Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Wha...? Is that satire? You realize Google's primary line of business is that they DO collect every bit of data on us imaginable and store it forever? [Then sell it.]<--Editing this to more clearly reflect that they plumb this data for advertising profiles and other research, while reserving the right to sell their information (about you) directly.

Search history, browsing history, where you physically go [maps], your social circle, your family circle, your demographics [age, race, sex, income bracket, geographical location, who owns your address, where you work etc.] What genres of media do you watch, who calls you [google call forwarding], who is in your pictures [google photos]. How do your patterns differ now from 5 years ago. They even have a sister company that is building a genetic profile on everyone indirectly and directly so they can sell your health risk info to insurance and target you with custom pharmaceutical advertising.

Did you think all their free services were free?

Lest you think this is tin foil hat territory. Here is a link to a respected science journal. https://www.scientificamerican.com/...fying-but-not-for-the-reasons-the-fda-thinks/

FYI, Apple doesn't care about your privacy. When you sign up on the iPhone upgrade program, their partner (Citizens One) gets access to your bank account, your home address, phone number, data on where you spend money, and many other personal details.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Demo Kit
It's on by default. My wife doesn't know that. The point is, if I hand a "normal" a MacBook/pro, their data is instantly stored. This coming from a company that says they don't store your data. What's even more hilarious is they still actively keep two weeks of data even after "fixing" the issue with ZERO explanations as to why it was even up there in the first place.
[doublepost=1486701912][/doublepost]
You think Google isn't using your data to improve their services? Really...?
I understand all that, I'm just saying that it's not simply based on using Safari, but more on using iCloud and having those particular settings, like in this case the setting for Safari, enabled.
 
Access to your bank account? Your spending habits/transactions? I call bs...

Not actual access to your bank account, details of you account for transactional purposes.

You might be very surprised how much info is shared, read the apple T&Cs. See everyone buys the BS Tim says while ignoring the facts
 
  • Like
Reactions: Demo Kit
Quite some time ago I noticed that Safari on iOS wasn't clearing my history when I was selecting "clear history and website data". To this day I still have to go to advanced > website data > remove all website data ...and I often have to repeat the "remove all website data" step multiple times before the data actually clears.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Demo Kit
opps.

Now Apple should know better, but i like the name...

You could just call these saving deleted Safari history on servers the work of "we need to store them just in case"

That's all you gotta say... and its amazing how often that phrase works on people.
 
i entered a terminal command some years ago to keep safari history *forever*. but unfortunately, it seems an update has returned that to 'normal'.
i think it's super useful for reserarch purposes, and i don't worry about privacy, cause if i need to hide any parts, i delete those manually.
 
Unfortunately I don't think Little Snitch and Little Flocker can completely prevent this privacy leakage problem. Adding blacklists to /etc/hosts may be enough? On the other hand, privacy conscious individuals won't be using Safari anyway, and really privacy conscious individuals won't be using Apple products.
 
And there I was, thinking about switching from Dropbox to iCloud because its run by the "secure" company.
 
Next up, your fingerprints actually do leave the device and oops we stored them on our servers
[doublepost=1486729029][/doublepost]
Of course they do not sell their proprietary data. That would be selling the cow instead of the milk. They are the intermediary. But hey its not just Google. That is what your club cards are for too. These companies do reserve their right to sell their data [about you] to other entities. Read the fine print. And read the article linked previously about 23 and me.

They absolutely do collect a creepy amount of information tied to your real identity. Technically much of the information is stored in non-relational, big data, databases. The real technology in big data is the proprietary algorithms that can relate the information between identities and other data. Yes, they use it to sell profiles for marketing and other research in other spaces.

They can and do tie those advertising profiles back to a list of devices and real identities for targeted advertising. They route Hawaiian vacation ads to websites you happen to be visiting, after you browse an article about Hawaii, even on other devices.

If the general public ever saw what they could provide about an individual if they ever chose to, that would be their doom. But its all too abstract for most people to really care.

Why is any of this such a big deal to people? Who cares if someone tries to sell you something, you can just choose not to buy. The danger is them handing over info to governments who make up crimes on whim and actually lock people in cages.
 
Just because you sign up for the program doesnt mean Citizens one has any useful information to collect. They dont have access to your bank. And they only have information sufficient to satisfy the loan, social security, address, name, payment information... They aren't seeing your other transactions on your credit card or bank.. It's basically a tempory loan account with them.

