Hookemfins
macrumors 6502
Disagree. I think SugarSync has the best interface and the absolute best of all the cloud services. If I didn't have one drive as part of Microsoft 360 and wanted to pay for cloud service, SugarSync would be the one.
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
iCloud Drive vs Google Drive, OneDrive, DropBox, and others
- Thread starter moonman239
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
Disagree. I think SugarSync has the best interface and the absolute best of all the cloud services. If I didn't have one drive as part of Microsoft 360 and wanted to pay for cloud service, SugarSync would be the one.
OneDrive for me, the Office Web Apps are actually pretty on point and have saved me a time or two. Google Productivity Apps, not so much and iCloud is still in Beta.
It used to be Dropbox for me, but ever since getting my iPhone 6, .rtf documents can't be displayed on the iOS Dropbox app. I had a couple .rtf text files set as Favorites as I liked having easy accessibility. I've now created Pages documents & access them via iCloud Drive & Pages on my iPhone. As soon as Apple (hopefully) increases functionality so we can maybe simply view folders, and open various document formats from a folder view, I'll migrate everything away from Dropbox. I also want my iPhone photos in iCloud drive, but sounds like we get that w/ iOS 8.1
Crazy Badger
macrumors 65816
Yes, running ownCloud 6.0.3 on FreeNAS 9.2.1.6 (both a little out of date, but they are running perfectly) so have access to almost 12tb of redundant cloud storage 😀
Of the 4 services listed in the poll, I'd say Dropbox was the best as it's the most mature and widely used across applications and environments. I still use it for syncing some application data, although some of that has migrated to iCloud. I also use OneDrive for Office 365 documents, although it's embedded in my ownCloud folders as their isn't an OneDrive Business client for OS X yet. Never really used Google Drive as I don't use many google services. If ownCloud as a little better supported within applications, I ditch them all and just use that.
Last edited:
josephd
macrumors member
I have been using Goggle Drive, One Drive, and Dropbox. One Drive and Dropbox have worked flawless on both my Mac and 5C.
As for Google Drive, I was a long time user until I got my Mac. I cannot figure out why my photos when I sync from iTunes to my 5C.
If I open the Google Drive app on my 5C, and click upload, the app for some reason does not recognize the photos on my phone, it only yields a blank screen.
Dropbox is nice also, but storage is lacking.If your invites don't sign up than you have to pay for more storage, which I don't mind if the rates were more more competitive.
Also with Dropbox, eventually I would like to see a thumbnail view of your photos within your folders. My eyes also are not the greatest.
I am not at that point where I need 1 TB of storage, so, in my case. $99 annually would be throwing away money.
Eventually, I am going to invest in an external hard drive.
I'll back up everything to that, and stick to One Drive as a secondary back up. You cannot beat the 30 plus gigs of storage I have with One Drive.🙂
As for Google Drive, I was a long time user until I got my Mac. I cannot figure out why my photos when I sync from iTunes to my 5C.
If I open the Google Drive app on my 5C, and click upload, the app for some reason does not recognize the photos on my phone, it only yields a blank screen.
Dropbox is nice also, but storage is lacking.If your invites don't sign up than you have to pay for more storage, which I don't mind if the rates were more more competitive.
Also with Dropbox, eventually I would like to see a thumbnail view of your photos within your folders. My eyes also are not the greatest.
I am not at that point where I need 1 TB of storage, so, in my case. $99 annually would be throwing away money.
Eventually, I am going to invest in an external hard drive.
I'll back up everything to that, and stick to One Drive as a secondary back up. You cannot beat the 30 plus gigs of storage I have with One Drive.🙂
Last edited:
baryon
macrumors 601
Dropbox.
I would never trust iCloud since the way it works is so damn unpredictable, not giving it a 5th chance.
Google drive is great but the desktop app doesn't have a quick way to generate and copy links like Dropbox does. I love the way you can just put JPEGs in a folder in Dropbox, right click the folder and you can get a link to a photo gallery and send that link to anyone. It's probably the easiest way to show people thousands of photos.
I do wish Dropbox offered more storage though! 3 GB is not enough, others are offering 5 GB for free.
I would never trust iCloud since the way it works is so damn unpredictable, not giving it a 5th chance.
Google drive is great but the desktop app doesn't have a quick way to generate and copy links like Dropbox does. I love the way you can just put JPEGs in a folder in Dropbox, right click the folder and you can get a link to a photo gallery and send that link to anyone. It's probably the easiest way to show people thousands of photos.
I do wish Dropbox offered more storage though! 3 GB is not enough, others are offering 5 GB for free.
josephd
macrumors member
SlCKB0Y
macrumors 68040
Traverse
macrumors 604
I've been a huge user of OneDrive for months, but I'm having issues lately.
