Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
The one thing that drives me crazy is being an Xfinity Mobile user, Xfinity likes to offload onto their Wifi hotspots.... so you will be walking down the road with 5G going and suddenly your internet drops because you are at the remote edge of an Xfinity hotspot where it recognizes it but can't get any data through, but prioritizes it over your 5G connection. Makes me always turn off WiFi when I leave the house.

Yep. This behavior is why I left XM after being a happy customer for 3 years. I was okay that they removed the 100MB free, essentially raising my bill from $2.16 of taxes each month to $14.16, but when my phone started jumping on the neighbor’s WiFi every time I went downstairs to get something to eat? That was too much. I could have just upgraded to a mesh network but it was far cheaper to port out and I’m actually paying about half for my service now than I was then (I’m a very low data usage customer and I use Google Voice so I don’t need a lot of minutes either).
 
The crime was AT&T and Verizon using DSS to claim 5G, slowing down both 5G and LTE customers in the process, while T-Mobile was busy deploying an actual faster and decently available midband network.

The midband network T-Mobile has available around my little city pumps 250+Mbps all day with peaks around 550Mbps and latency rarely goes over 20ms compared to LTE speeds that average 20Mbps and peak at 100Mbps with latency 25-175ms with an average around 70ms. It’s a noticeable improvement and it’s the fastest network here hands down.
Where I live T-Mobile gets around 20-30 megs with some random spots hitting 250-500mbps. AT&T usually sees 150+ everywhere with some spots dropping to 50-75. Overall AT&T poops on T-Mobile by me. Just depends on the area. And Verizon is straight up useless with most speeds being under 10mbps.
 
Where I live T-Mobile gets around 20-30 megs with some random spots hitting 250-500mbps. AT&T usually sees 150+ everywhere with some spots dropping to 50-75. Overall AT&T poops on T-Mobile by me. Just depends on the area. And Verizon is straight up useless with most speeds being under 10mbps.

AT&T does have decent service here. Verizon is by far the worst. T-Mobile’s midband is formidable though and they’re deploying it crazy fast.
 
AT&T does have decent service here. Verizon is by far the worst. T-Mobile’s midband is formidable though and they’re deploying it crazy fast.
I actually have AT&T as my main provider, and have been toying around with a T-Mobile prepaid plan as an esim just because I’m bored and I find it interesting. T-Mobile when it works works very well, but they don’t have the coverage AT&T or Verizon do in Phoenix at least. I was at dinner in a normal shopping center and T-Mobile had “no service” displaying on my phone… but walk out into the parking lot for a speed test and I almost hit 500mbps…
 
  • Like
Reactions: max2 and RalfTheDog
I actually have AT&T as my main provider, and have been toying around with a T-Mobile prepaid plan as an esim just because I’m bored and I find it interesting. T-Mobile when it works works very well, but they don’t have the coverage AT&T or Verizon do in Phoenix at least. I was at dinner in a normal shopping center and T-Mobile had “no service” displaying on my phone… but walk out into the parking lot for a speed test and I almost hit 500mbps…
652FB681-EF42-475A-8D03-C92FB22ED3F0.jpeg
4CC51F13-B443-48A6-8219-29D942ABF86D.jpeg

What I don’t understand is… on both AT&T and T-Mobile—if I force them onto lte (instead of 5g auto) I get WAY better speeds. If I leave it in 5g auto, my speeds suffer dramatically on both services.
 
somehow the 'tech media' managed to glue together the coverage of low-band 5G, the network performance of mmWave 5G and the price point of DSS 4G/5G
And not even just that. They also came up with all sorts of "real-time" use cases that will "change our lives forever", when in reality the inherent unreliability of networks will always prevent such applications from happening, no matter how low latencies are in a lab setting.
 
I love this - this is really great news.
To often you are stuck in a ****** WIFI network and nothing works although 5G is available.

I would even love this option for slower cellular networks (like 3G,4G).

Even an alert in message center (ideally with a network ignore/log-out option) would be great - so one could log-out of the Wifi if it is a nuisance.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RalfTheDog
Nice! But what about WiFi 6E? Isn't that faster and more reliable than 5G.
For all sorts of practical reasons, a cell network (even our current 4G ones) is a lot more reliable than a wifi network served from a home router combo. Technicians maintain these towers and the network 24/7 with failovers and all that. Random home networks you don't control will fail for random reasons you don't control, and there will be nobody standing by. Also, idk if wifi 6 improves this, but wifi in the past has had terrible support for handoff between access points; LTE has a complex way of dealing with this.

