Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
The devil is in the details, which we don't know yet.

This could very well be a government mandated NSA backdoor protected by a national security letter. That way the NSA or other gov TLA orgs have direct evidence of what sites you are signing into and can turn on direct tracking in the browser. Tell me we've not heard of more outlandish things from NSA, FBI, CIA leakers.
 
The devil is in the details, which we don't know yet.

This could very well be a government mandated NSA backdoor protected by a national security letter. That way the NSA or other gov TLA orgs have direct evidence of what sites you are signing into and can turn on direct tracking in the browser. Tell me we've not heard of more outlandish things from NSA, FBI, CIA leakers.
If you watch the video, there are PLENTY of details.
 
The devil is in the details, which we don't know yet.

This could very well be a government mandated NSA backdoor protected by a national security letter. That way the NSA or other gov TLA orgs have direct evidence of what sites you are signing into and can turn on direct tracking in the browser. Tell me we've not heard of more outlandish things from NSA, FBI, CIA leakers.
No.
 
Interesting. Hopefully it reaches wide support, although I doubt that some companies would. Eg I don’t think Google would support this as solving captcha is a way to train Google’s AI, or so I’m told… :D
I can’t see how useful it is. Since I often have to give wrong answers to get it right. So, I like I’m sure many others, have adapted and know what it likely got wrong. To solve the captcha. Rather than give it the correct answer and have to solve a second one.

Some it is the worst at is differentiating between motorcycles, scooters and bicycles. Often it thinks all are the same. Another being crosswalks. Where it doesn’t thing the blank space between the perpendicular and parallel lines is part of the crosswalk.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Atlantico
Interesting. Hopefully it reaches wide support, although I doubt that some companies would. Eg I don’t think Google would support this as solving captcha is a way to train Google’s AI, or so I’m told… :D
This is correct. As long as Google reCAPTCHA dominates, we won't see much difference. Companies would have to introduce this alongside that, and good luck doing that!

My hope is that many companies use form builders to create their website forms, so hopefully those will be updated by the company that sells that software to automatically authenticate. For instance, we have a large deployment of Gravity Forms across hundreds of websites, which is a popular WordPress plugin which already has Akismet and Google reCAPTCHA built-in. If the vender added support for this and enabled it by default as an authentication option which supersedes other authenticators, that would add no extra work for my team to deploy.

Even better would be if Akismet themselves added this as they are really popular on WordPress. The vast majority of our sites only need Akismet and we only add reCAPTCHA if they start having problems with spam. We do this to reduce friction for the end user so we can maximize conversions. Bypassing reCAPTCHA would be great for conversions as we always see a dip with it because people get frustrated when trying to provide training data for Google's AI.

---

IDK about anyone else, but I actively try to thwart Google's AI. I'll always throw another image in there each time that doesn't belong to see how it responds. Usually if you have enough accurate photos it accepts the data, lol. Sometimes it kicks it to another set of images, and I'll do the same thing again. I think you just have to get the score high enough to pass as human, but then my false positives are hopefully screwing up their training data, because I can't stand Google and their horrible privacy practices.
 
This needs to be implemented yesterday. I’m so sick of sitting there like a moron trying to decide if the tiny piece of a car’s side view mirror that’s sticking out over the square line is enough to require that square being selected.
 
Last edited:
Why? The web forms use captcha to fight bots and spam. They don't care how they get it. Just that it's legitimately identifying a real person.

It is captcha providers that might object, like Google, who only provides free captcha as a way of getting the world to train their object recognition AI.

The sentient google AI is amazing at identifying photos with school busses.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Robert.Walter
Interesting. Hopefully it reaches wide support, although I doubt that some companies would. Eg I don’t think Google would support this as solving captcha is a way to train Google’s AI, or so I’m told… :D

My first thought exactly. Google won't like this.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Robert.Walter
I hate them too, but recently had to build a website where I needed to implement Google’s eCAPTCHA.

Basically if the browser detects certain characteristics, you’ll need to solve the captcha. This was necessary because we had too many instances of scripts/bots trying to blast our text entry fields, and ruining it for everyone.
Are the characteristics up to your choice as a website designer or is it fixed ? What kind of characteristics is that ?
As a non robot internet user, I would be so happy to avoid this nuisance...
 
Does this have any privacy implications though?

Captcha isn’t private.

It’s also not just a security measure.

Captcha uses your result and sells it to machine learning systems for cars and spy camera systems.

When you use captcha you are teaching all the spy camera systems around the world.

The same spy camera systems that are used to oppress innocent people.

It’s a monstrous system that should have been banned years ago but politicians asleep because blood drinking corporations like Palantir pay money for all that data.
 
This is a little bizarre for me… isn’t captcha supposed to avoid the repeat submission of forms via automatic means?

Theoretically tying a captcha to faceID would allow someone to pay people a ludicrously small fee to just stand there for hours letting faceID pick their faces up so the bot can keep sending fraudolent requests

There’s already services that offer captcha resolution by literally having a room full of people clicking them for you, this would make that even more trivial unless I’m missing something
 
but I like captcha

D5C22390-0FC0-422E-B4EF-FAA269056EE0.jpeg
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.