Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Well

  • air, no brainer

    Votes: 44 39.3%
  • Mini retina, no brainer

    Votes: 23 20.5%
  • Air, but tough choice

    Votes: 17 15.2%
  • Mini retina, tough choice

    Votes: 28 25.0%

  • Total voters
    112
iPad Air iPad Air iPad Air! I love the 9.7 inch display in my 3rd gen ipad. I feel that the 7.9 inch of the mini really only is good for travel. I would never want to sit at home and use a mini.
 
iPad Air iPad Air iPad Air! I love the 9.7 inch display in my 3rd gen ipad. I feel that the 7.9 inch of the mini really only is good for travel. I would never want to sit at home and use a mini.

You should try it. Using one at home would change your mind. I have both. I love the Air but use the rMini.
 
i was a bit jealous of the mini form factor when i had the older iPad. but once the air came out it was a winner and it really feels no heavier than the mini retina.

Yep. I never liked the size of the mini. Just a tad too small and too toylike for me. The Air has the perfect sized screen for a tablet, IMO. Not too big or small. The goldilocks story comes to mind..... :D
 
As others have mentioned in other posts. It's not until you compare the colors to the Air will you see a difference. I have an Air and tried both the Mini and rMini and I could see a slight difference in the colors.



There's nothing wrong with the rMini screen until you compare it with a Galaxy Tab S. ;)

So, a slight difference is the same as a major colour gamut problem now is it?
Stop with the hyperbole, their is NOTHING wrong with the Retina iPad Mini screen, I can imagine people on here sticking their noses up to their Retina MacBook 's and their Apple Cinema displays to try and detect differences... :rolleyes:
And I will assume you are being funny with the Samsung comment? Relating to the stupid advert posted on the front page the other week?
 
Tried the mini, it's a really useful device but the Air is portable enough for me, and I like the bigger screen, and the screen (colours especially) also seems more dynamic.
 
You should try it. Using one at home would change your mind. I have both. I love the Air but use the rMini.

I haven't tried the retina mini, but I did have the original mini, and the iPad 3. When I got the original mini, I used it exclusively, both at home and out of the house, for about a week. I then picked up the 3, and my god, everything was so much bigger and easier to see and use. I still kept the original mini for on-the-go because it was so much lighter than the 3. But when home, I almost always used the 3. And when the Air came out, I got the Air and never looked back.
 
I picked iPad Air but that is really because of two things

A) My usage needs. I use my iPad Air for reading textbooks and pdf articles and don't want to do that on a smaller screen. That doesn't make the iPad rMini bad. It just doesn't suite my particular usage case.

B) The UI on the iPad rMini (at least if it is the same as the older iPad Mini) is too small. They just shrunk down whatever was on the full size iPad to the size of the iPad mini and it makes text and touch targets sometimes a bit too small. Small android tablets (not perfect by any means) don't have this particular problem because their UI was designed for their size. This is a fault of the mini vs. the full size iPad but I'm guessing that it is something some people can get used to. I didn't want to get used to it.

I think anyone who is deciding just between iPad Air vs iPad rMini should decide first if they want a small or a large tablet. The iPad Air is light for a large tablet but it is not a one-handed device (for me anyway). It is significantly heavier than the mini tablet category so if you want a small light device I don't think the iPad Air will make you happy but if you don't care as much about that then the iPad Air is the better device (mainly due to point B).
 
I think the question is better posted if the rMini also has the same color gamut quality as iPad Air.


But anyway, value-wise iPad Air wins me. But I find rMini is more practical and easier to carry around.
 
it's like asking

you are living in a city or in a tiny town on the mountains many miles away from civilization
what would you take a small city car or a large jeep



is not about money, specs, better or not

is about own preference and kind of use

more portability (tinier the better)
larger screen

awaiting for the rMini 3
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.