Regardless, wifi 6E on a reliable home network means nothing if the ISP isn't giving you very fast service.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: max2
Shouldn't Wi-Fi Assist setting do the same thing? The feature is described as "Automatically use cellular data when Wi-Fi connection is poor."
I think that's just when the signal is poor (due to distance etc), not the connection to the Internet. So, just that L1 hop to the access point, not the whole end-to-end connection.
 
I actually have AT&T as my main provider, and have been toying around with a T-Mobile prepaid plan as an esim just because I’m bored and I find it interesting. T-Mobile when it works works very well, but they don’t have the coverage AT&T or Verizon do in Phoenix at least. I was at dinner in a normal shopping center and T-Mobile had “no service” displaying on my phone… but walk out into the parking lot for a speed test and I almost hit 500mbps…

I have Tello as my main provider so I don’t normally have 5G (Apple has to fix the carrier bundle to see the new 240 SIM cards as T-Mobile - it’s affecting a number of T-Mobile MVNOs right now) but I did try Connect for a month and the speeds were pretty impressive.

e5622d5a44624fdb2b22ea3454f1ce7e.jpg


T-Mobile has always had that particular coverage problem. I remember when they had a dead spot on my route home from work that was right in the middle of the highway in downtown Denver. I would always have to tell people the call was about to drop and then immediately call them back because the gap was only like 50 feet at the most.

View attachment 1817658View attachment 1817659
What I don’t understand is… on both AT&T and T-Mobile—if I force them onto lte (instead of 5g auto) I get WAY better speeds. If I leave it in 5g auto, my speeds suffer dramatically on both services.

I think that’s just the modem firmware. Same thing with getting stuck on n71 SA and having crappy speeds despite n41 NSA being available with 300+Mbps at the same area. Apple needs to tweak the modem a bit.
 
  • Like
Reactions: nardobenz
I actually have AT&T as my main provider, and have been toying around with a T-Mobile prepaid plan as an esim just because I’m bored and I find it interesting. T-Mobile when it works works very well, but they don’t have the coverage AT&T or Verizon do in Phoenix at least. I was at dinner in a normal shopping center and T-Mobile had “no service” displaying on my phone… but walk out into the parking lot for a speed test and I almost hit 500mbps…
People on the Internet put too much effort into saying T-Mobile is great for me to believe it. All over California it seems, their coverage is spotty, as I know from friends and family having to borrow my phone. Sure you maybe get better speeds for less $ in the spots it works, but it ain't worth.
 
  • Like
Reactions: max2
People on the Internet put too much effort into saying T-Mobile is great for me to believe it. All over California it seems, their coverage is spotty, as I know from friends and family having to borrow my phone. Sure you maybe get better speeds for less $ in the spots it works, but it ain't worth.

That’s why if I start getting out of the house more I’ll get an AT&T eSIM as a secondary. Get T-Mobile’s speed where it’s available and AT&T’s reliability everywhere else.
 
  • Like
Reactions: sudo-sandwich
Apple: We will prioritize cellular connectivity over wifi for apps.

Also Apple: Want to backup your phone? Must be on wifi!
 
  • Like
Reactions: max2
Honestly I'd like iOS to properly fix this issue.
coming across a public Wi-Fi access point that needs authentication, even if 'forget network' has been done, iOS will still 'CLING' onto that network causing a delay in loading websites in Safari or a delay in any 1st/3rd party apps installed.

McDonald's
Tim Hortons
Starbucks etc. ALL need end user interaction to authenticate BEFORE you can use that internet connection.

This has been a LONG standing pain point on iOS.

Connection to an access point is just that, it doesnt' mean you're connected to the internet: On-ramp to a highway can STILL be closed and prevent your car/suv/truck etc from getting the full internet super highway. This is like basic 1984 stuff why is this so hard for Apple to figure out?!
Weird, I've seen the exact opposite. When I tell it to forget, it forgets.
 
