Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
The thing is, you are not the average person anymore. There are millions of teens and adolescents out there that do not even know what a CD/DVD is.

They know what youtube is though, a lot of youtubers do repair guides :)

This constant "oh you are not the average person" needs to stop, a good percentage of humanity likes DIY stuff, and it's not 1%.
 
The iMac is nice machine but Apple is definitely turning it into a very expensive disposable commodity. Long gone are the days of upgrading it to last a little longer. Of course its in Apple's best interest to stop customers from upgrading it. That way they have to buy new computers.

This wasn't an overnight progression, Apple has been making its computers more and more locked down with every iteration it seems.

I love the design, the OS, but I do have to think twice about laying out nearly 2k of my hard earned money with no future of it being upgraded.
 
It's not an abomination, and I'm so glad you don't work for Apple.

It's been so long since I've had to read or write a CD/DVD, but that's why I have the external Superdrive. It makes a lot of sense to make it a user-connectable option for those who need one instead of a standard part of a Mac.


It's not sad at all. Soldered components make them more reliable, reducing the need for maintenance. They're also much more recyclable these days. Buy the RAM you want up front. There are plenty of companies who buy used Macs, the money for which can go towards a new one. This penchant for upgradeability is so '80s/'90s. Come on up to this century.
While you are right about dvd drive,you are completely wrong about upgrade..
the only real reason Apple is doing that is to make more profit by forcing users to purchase a new machine sooner by downgrading lifespan of a premium expensive desktop computer.
Don't forget it's a full on desktop computer,not a phone or travel laptop.
most people cannot afford to by whopping price of maxed out initial factory upgraded models.
and about upgradeability being 80s/90s..would you say that about Mac Pro too?
 
Last edited:
So we have to pay the price of an entirely new logic board if the SSD dies? or one ram module?

Having to pay Apple prices for repair often means that it makes more sense to replace the whole machine, which is poor for the environment.

So you think its better than instead of simply replacing a dead SDD, that you now have to pay Apple's inflated repair costs to replace the WHOLE logic board instead of just the SSD?

Do you understand the economic and environmental ramifications of that?



Apple made a poor decision. Poor for customers and poor for the environment. You are supporting it as you've decided to stand up for Apple because for some reason you think that its higher profits for Apple is more important than the environment or customers.

I find it laughable that people use sales data to justify things. Mcdonalds sells more than then high end restaurants do. Does that make the decisions they make about their food any better? No it doesn't.
Oh please give me a break about that environmental stuff. It's just an excuse on your part to bash Apple.
If the SSD fails under the warranty coverage, Apple will repair at no cost. On an iMac like this, or a MacBook, the AppleCare is mandatory. If you can't afford that, it's fine, don't buy an iMac.

Replacing the entire motherboard just because of SSD failure isn't repair, it's replacement, because Apple will probably charge you $1000 for a 'repair' that should cost $100 to replace just the SSD alone and you'll likely buy a new mac at that point. So please, stop being disingenuous. "Oh dude but you should be Applecare" No. More profits for Apple just because they are being greedy and solder the SSD? No way.

If something is being made complex unnecessarily (soldered SSD) expect users to rightfully complain about it. It makes zero sense to solder it, other than more profits for Apple due to servicing and upgrades.
Oh dude you should buy AppleCare.
I strongly advise to not buy a Mac without it.

You don't solder SSD on a motherboard, not on a macbook and not on a desktop machine, it's not rocket science ;)
They did. Deal with it.
Don't buy it
 
  • Like
Reactions: doelcm82
It's not an abomination, and I'm so glad you don't work for Apple.

It's been so long since I've had to read or write a CD/DVD, but that's why I have the external Superdrive. It makes a lot of sense to make it a user-connectable option for those who need one instead of a standard part of a Mac.