Maybe it's the Office for iOS apps and not OD, but I keep having files vanish and randomly reappearing and one time a document I was working with just disappeared and I went to OneDrive's website and it was gone there too!! It just reappeared on my iPhone and said "corrupt" but then opened.
Now that office works with Dropbox I may switch back and see if these issues persist.
Maybe it's the Office for iOS apps and not OD, but I keep having files vanish and randomly reappearing and one time a document I was working with just disappeared and I went to OneDrive's website and it was gone there too!! It just reappeared on my iPhone and said "corrupt" but then opened.
Now that office works with Dropbox I may switch back and see if these issues persist.
I've used all the options a little and onedrive is by far the best. I've been using onedrive and syncing 2 computers (one VMware w/win7) plus multiple iOS devices with no problems for the last 6 months. The IOS app UI could use some touch up, mainly the icon sizing, but overall it's the best for syncing for sure.
simonsi
Contributor
I've settled on Dropbox as primary and Box as secondary cloud services, I'll only entertain services with 2-step verification now.
I then use Safemonk for encryption on Dropbox, Boxcryptor for encryption on Box (neither for all files, just for specific folders within the clouds)
I then use Safemonk for encryption on Dropbox, Boxcryptor for encryption on Box (neither for all files, just for specific folders within the clouds)
Traverse
macrumors 604
I post this in another thread and feel it's relevant here. It's some observations of Dropbox vs OneDrive.
In February I purchased the Office University $79.99 for 4 year subscription and have unlimited OneDrive storage. I switched from Dropbox to OneDrive to utilize Office for iPad. It's been fine until recently I've had issues with the Office apps not recognizing files and one file actually vanished from OneDrive all together only to reappear on my iPhone later. I don't like inconsistency and some apps I've been exploring only sync with Dropbox so I dusted off and installed my old account. Here are some positives and negatives.
All that being said, there are some pros.
Now that Office for iPad works with Dropbox I've considered switching back for the better service and third party support, but I have unlimited OneDrive space and only 8GB of Dropbox and I can only get more by referrals which is hard if you really don't know THAT many people. I could use OneDrive for my video and Picture backup (13GB) and just use Dropbox for my school files and apps, but I'd much rather just use iCloud and OneDrive versus iCloud, Dropbox, and OneDrive.
I don't know what I'll do.
In February I purchased the Office University $79.99 for 4 year subscription and have unlimited OneDrive storage. I switched from Dropbox to OneDrive to utilize Office for iPad. It's been fine until recently I've had issues with the Office apps not recognizing files and one file actually vanished from OneDrive all together only to reappear on my iPhone later. I don't like inconsistency and some apps I've been exploring only sync with Dropbox so I dusted off and installed my old account. Here are some positives and negatives.
- In terms of pure OS integration Dropbox far exceeds OneDrive. The OneDrive sidebar icon in the Finder is a generic folder whereas Dropbox uses it's logo which is nicer at a glance.
- Dropbox uses Finder icons to show which files are synced and which are synching. To be fair, Apple didn't really allow this until Yosemite so OneDrive didn't have this being sold through the Mac App Store.
- Lack of support. Microsoft simply doesn't prioritize it's Mac users. There hasn't been one update for Yosemite to allow Finder icon symbols or even to address the disappearing menu bar icon in Yosemite's dark mode!
- OneDrive doesn't sync files with non-windows compatible name characters such as "/ * &". This can be annoying for someone used to a Mac's file system.
- OneDrive doesn't sync metadata like tags. I restored my computer and loaded my files from OneDrive and lost all my tags. :/
- On average it uses slightly more CPU resources than Dropbox. Where Dropbox would drop to 0.0% usage when idle, OneDrive would sit at 0.6% and when synching OneDrive would use 1%-2% more CPU.
All that being said, there are some pros.
- OneDrive (good or bad) isn't as integrated so it isn't as intrusive as Dropbox. Dropbox install a Finder toolbar icon that can't be permanently removed in mavericks and requires a trick in Yosemite. That is unacceptable.
- OneDrive doesn't force a control-click (right click) menu item like Dropbox's "Move to Dropbox." This is annoying because it's right next to the move to trash option.
- And I must say, although lately I'm having random issues, OneDrive has been solid. I have yet to loose a file or have any corruption.
Now that Office for iPad works with Dropbox I've considered switching back for the better service and third party support, but I have unlimited OneDrive space and only 8GB of Dropbox and I can only get more by referrals which is hard if you really don't know THAT many people. I could use OneDrive for my video and Picture backup (13GB) and just use Dropbox for my school files and apps, but I'd much rather just use iCloud and OneDrive versus iCloud, Dropbox, and OneDrive.
I don't know what I'll do.
grahamperrin
macrumors 601
Wuala no longer recommended, but I did purchase a subscription today
I prefer Wuala above all others, but I no longer recommend it.