  • Like
Reactions: max2
yes- ironically my home network will connect for like 5-6 city blocks before it’ll switch to 5G. But during the time I’m outside of my apartment I have very slow internet for CarPlay/maps/etc
Yeah. People were complaining about the Control Center wifi toggle only temporarily disabling wifi joining, but I rely on that behavior. Gotta temp disable it when I leave the house if I realize outside that I want to navigate somewhere. And if you use CarPlay (which I don't), you can't even pre-start your nav inside your house because it'll stop the nav when you connect the phone.
 
Why not? They'll automatically report me if I have suspicious images in my Photo Library, so why not do something in my favor as well and auto accept agreements on my behalf? Half-joking, half-serious...
They'll report you if you exceed the threshold for flagged images. Just one image won't do it.

Why won't they accept the agreements for you? Well, we have a number of sue-happy Karens that look for every opportunity to complain about rules and policy. Giving them an opportunity to sue for actual damages would mean Apple is just asking for it. Apple is smart to leave the captive system as-is.
 
How is iOS auto accepting any different than when the 19-year-old at Verizon clicks agrees to the iOS T&C during device setup?
If you've ever done the setup at an Apple Store, they look but don't touch when guiding you through setup, and it's all about liability. Technically, Verizon should not be accepting agreements on your behalf. It's one of those cases of "who cares" until someone makes a mess of it.
 
that explanation doesn’t change anything I’ve stated. Apple should NOT auto connect to such networks and try to use data. There should be some sort of detection that it’s a hotspot and if not use interaction involved shouldn’t use that as a priority.

right now even in iOS 14.7 it still does. Test this yourself you’ll see what exactly I mean and how it affects iOS internet connectivity.
Some of those hotspots load the captive page directly from the router. Not using data from the hotspot would prevent you from connecting; a cellular connection wouldn't be able to retrieve the login page since it cannot connect to the local IP address.

I recommend forgetting all public wifi hotspots if you do not use them so they will not auto-connect while you're out and about. The "Auto-Join Hotspot" setting is only for the tethering hotspot, so that setting can be left on.
 
gotta make sure that connection for icloud upload is stable so CSAM right?
No, because CSAM doesn't involve any server communication that doesn't already happen, since it's done when a picture is uploaded to iCloud Photo Library. It is described in detail in a paper Apple wrote about the algorithm. You should now comment on this if you don't know how it works.
 
  • Disagree
Reactions: ilikewhey
No, because CSAM doesn't involve any server communication that doesn't already happen, since it's done when a picture is uploaded to iCloud Photo Library. It is described in detail in a paper Apple wrote about the algorithm. You should now comment on this if you don't know how it works.
How does that invalidate what he said? It needs a connection for the server comm you're mentioning.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ilikewhey
No, because CSAM doesn't involve any server communication that doesn't already happen, since it's done when a picture is uploaded to iCloud Photo Library. It is described in detail in a paper Apple wrote about the algorithm. You should now comment on this if you don't know how it works.
take your own advice and stop posting then 😂
 
My problem was quite the opposite last year. Due to a very bad ice storm, I was without cable at my house for quite a few days. I had backup power, but my only internet was cell. If I did not turn off WiFi and unplug my routers, I had no internet because, my devices kept defaulting to the not working WiFi connection.

Just to be clear, I tethered my laptops and desktops to my cell phones, but the phones would try to connect to my not working local network. About five times a day, I would turn on the TV to see if cable was back up. About five times a day, I would be very disappointed.
 
I have Tello as my main provider so I don’t normally have 5G (Apple has to fix the carrier bundle to see the new 240 SIM cards as T-Mobile - it’s affecting a number of T-Mobile MVNOs right now) but I did try Connect for a month and the speeds were pretty impressive.

e5622d5a44624fdb2b22ea3454f1ce7e.jpg


T-Mobile has always had that particular coverage problem. I remember when they had a dead spot on my route home from work that was right in the middle of the highway in downtown Denver. I would always have to tell people the call was about to drop and then immediately call them back because the gap was only like 50 feet at the most.



I think that’s just the modem firmware. Same thing with getting stuck on n71 SA and having crappy speeds despite n41 NSA being available with 300+Mbps at the same area. Apple needs to tweak the modem a bit.
I just leave my phone on lte since AT&T’s real 5G isn’t deployed in Arizona yet, and their lte still gets speeds over 100mbps
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.