I have the original iPad. The iPad 2 and the new iPad. The new iPad is by far the best and clearest picture of them all. Until you compare them side by side you will never know. I use my new iPad all day and have no idea about any heat issue. The screen itself is worth the extra 100 dollars. I'm sorry but I think the new iPad is amazing.
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
I went with an iPad2. Did I make the right decision?
- Thread starter ozziegn
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
A great many posters here, just post to bitch.With all the items sold by Apple, something has to be unacceptable, or they would be made by God. Problems arise, send it back, let Apple make it right, then move on, poor them, the complainers, they got a Lemon, life deals us all varying degrees of adversity, if yours is only a problem with your Apple product, as annoying as it is, pull up your big boy pants,deal with it and move on
Maybe its my eyes.. but I have to say I have to look hard to see a huge difference between the screens.
I have an iPad2 and went to BestBuy ready to get the iPad3 because my wife wanted mine.
I compared and compared and unless I am looking at photographs that have been zoomed in I really cant see a huge difference. Even websites unless I enlarge the letters I cant tell that much difference.
Sure its nicer but to say "wow" or all the hype that Apple is putting in I am not sold on it.
I can actually tell the difference MUCH more in the iPad3 camera (although I have yet to use mine on the iPad2 in real life)
Also I do notice the extra thickness and weight.. i am sure unless you are comparing specifically you will not notice this after a while.. but then again I think its the same for the screen
I have an iPad2 and went to BestBuy ready to get the iPad3 because my wife wanted mine.
I compared and compared and unless I am looking at photographs that have been zoomed in I really cant see a huge difference. Even websites unless I enlarge the letters I cant tell that much difference.
Sure its nicer but to say "wow" or all the hype that Apple is putting in I am not sold on it.
I can actually tell the difference MUCH more in the iPad3 camera (although I have yet to use mine on the iPad2 in real life)
Also I do notice the extra thickness and weight.. i am sure unless you are comparing specifically you will not notice this after a while.. but then again I think its the same for the screen
Last edited:
Maybe its my eyes.. but I have to say I have to look hard to see a huge difference between the screens.
I have an iPad2 and went to BestBuy ready to get the iPad3 because my wife wanted mine.
I compared and compared and unless I am looking at photographs that have been zoomed in I really cant see a huge difference. Even websites unless I enlarge the letters I cant tell that much difference.
Sure its nicer but to say "wow" or all the hype that Apple is putting in I am not sold on it.
I can actually tell the difference MUCH more in the iPad3 camera (although I have yet to use min on the iPad2 in real life)
Also I do notice the extra thickness and weight.. i am sure unless you are comparing specifically you will not notice this after a while.. but then again I think its the same for the screen
If I look closely at icons on the home screen and the fonts I can easily tell that ipad 2 is pixelly. but it still has a beautiful screen. it's just not high res.
Exactly.. you have to look for it and look closely. And if I am looking for will likely notice it in some cases.
In everyday use I am not "looking" for it. Yes the screen is better but certainly not night and day or a whole new user experience like some people on the forums imply.
Last edited:
I don't even need to try at all and I can tell the difference right away. To each there own but for me personally it was money well spent.
Wish more answers were like this rather than "You made a terrible/horrible decision" "You'll regret it".
It ultimately depends on what you want and how you will use it. For me, i just bought a refurb ipad 2, $168 cheaper than buying a new ipad (here in canada) and to me, the price difference was not justified because i won't really take advantage of the retina display, won't ever use the camera on my ipad because i have an iphone4 anyways. I don't read PDFs, don't read books, don't store any photos on the ipad and none of my movies/tv shows are 720P, much less 1080 or bluray quality. And to me, the iPad is simply a toy i use maybe 3 hours a week and when travelling. I don't feel the need to spend more than $500 on an item for that.
lol hell no you did not make the right decision
you bought something vastly inferior when you had the option not to. quite foolish imo.
lol - I guess here's where I'd need the "read the thread" icon to post on your reply.
This is what you think now, I suggest you try the new iPad and let it do the talking. For one thing, the battery is better than the iPad 2 imo, I charge mine every 3 days or so, and it depends on what brightness you use. I use around 30-50%. It is plenty for me, even in the bright sunlight. As well, the new iPad does run hotter, but can you tell the difference? Usually no, unless you run really graphic demanding apps/games. And then things get scambled when you say the screen is not a big deal I must say, the new Retina Display is what defines the new iPad, it an awesome sight for reading and browsing through the web without things being pixelated. And then the camera, well the back camera blows the iPad 2's camera out the water that is a very big given imo. And then the front has no change, although I have not used it once since I have gotten my iPad.
Very glad to read you went with the iPad 3. It's a much better decision, you are already spending $400, why not another $100 for a vastly superior version?
