this! ;-)
Cheers
PS: Sorry - maybe about to answer my own question. A little more reading leads me to think no ;-(. The issue is that AppleTV and iPhone / iPodTouch register with an iTunes application (running on Mac or Win) and not with the embedded third party "iTunes Server". So unless / until HP can duplicate this functionality from iTunes application - or Apple beat HP at this game, its no HP MediaSmart for me ;-( And I have even warmed up by CreditCard!!
This is where Apple should go.
For years people here have been asking for a mid tower system, TC is too small, do not have all the same services of the HP, OSX Server (unlimited license) is now only 499.
Making a system based on OSX Server with media streaming and everything else that comes with the OSX Server, would address the needs of small companies and also address the home market. It would also provide TM backup of downstream workstations and full user authorization to files and features. But one thing will be needed ...... The box would need to come with two gigabit ethernet ports so it can be used as a firewall.
I would pickup 2 of them, one for a Firewall and another for internal media server, file server and anything else. $800-900 pricepoint would do for me.
Will you listen Apple?
After an external hard drive failure, I got the following to backup all 4 bays of my Mac Pro. So far, so good, I can back up everything in all 4 bays with one click in Time Machine and it's expandable--right now, 4 1.5 TB SATA drives (good enough to back up 4 TB of total potential data) back up about 1.4 TB of actual data. Not bad.
What do people think of this?
www.drobo.com
This can all be done very easily with current hardware (or much older?...), it's just a software issue.
Looking at the features most people want, it seems that a simple itunes server option would cover a lot of it. I also think your price point is far too high considering what you're actually asking for, and I'm not a fan (at all...) of osx server.
I don't use itunes/time machine (but it's easy enough to get the library/image shared if that's all your after - if you can use google), and use freenas and monowall/pfsense on various boxes for a 'server' and firewalls - perhaps an option you could consider? Free and 'better', assuming you're top purchasing priorities aren't a shiny and branded aluminium box with a limited (but one-click) use![]()
Hi
Does anyone have experience yet of how well this server works with AppleTV? Like many others I would like to export all my iLife media to this server and then consume it seemlessly from iTunes & iPhoto "client" on my main Mac, from an AppleTV box, from an Airport Express (for audio of course, using iTunes client on Mac or iPod Touch Remote control) etc.
Can anyone advise if this box is the magic bullet?
Also I would like to ensure that any iTunes Account purchases (my wife and I have our own iTunes Store accounts and seperate user accounts on the main Mac) are all sync/copied over to the server and freely accessable on my max. five Apple consuming devices.
Hope someone can clarify this! ;-)
Cheers
PS: Sorry - maybe about to answer my own question. A little more reading leads me to think no ;-(. The issue is that AppleTV and iPhone / iPodTouch register with an iTunes application (running on Mac or Win) and not with the embedded third party "iTunes Server". So unless / until HP can duplicate this functionality from iTunes application - or Apple beat HP at this game, its no HP MediaSmart for me ;-( And I have even warmed up by CreditCard!!
Hey everybody, some good discussion here. I wanted to clarify a couple points I saw mentioned. HP have committed to providing the 3.0 software for previous generations of the MediaSmart Server, so yes, present owners of the EX47x and EX48x should be able to get perform this update in the Fall. As for availability, they are available for pre-order now and I believe they will be available in October. Another bit of good news is that the servers will once again be available in Europe.
I've got all this info and a ton more in my review, if anyone is looking for more details. Thanks for the link in the blog post.
http://www.mediasmartserver.net/2009/09/14/review-hp-mediasmart-server-ex490-and-ex495/
If you dig around on wegotserved.net, they have a guide showing how to install the 2.x updates on the 47x series
RudolfOSX said:Does anyone have experience yet of how well this server works with AppleTV?
Great to hear you got the 2.5 update working well, the tutorial and Add-In that Nigel Wilks and myself wrote is available here.
We've got an excellent Wiki article on getting the Apple TV working with your Windows Home Server, I'd suggest checking into this before you make your final decision. We've also got discussion in the forums about installing iTunes 9 on the Server and the users experiences after doing so.
I WANT THIS.
I don't give a flip if Apple wants to make one. Why sould I care? This seems to do everything I want (I'm still reading, not positive yet) and it seems to play nice with my Mac!
Why shouldn't I just get one of these?
EDIT: Ok, it still looks good, but I'm not clear why I would buy one of these over a Drobo. It's cheaper and I guess it does less...? But I'm not seeing any reason I'd need this HP machine over that.
Still, looks good overall. I guess it's just overkill for me.
Great to hear you got the 2.5 update working well, the tutorial and Add-In that Nigel Wilks and myself wrote is available here.