Edit: Just trying to steer away fear mongering
No one is fear mongering. People are just pointing out the amount of information that is actually shared.
I'm going to giggle. You said they don't have any useful information to collect and then listed that they collect the ss, address, name, and payment info. You and I have extremely different definitions of useful.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Demo Kit and CE3
Yeah but so does your doctors office. Are they going to turn that information around and make a profit? Or worse, you think they can track you?
See, this is how conversations go off the rails. You started by questioning the bank account info sharing. When both @MH01 and I pointed out that the account details are shared, you moved to a defense of fear mongering. When it was pointed out that no one was actually fear mongering, you move to an inaccurate analogy of a doctor's office. A doctor's office, really? HIPAA laws govern a doctors office. More importantly, this isn't about you sharing your information, it's about a company sharing your information with another company. Your follow up questions regarding the doctor's office are immaterial and irrelevant. Bluntly, if you're looking for fear mongering, look no further than your follow up question since the only person to bring up profiting and tracking is you.
 
I guess I'm just not getting why having my personal web history even dated back 10 years would be any concern at all. Like, whatsoever.
 
I guess I'm just not getting why having my personal web history even dated back 10 years would be any concern at all. Like, whatsoever.

Point is, Apple prides itself on NOT storing user data. And they were caught doing so. Plain and simple.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Demo Kit
It's been already said that if a service is free, it means you are the product.
Speaking within the cloud services context, though, users are always part of the product.
 
No one is fear mongering. People are just pointing out the amount of information that is actually shared.
I'm going to giggle. You said they don't have any useful information to collect and then listed that they collect the ss, address, name, and payment info. You and I have extremely different definitions of useful.

The thread is about iCloud, not retail purchase/finance agreements.

Apple's privacy policy covers data Apple collects and stores in its systems. The information you provide when setting up a credit agreement goes to the bank, not Apple.

If you setup financing for an Apple product purchase through CitizensOne (iPhone Upgrade Plan) or Barclaycard (finance of other Apple Store/Apple.com purchases), the information-gathering goes through the bank's servers, not Apple's. The Terms and Conditions you agree to (without reading) are the bank's, not Apple's. You're not giving Apple permission to give your Apple data to CitizensOne or Barclays. You're giving the bank enough info to verify your creditworthiness.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 44267547 and Jyby
  • Like
Reactions: Demo Kit
And there I was, thinking about switching from Dropbox to iCloud because its run by the "secure" company.

Encrypted sparsebundle on Dropbox is pretty secure if you're not wanted by NSA or something.

Any method of "encryption" where you don't own the key (google sync, whatever else sync) is not secure by design.
[doublepost=1486752937][/doublepost]
Completely incorrect. Chrome sync and its protocols are open source.

Not Chrome, Chromium.

Chrome is closed source. Google server infrastructure is closed source.
[doublepost=1486753216][/doublepost]
Just like Microsoft, Apple, or any company following the law. You see the trend here? The law.

Am I missing something – what law exactly covered PRISM-level surveillance?
 
Last edited:
The thread is about iCloud, not retail purchase/finance agreements.

Apple's privacy policy covers data Apple collects and stores in its systems. The information you provide when setting up a credit agreement goes to the bank, not Apple.

If you setup financing for an Apple product purchase through CitizensOne (iPhone Upgrade Plan) or Barclaycard (finance of other Apple Store/Apple.com purchases), the information-gathering goes through the bank's servers, not Apple's. The Terms and Conditions you agree to (without reading) are the bank's, not Apple's. You're not giving Apple permission to give your Apple data to CitizensOne or Barclays. You're giving the bank enough info to verify your creditworthiness.
True, the thread is about iCloud. However, this particular conversation was about data sharing.
I'm going to disagree about this though... http://www.apple.com/legal/sales-support/iphoneupgrade_us/
"By enrolling in the iPhone Upgrade Program, you understand and agree that Apple, its subsidiaries and agents, the Bank, and Trade-In Service Provider may collect, process, transmit, maintain, share, and use certain of your personal information, such as your name, mailing address, email address, and information related to your loan and loan status, in order to perform the service and support obligations under your iPhone Upgrade Program. You may receive periodic iPhone Upgrade Program-related texts, emails, or other communications from Apple, such as notices regarding expiration of your account, upgrade eligibility, and changes to the iPhone Upgrade Program Terms & Conditions. You may also receive requests to participate in surveys related to the iPhone Upgrade Program."

Again, the information is shared. Nothing wrong with it, nothing nefarious about it. But it's shared. Which was the point of that particular conversation.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Demo Kit
Yeah but so does your doctors office. Are they going to turn that information around and make a profit? Or worse, you think they can track you?

What my doctors office got to do with an iPhone upgrade ? Relevance much ? I like green apples .
 
I guess I'm just not getting why having my personal web history even dated back 10 years would be any concern at all. Like, whatsoever.

Then keep your history forever. I regularly delete my history and cookies because I have no idea what the cookies these companies install when I visit their sites actually track (I'm sure it varies). When I visit one site and then go shopping or banking (or whatever) on another site, I don't want their cookies tracking any of that data. It's none of their business.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.