I'm sorry $100/$400 is a 25% premium over the iPad 2. It not a 'no brainer' especially if price was a factor for the OP. Then again if it was, he should have bought a refurbished one for $350.
Last edited:
Agreed. I have iPad 3 and love it however for someone who isn't going to be using it for reading then ipad2 is fine. It's - ipad2- better than any other tablet out there and at a reasonable price.
The problem with a thread like this is that people will give you an answer which is designed to justify their own purchase. Nobody likes to feel that they've made a bad decision.
My situation, is that I took my iPad 3 back to Apple for a refund at the weekend, because I didn't feel that there was enough of a leap between it and my iPad 2. The Apple employee that processed my refund seemed to agree, saying that she had not made the jump from iPad 1 for the same reason.
In truth, the screen is slightly nicer, but in my opinion, that is due to the colour saturation as much as the resolution.
As someone else said in this thread, people were more than happy with the iPad 2 screen a month ago, and the other so-called improvements in the iPad 3 are very slight.
I suppose it boils down to how much disposable income you have, and whether you feel you'd rather have a slightly higher resolution screen on your iPad or an extra £100 in your bank account for other things.
My situation, is that I took my iPad 3 back to Apple for a refund at the weekend, because I didn't feel that there was enough of a leap between it and my iPad 2. The Apple employee that processed my refund seemed to agree, saying that she had not made the jump from iPad 1 for the same reason.
In truth, the screen is slightly nicer, but in my opinion, that is due to the colour saturation as much as the resolution.
As someone else said in this thread, people were more than happy with the iPad 2 screen a month ago, and the other so-called improvements in the iPad 3 are very slight.
I suppose it boils down to how much disposable income you have, and whether you feel you'd rather have a slightly higher resolution screen on your iPad or an extra £100 in your bank account for other things.
iPad 2 Screen = Mud
I bought the iPad 2 a couple of weeks ago, before I had the chance to actually physically try an iPad 3.
Then at work we got our iPad 3 demo model in, after I spent all of 20 seconds with it I knew I had made the wrong decision buying an iPad 2...
eBayed my iPad 2 lost 30$ and bought an iPad 3 through work so didn't actually lose any $ - To me the screen on the iPad 3 is exceptional, the screen on the 2 looks like mud in comparison.
When I look at my MacBook Air 11 screen it also looks pretty average when compared to the iPad 3.... Timmy bring on the retina display laptops please...
I bought the iPad 2 a couple of weeks ago, before I had the chance to actually physically try an iPad 3.
Then at work we got our iPad 3 demo model in, after I spent all of 20 seconds with it I knew I had made the wrong decision buying an iPad 2...
eBayed my iPad 2 lost 30$ and bought an iPad 3 through work so didn't actually lose any $ - To me the screen on the iPad 3 is exceptional, the screen on the 2 looks like mud in comparison.
When I look at my MacBook Air 11 screen it also looks pretty average when compared to the iPad 3.... Timmy bring on the retina display laptops please...
The other day, a coworker handed me their iPad 2 to get his email configured correctly.
I have the iPad 3 (my first and only iPad), and I immediately noticed the pixels -- pixels everywhere! -- on the iPad 2. The 3's Retina screen truly does spoil you, and going back is hard.
I won't say the iPad 2 is a bad device, hardly... it is a great piece of hardware at a great price. The 3 is even better, but there are some concerns: price for one, and also the quality of some display elements/assembly (screens with hues, backlight bleeds, etc.).
I have the iPad 3 (my first and only iPad), and I immediately noticed the pixels -- pixels everywhere! -- on the iPad 2. The 3's Retina screen truly does spoil you, and going back is hard.
I won't say the iPad 2 is a bad device, hardly... it is a great piece of hardware at a great price. The 3 is even better, but there are some concerns: price for one, and also the quality of some display elements/assembly (screens with hues, backlight bleeds, etc.).
Let's get one thing straight. For anyone looking at the iPad and doesn't want to go all out to splash cash on it, the iPad 2 is perfect.
Especially if you're new to the iOS ecosystem. For us who came from the iPhone, it makes sense to go for the newer iPad. As some have said already, the screen and thinness make the iPad 2 brilliant for any newcomer. Use the $100 for apps as you'll then have a good basis to look at the iPad 4. Skipping a generation of Apple products is always a wise move as the major improvements come every 2 generations.
iPad > iPad 3
iPad 2 > iPad 4
Especially if you're new to the iOS ecosystem. For us who came from the iPhone, it makes sense to go for the newer iPad. As some have said already, the screen and thinness make the iPad 2 brilliant for any newcomer. Use the $100 for apps as you'll then have a good basis to look at the iPad 4. Skipping a generation of Apple products is always a wise move as the major improvements come every 2 generations.
iPad > iPad 3
iPad 2 > iPad 4