Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
The tinted look is way more readable, but they should just make it the default, instead of adding yet another option. It's getting ridiculous.
I prefer clear they created the toggle to satisfy people like you who keeps complaining about it
 
Last edited:
I wonder how Steve Jobs would have felt about this. He wasn’t a fan of fiddly interfaces.

So hard to know. He did champion brushed metal and full on skeuomorphism. And back in the day, he extolled the very transparent Aqua 10.0 interface.

He's certainly on record for saying "choice is good" during a keynote, though that was during a momentary trepidatious mood.

I tend to recall this moment from the release of Leopard, though, when he appeared to be responding directly to user requests with respect to the interface. Listening to what people thought about Apple seemed like such a critical tooth of Steve's cog – as well as a critical part of Apple's success during his years – that I don't think it's that hard to know. Of course he'd be listening to users and take into consideration what he thought they wanted from Apple. I imagine the ability to gauge some of their applause instantaneously – an ability modern Apple has voluntarily waived – was another reason he loved the live keynotes.
 
  • Like
Reactions: hieranonymous
This is the last time I really loved Control Center design and look.
(like iOS 12 I think?)

636322847516702018_c0018d4873.webp

Good lord, that looks like an oasis.

I can't help but think of Steve Jobs occasionally mentioning in keynotes that the staff was working on a current problem only to realize they'd solved it years ago.
 
Okay, so, basically, iOS 18, which still looks and feels a lot like iOS 7, just a bit less flat. So, Apple is apparently unable to actually overhaul iOS with a new, modern, tastefully done design that doesn't blind you, or that goes beyond the dock and a few overlays.
 
Liquid Glass has really felt like change for the sake of change for me, like they ran out of ideas of where to take the design and said "let's update Windows 7's glass for 2025!"

It just hasn't worked for me. The HDR highlights on button taps are bright as hell, the interface feels incredibly cluttered (mostly due to interface elements that IMO are larger than they need to be)...

Just not a fan, unfortunately. I hope they can dial it in, similar to how by iOS 9/10, they'd really dialed in the iOS 7 look.

That's largely how it's felt to me since the start. I kind of get the chain of reasoning: "device screens are all rounded now," "there's wasted space around the corners," "wouldn't it be nice if the content could extend all the way out," "if the content extends all the way out, wouldn't it be nice if the interface didn't totally obscure it," et cetera.

But within a week of the announcement, I'd already arrived at my own chain: "okay, there are some reasonable starting points there," "they've really taken them pretty far," "Apple's biggest design changes are usually the most drastic in the initial stage and settle in from there," "do I really want another one of those right now, when so much seems so well-settled already," and so on. And, so… here we are in the initial fade of the initial stage, I guess. It's still going to be a while.
 
I think Liquid Glass has been a mixed design, it's often not the transparency that causes issues, on Tahoe at least, it's the general lack of contrast, endless white panes with dark text and no contrast between side bars and main panel (music app), or moving elements as part of a redesign for its own sake, such a moving the main controls from the top of the screen and shoving them on a random island floating in the content (music app), or basically just...the music app.
100%. The contrast in the new design is awful. Everything is just so washed out. Until they fix that I'll stay where I am on Mac as I use it 14 hours a day.
 
This shows that Apple has absolutely no idea how to solve this problem. They opted for a solution that has nothing to do with usability or readability, and they don't have a setting that would be both transparent and readable. Now they're resorting to a prosthetic. Complete absurdity. What's next? Rounding the corners in the Tahoe? (That wouldn't hurt, though.)
 
So hard to know. He did champion brushed metal and full on skeuomorphism. And back in the day, he extolled the very transparent Aqua 10.0 interface.

I think that the Apple of the 21st century has consistently championed 'look at me!' interfaces - although I would argue that the much maligned flat iOS 7 was pretty restrained.
and the transparency got toned down every release after Jaguar (10.2)

So did iOS 7's translucency. It was too translucent on release and they gradually toned it down over the years.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.