It's not sad at all. Soldered components make them more reliable, reducing the need for maintenance. They're also much more recyclable these days. Buy the RAM you want up front. There are plenty of companies who buy used Macs, the money for which can go towards a new one. This penchant for upgradeability is so '80s/'90s. Come on up to this century.

he said since they dropped the drive not because. obviously with every year optical drives are used less but it certainly wasnt the right time then. apple didnt help ease people of them they just made it more complicated for people.

as for being more reliable can you post stats on that? as far as being more recyclable the best thing is to be able to use the computer as long as possible and get as much out of it. its unrelated to this topic but itunes 12 not working on sl means lots of fully functioning computers cant be used with new ios devices. back on point are you really claiming that all this soldering and locking out users/hackers has made the computer more recyclable? if so then please expand.

So...what's your point?

seems quite obvious. ifixit promotes users to make and get the best out of their machines. sadly the computer industry is evolving in this way though (every big business is). then he he goes through apples history and rules and laws.

What a silly definition is "disposable computer" ...
If you configure well your iMac, it will works flawlessly for 4-5 years at least. And it will keep an high resale value even after that period, being a good choice for someone with less needs.
If it will break, Apple can service it. Not being user serviceable doesn't mean not being serviceable at all !
I know that on a tech geeks forum most of the people are able to do it by himself, but this doesn't reflect the average customers attitude.

if its a serious question whether it makes sense to repair the computer because of the high repair cost then it certainly is not that serviceable. the option has to be realistic. buying and upgrading later most importantly gives people the option to really evaluate what they need and spread the cost over the lifetime of the machine.

You know its funny, people have had the exact criticisms since the Bondi iMac came out in 2008. Yet Apple continues to sell millions of them, so they must be doing something right. If someone is hell bent on opening up their computer and upgrading every little component, an imac is definitely not for them.

no they havent. its only in the last few 3-4 years apple has been on this route with the imac. obviously people know that however there isnt a whole lot of other mac options out there hence the frustration.

Apple quality is terrible? Lol ....
Not buying AppleCare was your choice. They would have solved you issue....
Lifetime of my macs always have been 3-5 years

applecare dosent make the quality any better. that cant be too hard to understand. how long you use your devices is your own prerogative.

i must say it is interesting (though not mildly surprising) to see the number of the lovers of the totalitarian rulers we have in giants like apple.

i mean jeez not trusting a site which documents every step of the teardowns because they broke an agreement you are not party to.
 
Last edited:
Oh please give me a break about that environmental stuff. It's just an excuse on your part to bash Apple.
If the SSD fails under the warranty coverage, Apple will repair at no cost. On an iMac like this, or a MacBook, the AppleCare is mandatory. If you can't afford that, it's fine, don't buy an iMac.

Oh please give me a break from all the ardent fanboism defending of Apple. Its just an excuse to show that no matter what Apple does you and others will stick up for them over the consumer.

And when they replace it it will cause a lot more environmental damage that it should of. Applecare is not mandatory, as repairs on a very expensive computer should not involve replacing the logic board when another component dies.

But in the end whats the use? You only care about Apple's bottom line. The fact that the environment and consumers will suffer as a result of this cost cutting decision (because thats really all that it is).

But oh no, Apple's bottom line which must really be suffering. Oh poor Apple, they're doing so poorly that they need to cost cut and rip off the consumer.

Oh dude you should buy AppleCare.
I strongly advise to not buy a Mac without it.

What because Apple's quality is so bad that its a necessity?

Theres probably no point in me replying to you any more as in some people's eyes, As long as Apple is making that bit more, everything is fine.
 
Last edited:
My point ? You MacRumors user know what the iMac is. You like it, you configure it in the right way and buy it. You don't like it, you don't buy it.
Without being such a drama queen over the forum.

So are you saying we cannot voice our opinions that criticize Apple? We are free to voice our displeasure with the direction apple is taking. What you consider is whining, many of us think of is voicing our opinion. Not everyone blindly walks lockstep with Apple,

Oh dude you should buy AppleCare.
I strongly advise to not buy a Mac without it.
I think you missed the point, why give more money to Apple when they shouldn't need too.