For the first time today I paid – around £7 for 10 GB (doubled from 5) for one year – because of the LaCie shift to a paid-only service. From the notice of termination of free storage and storage promotion:
Broadly coincidental, with some complaints about Apple and/or iCloud in the four pages of commentary:
PDF Reader 'GoodReader' Removes iCloud Drive Functions to Comply with 'Mandatory' Apple Policy
From a NAS-oriented topic:
My reasons for no longer recommending Wuala revolve around various changes that have occurred over the years, some of which removed functionality that was essential to my use of the service.
(I don't object to the ~£7 for annual maintenance of existing content.)
I prefer Wuala above all others, but I no longer recommend it.
For the first time today I paid – around £7 for 10 GB (doubled from 5) for one year – because of the LaCie shift to a paid-only service. From the notice of termination of free storage and storage promotion:
Broadly coincidental, with some complaints about Apple and/or iCloud in the four pages of commentary:
PDF Reader 'GoodReader' Removes iCloud Drive Functions to Comply with 'Mandatory' Apple Policy
From a NAS-oriented topic:
My reasons for no longer recommending Wuala revolve around various changes that have occurred over the years, some of which removed functionality that was essential to my use of the service.
(I don't object to the ~£7 for annual maintenance of existing content.)
Dropbox FTW...
I wonder if this would imply that more users will switch to iCloud drive now its part of Yosemite once users upgraded.?
I wonder if this would imply that more users will switch to iCloud drive now its part of Yosemite once users upgraded.?
iososx
macrumors 6502a
You've taken the words right out of my mouth, after suffering through MobileMe and iCloud, I finally got smart and bailed out of Apple's Cloud failures.
With a combo of my Mac Pro NAS equipped home network and spreading my files across a few Cloud services, I'm in great shape. 🙂
OneDrive all the way. Beats the pants of all the others..
Simply good value for the money. 1TB for £80 per year with a 5 licence Office suite, compared to £180 per year from Apple with nothing extra (and don't compare Office to Pages et al).
Simply good value for the money. 1TB for £80 per year with a 5 licence Office suite, compared to £180 per year from Apple with nothing extra (and don't compare Office to Pages et al).
grahamperrin
macrumors 601
Milking customers, Seagate controlling interests and why I no longer recommend Wuala
If open source can be classed as nonproprietary in that context, then I guess that it should be possible to take an open source approach to a network file system client for iOS.
First amongst Google search results for "iOS" +AFP|NFS|SMB: FileExplorer Free
not open source, but that's an example of an SMB/CIFS client (and more) for iOS.
On the subject of milking:
2009-03: Wuala Blog - Exciting news: Wuala merges with LaCie
2009-08: Wuala Blog - Developer Zone: Trading Storage - What's New
2011-10: LaCie: Wuala ceases to trade storage, loses essence - fuzzy (cached by Diigo)
2012-08: Seagate and LaCie Announce Completion of the Acquisition of a Controlling Interest in LaCie | Seagate
2013-01: Wuala Blog - Wuala Hybrid Cloud - Now Available!
2013-10: Wuala Forum View topic - Wuala web no longer displays web-friendly content (cached by Diigo) the forum in its entirety was removed 🙁 (I don't know when) and I have no record of a reply. Whilst my 2013 enquiry about the regression was suitably polite, I can now say
WTF?
What happened to the interface that I knew and loved? Seagate (controlling interest) can **** right off with any hope from them of me further investing in such services.
----
And that's why I prefer occasional tinkering with FreeNAS 😎 to the convenience of out-of-the-box functionality from a brand that lost my confidence 😡
If open source can be classed as nonproprietary in that context, then I guess that it should be possible to take an open source approach to a network file system client for iOS.
First amongst Google search results for "iOS" +AFP|NFS|SMB: FileExplorer Free
not open source, but that's an example of an SMB/CIFS client (and more) for iOS.
On the subject of milking:
2009-03: Wuala Blog - Exciting news: Wuala merges with LaCie
2009-08: Wuala Blog - Developer Zone: Trading Storage - What's New
2011-10: LaCie: Wuala ceases to trade storage, loses essence - fuzzy (cached by Diigo)
2012-08: Seagate and LaCie Announce Completion of the Acquisition of a Controlling Interest in LaCie | Seagate
2013-01: Wuala Blog - Wuala Hybrid Cloud - Now Available!
2013-10: Wuala Forum View topic - Wuala web no longer displays web-friendly content (cached by Diigo) the forum in its entirety was removed 🙁 (I don't know when) and I have no record of a reply. Whilst my 2013 enquiry about the regression was suitably polite, I can now say
WTF?
What happened to the interface that I knew and loved? Seagate (controlling interest) can **** right off with any hope from them of me further investing in such services.
----
And that's why I prefer occasional tinkering with FreeNAS 😎 to the convenience of out-of-the-box functionality from a brand that lost my confidence 😡
Last edited: