Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Inability to Use Apple Pencil for Navigation in iOS 9.3 Appears to be Intentional
- Thread starter MacRumors
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
The anger isn't coming from some belief that Apple is intentionally trying to oppress users. The anger is coming from the fact that, while it's not their intention to oppress, it is in fact the effect. Surely you can wrap your mind around that. I'm sure they have their reasons, and from their level and point of view, they probably make a great deal of sense.
Doesn't change the fact that I just spent $100 on something that I thoroughly enjoy, and they're (possibly) taking away the functionality I most enjoy. It's as simple as that.
Upon first reading this story, I was nonplussed. When I've got the Pencil out for writing/drawing, I will also use it as a stylus for navigation. Not having that ability would be initially frustrating, so Apple's decision to remove it is mystifying.
But I've had a day to consider, and now I kinda get it. As others have pointed out, Apple wants to reinforce the Pencil as a writing/drawing apparatus. They've never called it a stylus in any press release or promotional material, so this move is about further defining the role of the Pencil as a specialized, optional tool.
My only real complaint here is that Apple should have restricted the Pencil's use from the beginning.
But I've had a day to consider, and now I kinda get it. As others have pointed out, Apple wants to reinforce the Pencil as a writing/drawing apparatus. They've never called it a stylus in any press release or promotional material, so this move is about further defining the role of the Pencil as a specialized, optional tool.
My only real complaint here is that Apple should have restricted the Pencil's use from the beginning.
I think many of those that some people call "haters" on Apple forums these days, are simply longtime Apple fans who are not happy with some of the decisions that Apple is currently making.
Not really that much more than many things related to iOS devices to begin with, like the inability to install just anything you want, or to change default apps, or have various other options that you might want to have that Apple doesn't offer, etc.Seems to me a type of oppression of its users, no?
But not being able to install anything beyond the app store has always been the case since there was an app store. Same with default apps (one reason my personal device is Android by the way), etc..
This is a scenario which is different. Today, those with an iPad Pro and a Pencil have certain functionality. When the GM rolls out - they will lose part of that functionality. Now I have no skin in this game at present. But I can understand why this is an issue and why some are getting upset. Further - it does nothing to entice me towards a purchase as not only might I like this functionality (since I now KNOW it is/was there) but also because who knows what might be taken away next?
Right, there's a difference in the sense that they allowed it for a short period of time due to a mistake, or an oversight, or something else. In a sense it would be similar if some update somehow allowed apps from outside the App Store to be freely installed and then a later update removed that ability again. There's history that existing features can be tweaked or changed or even replaced or removed in some updates, that's not really new either in the world of iOS or really any OS or software lifecycle. Sure, there are certainly complexities involved when a station like that arises and it's not just completely clear and cut and dry. But, the specific aspect of "oppression", especially as applied to something iOS related, that just seems to be par for the course, so to say, given what iOS and it's devices are and have been.
Selecting text, underlining text, highlighting text - is marking. Based on this post and thread that has been removed and I feel that is a mistake. While I do navigate my books while reading with the Pencil, I could get over that, but losing select text is going to impact my ability to study. Which is why I bought this in the first place....
In some cases you're absolutely right, but there are plenty of people who argue with anyone who dares to say they like something that Apple has done. It's almost like a game where these people fight over who can bend over backwards more to criticize Apple and those who don't criticize them the same way.
They GUESSED it was an Apple choice and that it wouldn't return.
As I said, it will return in the release.
https://forums.macrumors.com/thread...ality-to-return-in-next-ios-9-3-beta.1957893/
Good to hear. You'd think MR would have checked before reporting on it but guess it generates clicks.
[doublepost=1456264580][/doublepost]
Good to hear. You'd think MR would have checked before reporting on it but guess it generates clicks.
My favorite now is when interacting with text(mac rumor forums), I can't highlight any of my text in a text box, as the keyboard pops up, and the highlighting functionality is gone. Makes it really difficult to MOVE a sentence from one place to another.
I already dread having to highlight more than one word to begin with, now they go and do this?
Pfffft
Edit a post here, when you get the popup, versus the straight text on the webpage. Sometimes the popup appears when editing, sometimes not.
With the popup, highlighting text to delete/move/copy brings up the keyboard, and you can no longer highlight text. At least that is what has happened to me the last 5 times I've tried to highlight text on a popup. Could just be macrumor's/forum tool's implementation.
Still doesn't negate the fact that highlighting text is a horrible experience in iOS.
This is on an iPad, btw.
Last edited:
This is precisely what I was talking about. I have experienced that problem and I just try to keep the finger aligned as I pick it up. Seems like a minor tweak they can make will fix it.
If you didn't see the news the pencil functionality will be back in time for the release
Also I wish you a speedy recovery!
I agree! I have arthritis in my finger so a stylus to navigate is actually one of the main reasons I bought the iPad Pro and pencil. What a disappointment if they take functionality away that actually makes the device have greater accessibility for people with defective digits!