Apple's direction on their computer line reminds me of GM back in the 80s when they basically introduced planned obsolesces into the cars, i.e., they designed the cars to only last a few years so you had to go back and buy a new one. While Apple quality is still good, I see a similar approach by Apple.
 
We can come up with all kinds of hypotheticals. For example, my Bondi iMac needed it's logic board replaced 3 times in the space of a few months! Yes, 3 times. Of course, it was all covered by Apple as I had Applecare. It would have cost a fortune otherwise. Macs have never been the cheapest computers. Like driving a BMW, you wanna keep it running smooth, you gotta pay up for the Apple care.
The low end models are very expensive in comparison to really cheap PCs but also a mix of crippled combinations just to cater websurfers and Mail c
They know what youtube is though, a lot of youtubers do repair guides :)

This constant "oh you are not the average person" needs to stop, a good percentage of humanity likes DIY stuff, and it's not 1%.
Luckily for some reason there are some weird cycles that make old practices to become a hip or cool thing therefore there may be crop of new kids whom will be leaning towards liking computers that are "tinkerable" therefore the Macs may come back in full glory sometime in the not so distant future...I hope...
 
  • Like
Reactions: alvindarkness
I'm sure the penalties for breaking the NDA were clear from the start. I know they spell out everything in my contracts with them, including any NDAs, so I would never expect them to water the penalties down after the fact for me nor anyone else. If that's an option, why have an NDA at all? Uniformity has always been Apple's thing, but so has the expectation that you keep your word with them. It's not about cooler heads, it's about what's in the contract, which was vetted, then signed.



A deal's a deal. Sorry. My word means something to me and others. Perhaps some people just aren't honest, I guess, and those aren't the kind of people who should be in the business world.

Every comment you make on MR makes me more and more sure I would never want to have a conversation with you.
Bringing that up again on an entirely unrelated post just demonstrates the kind of person you are.

The iMac is nice machine but Apple is definitely turning it into a very expensive disposable commodity. Long gone are the days of upgrading it to last a little longer. Of course its in Apple's best interest to stop customers from upgrading it. That way they have to buy new computers.

This wasn't an overnight progression, Apple has been making its computers more and more locked down with every iteration it seems.

I love the design, the OS, but I do have to think twice about laying out nearly 2k of my hard earned money with no future of it being upgraded.

I'm glad to see the staff members apply logic to their thinking.
 
An important point is that in Europe Apple's warranty covers 2 years vs. in the US only 1 year. If US consumers start demanding it, we may see a spin in the market. I boggles my mind how polarized the consumer behavior in the US tend to be either consumers that don't give a crap on how their possessions are used and if something gets broken they tossed it and buy a replacement vs. those that think very carefully what they buy, and once they invest on it they try to make it last as much as possible, in some cases to the extreme of neglecting new technology or just balancing the needs vs the wants and nice to have features.
There seems to be a very few of us that dabble in between them.
For my Macs I do want them to be powerful fast and upgradable, and terrible hate when apple releases a new OS X version that doesn't run all the new features in the former hardware just because they purposely want to drive sales of the new models even you can make a simple upgrade or buy an accessory to make it work.
The optical drive (Superdrive) is a good example of something they decided to keep releasing without BluRay until they removed it completely. Good that there are plenty of options to buy an external BluRay drive/burner, it took a few months to have them in the market with proper OS X support, but there are some workarounds.
Sadly keeping spinning HDD at 5400 rpm in a late 2015 iMac is a carefully measured moved by Apple Marketing and its fueling those know it all rich kids that are used to pay extra for everything on top of the Apple Care premium payment.
 
