Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

How long will it last

  • 3 years or less

    Votes: 27 61.4%
  • More than 3 years

    Votes: 17 38.6%

  • Total voters
    44
You heard it from me first.

Truly a gimmick.
Absolutely! Steve Jobs was a minimalist and aesthetics queen who didn't like buttons, battery doors, and ports and his main goal was to remove as much as possible from the iPhone (all Apple devices really)...and he's rolling in his grave as we speak.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: LoveToMacRumors
A big issue for me is that it’s essentially in the exact same place as the volume up button, just on the other side. But it’s also flush with the phone making it harder to actually press without shaking the camera. As just a shutter button, I think the volume up is superior. Launching the camera is great but it requires 2 clicks of the button from screen off. Whereas last year you could just set the camera to the action button right beside the volume up. Hold the action button once and you’re in the camera then hit volume up to snap a picture.

In reality, both of these buttons are annoying because one you have to double click to launch the camera and the other you have to hold to launch the camera.

But my accidental zooms trying to snap a pic with the Camera Control is making me appreciate the Action button / volume up combo from last year that I never used.

Mainly I had high hopes for camera control because I shoot vertical video for work all day and the Action button was useless for that. It works well for launching the camera vertically but after that I can hold the phone more stable by just hitting record on the screen.
When you use the volume buttons, the cameras are in the worst spot, the same spot that your fingers are. If you try to hold it so your fingers are not in the way, then the power button is going to be in the way. The camera control makes it so you don’t need to think about it.

Also, the action button can take pictures if you have it set to camera. No need to use the volume buttons.
 
  • Like
Reactions: QquegChristian
The iPhone is portrait, it just is, and the iPhone changed the world. You can hold it landscape and you do on YouTube when you’re getting invested, but… day to day… you hold the iPhone vertically.

I say this as a director and cinematographer of award-winning movies who absolutely despised vertical video.

Now I work in marketing shooting vertical video for Fortune500 brands. What I shoot primarily goes to TikTok or IG reels. It’s meant to be viewed on your phone, held vertical. It’s a different medium but it’s still a medium. Do I want to rotate my phone every time I open Instagram? No. So we adapt.

Last week I had to film a video both vertically for TikTok and horizontally for a YouTube version and it was funny because I’ve honed vertical video so well that the horizontal version was awful. I’d adapted to telling the story in a vertical frame and had a very hard time fitting it in focus horizontally.

I would have never imagined that in the past. I’m the snooty film guy. I shot my last movie in 2:35.1 in 8k raw redcode that I only let go through 1 generation loss before the 4K master out of DaVinci Resolve.

Now I make TikToks on salary and make way more money than I ever did in actual film. The “Pro” in iPhone Pro covers a lot more use cases than meets the eye.
I hear you. I guess it's all what you're used to.

I work for a Fortune 100 company. For about 15 years now, we've had an edict that any PowerPoint presentations we build for internal meetings have to be in portrait format - basically, any presentation that's going to spark meaningful back-and-forth discussion and that might end up on paper has to be in portrait. (If it's more of a PR-type presentation, internal or external, that's primarily going to be projected, then that's going to still be in landscape.)

Switching to portrait after years of doing slides in landscape was really difficult. We had to completely rethink how we built slides. But now it's second-nature.

The funny thing is that we have a number of joint ventures with international partners, and each of them appears to do everything in landscape within their own companies; for our JV presentations, we have deferred to them and continue to do those in landscape. It's a pain, especially when your boss says, "You know that great slide you made for our internal presentation? Can you redo it in landscape for the JV deck?" Argh! Things never fit just right and it just looks weird!

To this day I pretty much refuse to browse Instagram because I prefer photos in landscape format. I like to do most of my photo browsing on the larger iPad screen, and the iPad pretty much begs to be used in landscape, at least with the case/stand I use. So I shoot most of my photos in landscape mode as well - plus I take photos of scenery more than I do people. Both my wife and I dislike having our pictures taken... We never seem to know how to smile for the camera and always seem to look uncomfortable in the resulting photos!
 
Came here to say something similar. Most people are taking photos and videos vertically (portrait mode), so they won’t even consider using the button.
There are plenty of people who are not like that. I don't really shoot video, but if I did, I would do it in landscape format, because TV screens. I shoot 90% of my photos in landscape as well because the screens I view them on - iPad, TV, MacBook, external monitor - are set up in such a way that the photos will be bigger on those screens when they are in landscape rather than portrait.
 
