Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
No matter how much of manual controls, you won't get a DSLR out of a phone camera. Those control helps but not make it better especially if you don't know what you're doing with them. In that sense, I was very impressed by the exposure adjustment demo Apple showed during iOS 8 announcement, which seems to be more along the line of Steve Jobs style feature that the system is simplifying the usage for the user.
 
Raw support

The whole point to a RAW is uncompressed files for editing.

There are compressed RAW formats. Canon CR2 and Adobe DNG both nondestructively compress RAW for example ;)

And to whomever said it's a "fail" on 8G iPhone- no one says you have to turn that option on. Let's not push for least common denominator features. Look to the future.
 
It would be awesome if you could download iPhone themes/icons like in Android. Can you imagine the possibilities? You won't have to deal with the ugly Safari icon. And Apple could focus on features instead of software UI design.
 
It would be awesome if you could download iPhone themes/icons like in Android. Can you imagine the possibilities? You won't have to deal with the ugly Safari icon. And Apple could focus on features instead of software UI design.

This is already possible.
 
There are compressed RAW formats. Canon CR2 and Adobe DNG both nondestructively compress RAW for example ;)

And to whomever said it's a "fail" on 8G iPhone- no one says you have to turn that option on. Let's not push for least common denominator features. Look to the future.

I look at the past, because looking at the past, it always seems to repeat itself, its inevitable. :D
 
You can allow it to focus and adjust then lock the AE/AF if you want to be able to shoot quickly without having to readjust.

I meant you cannot force the current (pre-IOS8) iOS camera in any way to use a shutter speed of at least 1/250s if it means having to use an ISO higher than the base ISO. This is why the iOS camera is (has been) useless in this scenario.

----------

No matter how much of manual controls, you won't get a DSLR out of a phone camera.

Of course you won't. It's only the Nokia 808 that can, in some way, match DSLR's, and only WRT effective resolution. (But not DR / noise / RAW support / AF speed.)

Nevertheless, full manual control is a godsend, particularly because previously the iPhone camera was completely useless under certain circumstances because of the complete lack of manual control and the system's always striving to use as low ISO as possible, making it impossible to shoot for example action under worse light. (See my prev. posts.)

----------

Please give us a raw files mode. Nokia promised it, and then never delivered.

Wrong. WP Nokias do have RAW, unlike, regrettably, iOS8.

----------

Would love to have manual focus control—especially when trying to take a photo of something up close.

You will have it in iOS8. And it's working wonderfully.

I, again, recommend checking out my own camera app at https://forums.macrumors.com/showthread.php?p=19223035 . If you have a friend that can compile & deploy iOS sources for you, you can start using it now.
 
I meant you cannot force the current (pre-IOS8) iOS camera in any way to use a shutter speed of at least 1/250s if it means having to use an ISO higher than the base ISO. This is why the iOS camera is (has been) useless in this scenario.

I see what you mean. I admit that I skimmed the article and didn't research much and thought the shutter speed was fixed. You're right about that.
 
Would a phone produce useable RAWs though? I mean of course they'd be uncompressed, unsharpened and un-noise reduced, which is already better than JPEG, but would the dynamic range be any better? I doubt the iPhone's sensor has a dynamic range greater than what we're already seeing in the JPEGs. It would of course be good to have RAW but maybe we're over estimating the benefit, this is not a DSLR.

The real issue is color balance, and highlight and shadow detail. if it looks like black on a jpeg, you won't be able to lift the shadows. Not so with raw.
 
A what kind of phone? ;)

HTC 8S - I only have it because I don't want to spend more than £25 on a phone a month as I'm a student and I'm not a fan on Android as I had real bad experience before ( though with windows phone I feel app less so I don't know what to do - see what windows phone 8.1 does and then maybe go for another windows phone or Andorid when my contract runs out).
 
Please give us a raw files mode. Nokia promised it, and then never delivered. It'd be such a nice option.

You don't know what you're talking about. They did deliver, and it's available on several Windows Phones right now, along with manual controls.
 
The real issue is color balance, and highlight and shadow detail. if it looks like black on a jpeg, you won't be able to lift the shadows. Not so with raw.
This is only possible if the RAW format has a bit depth greater than 8bit/ch. I guess with the iPhone this is probably not the case (at least not without any tweaks, like combining multiple exposures to enhance depth).
 
Mac Rumors must have a new writer, and I dislike their style. Over the last few days ive noticed most of the pieces when describing a few points always the the very annoying .....and more at the end of the sentence. The piece about the Amazon phone was covered in this awful style of writing. Its lazy.

:mad:
 
This is only possible if the RAW format has a bit depth greater than 8bit/ch. I guess with the iPhone this is probably not the case (at least not without any tweaks, like combining multiple exposures to enhance depth).

I wouldn't be so sure. Modern image sensors usually have a greater dynamic range than a jpeg can represent. Giving us access to the RAW file means we could adjust the exposure a lot more without introducing noise.
 
HTC 8S - I only have it because I don't want to spend more than £25 on a phone a month as I'm a student and I'm not a fan on Android as I had real bad experience before ( though with windows phone I feel app less so I don't know what to do - see what windows phone 8.1 does and then maybe go for another windows phone or Andorid when my contract runs out).

I have a Nokia 520 as well and I really like it sometimes more than my iPhone. Running WP 8.1 makes it on par with iOS i feel.
 
I like how it is the normal controls, until you open it up to all of the full controls… For standard too advanced users… Looks pretty awesome!
 
It is.....

interesting to see how a device, as cell phone, had evolved to do more things than originally conceived. I think that is the reason more and more cell phones are not more "normal cell phones" and become "smartphones". I know for sure people what value things like bigger screen sizes and,yes, camera abilities in their phones.....I think Apple is pushing toward better camera management in the iPhone because the competition have very good offers. Nokia phones are preferred by some people for their cameras, having even some 41-megapixels model. Obviously, a powerful camera without equal powerful controls is not so good.....:eek:

And yet, too many people will end with an expensive camera.....(not so expensive as many DSLR s).....

:):apple:
 
This is only possible if the RAW format has a bit depth greater than 8bit/ch.

Color balance can be fixed with any bit depth. While iOS has excellent automatic WB, in some cases it can too be fooled (e.g., flourescent lighting).

----------

Because 90% of people only want/need the basics?

... because they're too dumb for a much more capable camera (or, in general, phone / any UI) interface?

----------

Giving us access to the RAW file means we could adjust the exposure a lot more without introducing noise.

Also add that iOS has very strong and destructive noise reduction. It'd be great to be able to have access to the non-NR'ed originals, as is the case with Nokia's handsets.

Too bad Apple still refuses to give us RAW access.
 
Why minus the aperture?

It has a fixed aperture. I think f/2.2 or something like that. Having variable aperture like a DSLR lens would necessitate the lens being larger.

I don't know what the smallest variable/adjustable aperture lens would be.
 
Please give us a raw files mode. Nokia promised it, and then never delivered. It'd be such a nice option.

Sorry to dissapoint you, but Nokia delivered months ago. :)

http://conversations.nokia.com/2013/10/29/another-nokia-first-digital-negatives-raw-dng-lumia/

http://conversations.nokia.com/2013/11/20/nokia-camera-raw-dng-support-available-now/

Lumia 1020, 1520, Icon/930 and probably all other future "Pureview" camera phones.
Luckily none of them was ever shipped with 8BG storage. 32GB or 16GB+MicroSD (up to 128GB)

And (almost?) all Lumia phones have manual control for shutter speed, aperture, focus, iso... from even earlier.
 
Last edited:
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.