Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Still flummoxed as to why it took ten whole years to get on-device processing for Siri. It’s been one of the massive complaints and contributors to Siri being borderline useless sometimes.
 
  • Like
Reactions: peanuts_of_pathos
Has it left beta since then?
Right!? HAHAHA. This is one example (of many lately) of apples arrogance not serving them so well. Siri has become a joke in every tech circle. As soon as it doesn’t work more than twice people are done with it.

Part of why the HomePod never took off. Sounds amazing but Siri is meh. So what did apple do? Release $550 headphones! LMAO
 
Still flummoxed as to why it took ten whole years to get on-device processing for Siri. It’s been one of the massive complaints and contributors to Siri being borderline useless sometimes.
I swear they announced this once before around the 5/5S era. I thought it was doing onboard processing for years now.

Maybe it was just for a small subset of commands/features, like “call” and names. Either way, Siri sucks and it is pretty much unusable for anything more that “call x” or “set timer for x minutes”. Completely worthless in AppleMusic unless you listen to hip hop.
 
  • Love
Reactions: peanuts_of_pathos
Can someone please confirm this, if I use Siri now with voice controls will it not send my voice to Apple for them to analyze and store in their servers? How does this work for a query like:-

"Who was the 10th president of the United States of America?"

I was hoping that the voice-to-text is done on device, then the text queries will go to Apple servers to return the answers.
In its current form, anytime you speak to Siri, that voice clip is sent to Apple and analyzed in the cloud, but the data is not linked to you. Then the response is sent back to your phone. That’s why Siri has always needed a network connection to function. With iOS15, that’s changing, and your voice is now processed on the device, if it’s recent enough.
 
  • Like
Reactions: peanuts_of_pathos
Wow, I think you're right. In fact, it's dumber than the original version of Siri.

I think they took out the wolfram alpha api. In the demo, Scott mentioned that you can ask it how many days until your birthday and when I tried that just now, it only tells me when my birthday is but not the number of days until my birthday.
It definitely still works on iOS, but not on macOS which is strange.
 
  • Like
Reactions: peanuts_of_pathos
Siri is a joke compared to what Alexa is in 2021. I could care less if her ultimate goal is to get me to buy more stuff.
It. Just. Works.
 
Last edited:
  • Disagree
Reactions: ikir
This is huge, starting to be really cool imo

the next thing that needs improvements is the translate app which is almost not usable, interface not friendly at all I mean come on it is really bad apple if you read me.

And also a feature I have been asking for around 10years is the ability to play music in a Bluetooth speaker AND record a video at the same time. WHY THE HELL DOES THE MUSIC STOPS.
Sorry but it feels good to shout it once in a while.
Translate app is indeed behind Google translate. And why on earth they don’t offer voice feedback for the original language and no handwriting option for Asian languages?

As for multi-source support, Apple better cannibalise their design philosophies first before we see that kind of change, the one place “courage” is much needed.
 
  • Like
Reactions: peanuts_of_pathos
Siri is pure SH!
How about getting it to work so its worth using first!
I use it everyday. Online forums are not the real world, most costumers use Siri and find it useful. Maybe Siri won’t tells you who who the cricket championship, but not everybody cares about news, just use for commands and I can’t imagine my everyday workflow without it.
 
Any improvements for the Apple Watch? That's where i want to use Siri the most and so far it fails with a lot of commands that work on the iPhone just fine.
 
  • Like
Reactions: peanuts_of_pathos
Useless for me since Siri is still not able to handle more than one language at a time. You should hear my incoming messages in Spanish or English when my iPhone is set to German. It’s hilarious
I agree with that and it will take another 5 years before any AI will allow the use of multiple languages
 
  • Like
Reactions: peanuts_of_pathos
Any improvements for the Apple Watch? That's where i want to use Siri the most and so far it fails with a lot of commands that work on the iPhone just fine.
I second that.
can someone confirm if you can skip songs while on airpods and away from your phone for a run for instance.
 
  • Like
Reactions: peanuts_of_pathos
I agree with that and it will take another 5 years before any AI will allow the use of multiple languages
It would actually be fairly easy with a little work around. iOS already remembers which keyboard you use for specific contacts. For instance, when I am starting a conversation with a friend from Australia, it is automatically the English keyboard, when I am talking to my BF, my keyboard is automatically in Spanish. All it would have to do is crosscheck the keyboard you have been using for contact X and automatically tell Siri "hey, use language XY for that contact". It is especially annoying when I try to answer a message from my Apple Watch. There should be a button to let you switch language for text speech. There is already one for hand writing. Why not do the same for text speech

edit: now that I think about it more, it actually also already works for auto correct, if I start a sentence in "German" it automatically gives me examples or corrections in German. If I start a sentence in English it automatically makes those examples in English and so on
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: peanuts_of_pathos
Would be great if it could finally pick a consistent device to use. Frequently I'm trying to set a timer on my homepod in the kitchen and then it picks it up on my phone in the other room.
 
One HomeKit feature I'm waiting for is multi-user-aware home/away settings.
For example, my wife works earlier than I do. She also has a much smaller "acceptable temperature range" than I do. I want to use home/away thermostat settings, but it either has to be the less-energy-efficient "for her" settings, or the more-energy-efficient "for me". So of course I have it set for her.

Right now, I have it time-schedule: 64-72 degrees overnight, 66-70 degrees for the couple hours she's up in the morning before leaving for work, 64-76 degrees during the time she's at work (I work from home, and that's my acceptable range,) and 66-70 again for the time she gets home from work until her bed time.

I'd love to have "If nobody is home, 60-80. If [me] home, 64-76. If [wife] home, 66-70, overriding [me]." Possibly with a "bed time" mode, too (as our Honeywell app does support having different "day vs night while occupied" settings.)
All of this is already possible. have a look at the Eve app where you can create complex automations with multiple conditions.
 
  • Like
Reactions: peanuts_of_pathos
I remember when Siri launched it was supposed to be context aware. But then it got dummer over time. I’m not holding my breath it will be more useful now.

And please: add multi language support. How hard can it be to read out my messages in their own language instead of butchering them.
 
  • Like
Reactions: peanuts_of_pathos
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.