If this is the case with the release, it's going to be a very long time before I move from 9.2. This is an idiotic move. I waited 2 months for a $100 accessory that they're taking functionality away from?
Boo.
Boo.
Got a tip for us?
Let us know
Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Inability to Use Apple Pencil for Navigation in iOS 9.3 Appears to be Intentional
- Thread starter MacRumors
- Start date
- Sort by reaction score
That's probably the desire. However, if that's the case it was a mistake to release the Pencil with those capabilities enabled in the first place.
[doublepost=1456233420][/doublepost]
For artists the Pencil is a big deal.
If you mean having focus by dumbing down the program then I completely agree. Ditch functional parts of a program to make it more touch friendly and you have apps. The funny thing is that the loss of functionality in many cases makes the app actually more difficult to use than using the desktop counterpart. I think the largest example of "razor sharp focus" is the lack of a filesystem because consumers are too dumb to navigate one.
What's nice is that my tablet has "razor sharp focus" because it has apps also, but at the same time can be used as a full PC. It's about choice, having the choice to use my stylus to drive the UI if I want to even though it's not made for that is powerful. Not having the choice, well it's powerless. Why limit yourself?
As for why I'm still here, I laugh whenever I hear this, it sounds a bit childish. I still contribute to the forums, if anything a dissenting opinion is valuable as it encourages discussion and puts things in Apple's view. Do you want all Apple dissenters Gestapo'd from the forums? Are you more comfortable with only Apple lovers on the forum? Sorry, I still own Apple products, I think they are a great company and really love their hardware. But if they deserve criticism, or if they nix a feature that is useful to me, you can bet I'll voice my opinion. Here's another hint, look back on this thread and count how many are unsatisfied with this decision. Representative of overall consumers? Maybe not, but still you get to see what should be a hardcore Apple majority actually complain about a feature being removed. Maybe you should wonder why all those who dissent in this thread are still here?
No one said Apple couldn't make the device work they way they intended, least of all me. I said Apple can't decide what your use of the pencil will be. People have found creative uses for every product ever invented. Uses beyond the manufacturers imagined use case.
As an aside, if Apple decides how you, C DM, use your products... that says something about you. What it is, I don't know. But it's something.
It's a keynote. It's used to introduce new products and services. It's not a detailed breakdown of all the benefits and features. It's a product highlight. Regarding your safe assumption? Might I suggest a bit more imagination. Besides, Apple had more imagination. They gave the pencil capabilities beyond drawing and writing.
Daggers out already on a function that has been removed from a beta, probably to test something else.
Imagine a world where everyone didn't jump to conclusions.
Imagine a world where everyone didn't jump to conclusions.
I agree - it does not make sense at all. When I use a pen/stylus on a device I expect it to do everything that I can do with a single finger. As you say: Switching grip or putting the pen down to just do a quick tap/selection with my finger (anything that does not require multi touch) is just stupid. The pen is already there in my hand, ready for that exact task.
It seems strange at first, but I wonder if they are attempting to prevent development of apps that require a stylus to navigate a UI that is so 'busy' that it makes normal touch navigation impossible. Even if that's their logic, maybe they should make it an option and give users the choice.
I'll venture that this has to do with the new iPad getting force touch, and the stylus not spreading the pressure over a large enough area as a finger.
Well, clearly if Apple decides that the pencil isn't a stylus then you wouldn't be able to use it as one, which is Apple basically deciding if for you. Otherwise it's one of those jumping over hour heard type of situations, whether you can imagine it or not. The article that I linked to also demonstrated what Apple had in mind with the pencil, beyond the keynote or anything else.
So, as an aside, seems like all it might say about me is that I take a pragmatic approach to things, which is a fairly normal thing (although perhaps not as common as it should be). Now, the relevance of trying to bring up some aside about someone rather than just sticking to the actual discussion, well, that is another thing in and of itself.
Last edited:
iOS has a filesystem, obviously, and it operates under a logical design philosophy: you interact with files via the apps that use them. And if you really want a "Windows Explorer" type app to browse/move/copy/delete files, there are apps that do that, you just haven't bothered to look for them.
It sounds like you simply weren't willing, or weren't able, to learn how to use iOS. That's ok, there are other choices out there.
Daggers out already on a function that has been removed from a beta, probably to test something else.
Imagine a world where everyone didn't jump to conclusions.
I jump to conclusions because this is exactly the kind of boneheaded move they've made in the past, most recently by disabling BT Keyboard and Remote App support in the ATV4 in an attempt to force people to use their horrible touchpad remote. (which didn't work... most people I know use an old Apple remote or universal remote instead).
As well, for many of us our iPad Pro is a big part of working and leisure life, and a potential change like this impacts us pretty heavily. So, yes, please excuse us if we express some concern.
I hear you man - like - I don't remember the original keynotes talking anything about how to remove apps from the phone so I never did it. I figured if Apple wanted me to delete an App I downloaded, it would have been featured during the keynote, right?
What? The pencil isn't a stylus? Maybe in the alternate reality of Ive. By every definition of what it does, it's a stylus. How did it come to be called a pencil? Easy, Ive made it up. How do I know? It's right in the article you linked.
Ive went on to talk about the naming of the Apple Pencil, explaining that he preferred "Pencil" to "stylus" because stylus "seems a product that's about technology," while Pencil "seems very analogue in its association.
That's pure Ive hubris... and marketing. A+ marketing. It's so good you have people doing mental gymnastics defending the "fact" it's a pencil and not a stylus. There's no science, technology, or wizardry that makes Apple's stylus a pencil. It's simply Ive deciding to call it that.
Clearly a portion of the market thinks they have the right to use the pencil in the way they see fit. Apple's vision notwithstanding. That's the way it should be; people using their products the way they want. Fortunately for those people, remaining on 9.2 allows them to continue to use their pencils they way they want.
I'm simply pointing out what Apple has seemingly had in mind with it all. No mental or other types gymnastics involved, just talking about the "is" aspect of it all, and not the "could/should". No commentary on my part has been offered as to it being good or bad or right or wrong.
Last edited:
I got that.
But I still can't understand WHY the change? if people want to use the Pencil for UI navigation, why not let them? the hubris of Apple in cases like this baffle me.
I agree. Apple sometimes reminds me of a parent interacting with their kids and deciding what is best for them. Telling the kid they can't do something and when asked why, the answer is "because I told you so".
I'm guessing they are trying to make it work the way they meant it to work which means addressing the oversight of releasing it the way they did with what is unintended additional functionality on their part. Now in this case the unintended functionality has turned out to be something useful to many, which certainly makes it a more complex and complicated issue.
There may very wel be other reasons promoting them to take it on now rather than just letting it be essentially, like some that have been brought up in relation to perhaps developers starting to rely on the pencil as an actual navigation and interactin tool, which is likely not what Apple would like to to be the case. However, again, that doesn't really mean that those who have been using it for those porposes and would like to keep using it in such manner would be seeing an improvement and would be losing functionality that is useful to them.
No, I actually ran iOS for several years. My latest foray was using the iPhone 6s+ for about 4 months, very nice phone. I delved deep into the functionality, even jailbreaking to regain some functionality I needed. I'm very familiar with iOS.
Just out of curiosity, do you think that Apple should extent the return period for Pencil? If I had bought the Pencil with the idea of using it to navigate and then they removed it months later I would be pissed.
Well, to be fair, just to go with that particular comparison, in plenty of those situations the parents are in the right usually.
Actually, it's often a case of what's easiest and least path or resistance vs being right. Not always - but often.