AR/VR is niche. It will stay niche as long as it's distinguishable from a pair on normal day-to-day glasses. The 16 pro will be obsolete before that happens.

Not all photos are meant to be taken horizontally. Portraits definitely aren't.
Agree that plain portraits, with nothing in the background, should be taken vertically. If you want to capture both a person's face and something interesting in the background, however, landscape is the way to go, as far as I'm concerned.
 
made some pictures today (landscape) and it felt like the most natural way to take pictures.

not sure if i'll use it for portrait though. but i rarely take pictures that way.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Chateaunole-du-Pape
I'm fine with the camera button, but why make it so complicated instead of the standard and simple two stage hard shutter button (half press to focus, full press to take picture) like dedicated cameras?
 
  • Like
Reactions: unchecked
I’m actually finding this to be better than having the adjustment controls enabled. I find those quirky to use. Having it as a single button to launch, and then snap the photos, is better for me.

Settings > Accessibility > Camera Control

1726952455832.png
 
It would have been cool if they added touch id to it as a 2nd layer of security for those who want it.

Otherwise I don't really have anything against it. From the reviews it seems a little "clunky" the way it responds, seems it could have been a little longer to be able to select more things with one swipe or zoom more in one swipe.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LoveToMacRumors
Yeah your opinion. Then just dont use it and stop whining.
Its not like it prevents you from doing something. Plenty of people like it, me included.

Deal with it.
it prevents me from enjoying the phone to the best of my ability. every time i pick it up i notice the button. its annoying af
 
  • Like
Reactions: MacBookPro88
It is a little gimmacky tbh but I don't hate it. I wish it were closer to the bottom edge of the phone as it isn't exactly in the most ergonomic position for swiping / pressing in landscape use.
 
The placement doesn’t make sense for a fingerprint sensor.
My xperia Z5 had the finger print sensor integrated in the power button. Best solution ever and so much more comfortable than the home button touch ID. Still miss it to this day.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Chuckeee
As mentioned in a previous post, it's clear that Ive is long gone, as the engineers have usurped the design team.

Not that an evolving engineered phone with updated functional features isn't required as technology allows and advances, but the action button seemed half baked idea and just tacked on last year by engineers who frustratingly needed more functionality, and the camera control button this year is again an answer to a question no one really asked.

My guess is one of those button will be gone in 3 years.
Engineers arent the ones coming up with the ideas or looking for new features to sell the phones. Those would be the designers and marketeers.
They are the people that engineer the feature others have requested.
 
Haven’t used it yet but I like the idea. It seems like the fastest way to recording a moment. Also I believe it allows you to fully use the camera with one hand since otherwise you need two hands to zoom.
Not best for every situation maybe. It doesn’t seem like a practical location for taking photos in vertical orientation.
Not sure if this is already possible, but I wish I could set the slider to always zoom since I don’t really mess with other adjustments.
Also I always slightly move the camera whenever I press a shutter button, so I wish I could set it so that resting my finger on the button for 3 seconds would take the picture.
 
I don’t know what everyone is so damn upset about, I love this button. The swipe feature has been great for me too, I just leave it on the lens switcher.

Im going on a trip Monday, can’t wait to use this thing non stop next week. It truly is a great addition. And on the pro max feels like it’s in a good spot to me, for landscape id probably only want it very slightly closer to the bottom.
 
I've been trying to use the new shutter button and I'm extremely disappointed, as others mentioned it's actually more work to use than the default way.

The biggest deal-breaker is that it requires too much force to click. I find two issues here:

1. The extra pressure required causes the phone to shake slightly with each press, increasing the risk of getting a more blurry photo.
2. The force needed makes it annoying to use repeatedly, especially when taking multiple shots or angles.

I find that using the regular/default digital shutter is so much effortless and comfortable .

Then the swipe functionality and having to double-tap to switch modes is so frustrating and unnecessary. There is an entire 6.3" or 6.9" gorgeous touch-screen, why force users to double tap of on a gimmick button to switch modes when it could be done so much quicker with the screen?

The only advantage I see so far is using it to launch the camera app, that's it.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.