You know its funny, people have had the exact criticisms since the Bondi iMac came out in 2008. Yet Apple continues to sell millions of them, so they must be doing something right. If someone is hell bent on opening up their computer and upgrading every little component, an imac is definitely not for them.
What I've learn over the years you shouldn't judge customer satisfaction by the mood on this forum.
If you listen to people here, Apple is doomed .... since 1988 :D
 
They know what youtube is though, a lot of youtubers do repair guides :)

This constant "oh you are not the average person" needs to stop, a good percentage of humanity likes DIY stuff, and it's not 1%.
In addition to this there are plenty of countries where Apple is trying to penetrate that still do sell plenty of CDs, DVDs and BluRays on their streets.
 
McDonalds sales are probably also growing. So they make the perfect food then?



So we pay more money to Apple for having the SSD soldered to the logic board which provides no benefit to us? Right.

This shows absolute fanboism. You're standing up for Apple over the customer.

http://www.inquisitr.com/1912340/mcdonalds-sales-plunge/

McDonald's is more akin to the rest of the PC industry, they raced to the bottom and found out it wasn't the right place to be.

An SSD doesn't have PCI-e speeds...it's almost as if you're not understanding that this is a large cache for the actual hard drive.
 
Uh, no. You'd buy the iMac with a platter (spinning) hard drive and theoretically solder in the PCIe flash drive. If you were so inclined.

Frankly, if I was being cheapskate, I'd just replace the hard drive with a budget SATA SSD. Any SSD will turbocharge boot up and application opening, and it will be a lot cheaper than a PCIe one. AFAIK Apple's PCIe SSDs are proprietary anyway so you'd have to get one of uncertain provenance off eBay or as an spare from Apple (which won't be cheap).

That said: deal with it folks: the real "entry level" iMac 4k is the 256G SSD model at US$1699, the $1499 one is just a marketing strategy (or maybe for some customers who won't buy SSDs).

the only real reason Apple is doing that is to make more profit by forcing users to purchase a new machine sooner by downgrading lifespan of a premium expensive desktop computer.

True. On the other hand, the whole PC market has been going down the toilet recently, partly because most people no longer need the power of their machine to double every year. Apple are one of the few companies bucking the trend. The inconvenient truth is that if Apple sold you an xMac (the proverbial upgradeable mini-tower with an i5 or i7 and a GPU in a PCIe slot) today, you'd get the base model, trick it out from eBay and wouldn't need to replace it for a decade.

My 2011 17" MBP with 8GB RAM is still perfectly respectable today - slapping a SSD in it a couple of years back gave it a new lease of life. The only serious nuisance is that it lacks USB3, which I can add via ExpressCard. Good news for me - bad news for Apple.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Benjamin Frost
The iMac is more and more like a laptop. I can understand from a production POV it will lower costs but if things go wrong it's gonna be easier for them to replace the whole computer than take it apart.

Had a 2011 MBP video card issue fixed last week. Thankfully it was under a recall notice so cost nothing but it did mean a whole new main board so virtually a new computer. I guess its now worth more to get Apple care than it even was if things go wrong with most new Apple computers.
 
McDonald's is more akin to the rest of the PC industry, they raced to the bottom and found out it wasn't the right place to be.

I'm just saying that sales doesn't mean the best decisions are not being made.

An SSD doesn't have PCI-e speeds...it's almost as if you're not understanding that this is a large cache for the actual hard drive.

I understand perfectly what the fusion drive is :)
 
The inconvenient truth is that if Apple sold you an xMac (the proverbial upgradeable mini-tower with an i5 or i7 and a GPU in a PCIe slot) today, you'd get the base model, trick it out from eBay and wouldn't need to replace it for a decade.

My 2011 17" MBP with 8GB RAM is still perfectly respectable today - slapping a SSD in it a couple of years back gave it a new lease of life. The only serious nuisance is that it lacks USB3, which I can add via ExpressCard. Good news for me - bad news for Apple.
It's inconvenient for the current state of affairs at Apple. That is the typical behavior of a non innovative company. Even though an xMac can be ran for many years if they indeed release new real hardware features that justify making the upgrade to a new machine worth it then they will stop the nonsense. The market will be well segmented and Apple will be catering all of them, still offering all-in-ones with some disposable models for the masses and upgradable ones for those who love the simplicity of a single package; xMac for those that like to build it and configura and continually make upgrades; Mac Pro for super powerful users; portables with super batteries and mobile features, etc...

If they increase just a tiny bit the investment in the Mac market without making them smaller and smaller, thinner and thinner but powerful and adding new tech to them they will have nothing to worry about because we will keep buying them.

3D printing is there fore the taking, and having the right technology to play with it and dominate the market is still to be seen. Hopefully they ant up the game.

The other future Mac line is the portable hybrid like the recent Surface Pro models, and so on...

The iMac is more and more like a laptop. I can understand from a production POV it will lower costs but if things go wrong it's gonna be easier for them to replace the whole computer than take it apart.

Had a 2011 MBP video card issue fixed last week. Thankfully it was under a recall notice so cost nothing but it did mean a whole new main board so virtually a new computer. I guess its now worth more to get Apple care than it even was if things go wrong with most new Apple computers.
Apple Care seems to be a necessary evil that should be considered as part of the retail price.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Seems funny how there are so many old PC's in the world, very old ones, still working, having their RAM upgraded, as it as expensive when these PC's were new.
Perhaps a new graphics card, perhaps a SSD to replace the old hard drive, and giving these old PC more life still.

Yet Apple keep branding themselves as the GREEN company doing the very best it can for the environment, yet on the other hand making sure new Apple computers will have to be scrapped, unlike the millions of old PC's around the world that, as I said, get upgraded and keep running for X or XX more years.

We all know this is all about Apple making the very most money.
Yet they sell it as if they are making the best computers and thinking of the environment 100%

God know what they will do to a car if they ever make one!!!!
 
In addition to this there are plenty of countries where Apple is trying to penetrate that still do sell plenty of CDs, DVDs and BluRays on their streets.

I'm sure a few people buy an iMac primarily to play CDs/DVDs - but not many. Meanwhile, plugging in a USB optical drive is no big problem since they don't need any more than USB 2 speeds. On the (increasingly rare) occasions that I buy a disc, the optical drive comes out of the cupboard for long enough to rip it to HD, then goes back in - I certainly don't need it plugged in.

Also, in my experience, those low-profile optical drives are horribly unreliable - you really, really don't want one built into a laptop or all-in-one.
 
That is a good point. How can we trust their repairability scores anymore after that NDA breaking stunt and after blaming iOS9 for ifixit's lazinesses to keep their apps updated.

How do you connect the two.

That's like saying how can I trust your cooking quality as a chef, when you avoided paying the tax you should have done this year.
 
  • Like
Reactions: numlock
Wow never seen such a compilation of BS in the same post.
Unrepairable? Who said that ? Apple can repair EVERY SINGLE PRODUCT they sell. It is difficult for USERS or third party unauthorized to do it.
All the other things about apple being bad and evil just made me laugh and I don't even take time to comment.
But ..... Tim Cook oversaw what ? Dude reality check: most of the electronic products are made in China.
And you surely have plenty of evidence about Apple bribe congressman....
Yes, he was instrumental in moving Apple's production overseas. Apple products were mostly made in the US until fairly recently, even the original iMacs. Everything I wrote is true. Trade with China didn't ramp up till the 1970s. A lot of high-tech manufacturing didn't move there until much more recently (relatively speaking—I don't know how old you are—I'm taking a longer view of this).

As far as repairability, if you look at Apple service manuals, the procedure for repairing parts is mostly to replace them. If a retina MacBook Pro has a crack in the display, you don't just replace the display, you replace the whole top assembly. If the battery is worn out, you replace the top case as the battery is glued to it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: numlock
Apple makes their computer very hard to upgrade because at the current computer speeds+upgrading the CPU or GPU, your computer purchase cycle might last as long as 10 years. If people will buy a new computer every 10 years, then Apple might as well shut down that division

I have macbook 2008, and tbh, its still running well(upgraded RAM and HDD).
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.