says_stuff
macrumors regular
I get your opinion and I thank you for trying to help with the issues reported so please do stick around.iPadOS is as great as ever, and I love the new features. Nobody ruined it. Though I do agree that many tech writers have come across as far too whiny and overly critical of the iPad and iPadOS. And I feel that some who built their careers on iPad content, like Federico Vittici at MacStories and Fernando Silva over at 9to5Mac to name some names, are kind of betraying the iPad user base with nonsensical comparisons to the MacBook Neo… Hopefully they come back around to better iPad content. Honestly, I was getting really frustrated with Vittici’s constant negative content streak there for a while, but then he had some positive stuff about iPadOS 26 and I thought maybe we’re getting back to that positive and useful iPad content I loved from him. But it seems now we’re back at more negativity again… It’s frustrating to me. I respect him and really like some of his content (and owe him for some of his work I’ve greatly benefited from), so I don’t want to be too hard on him. But it is sad to see. It feels like he’s just trying to fit in with the narrative of other tech writers, where before he wasn’t afraid to “think different”…? I don’t know, it’s just really frustrating and sad.
All that said, I find iPadOS 26 to be a great update, and the new features improve my workflow on a near daily basis. At first I was a little worried about the new windowing feature possibly being more cluttered than the prior Stage Manager system, but I think they struck the perfect balance. App windows can still sort of autosnap on a grid if you want your window to be centered, and you’re moving it more slow and intentionally, but windows can also be placed wherever on the screen. It’s hard to describe, but it just works… I do think they could add basic split screen to the fullscreen windows mode, or an in-between option, but I think they wanted to simplify things and cut down on the multiple separate multitasking systems thing. Perhaps they’ll add an intermediate mode or something. Personally, I think the new multitasking mode works perfectly fine, and Split View and Slide Over aren’t that terribly different from the way it was before…
App UIs that don’t behave within the system’s UI paradigms are solidly the fault of app developers, not iPadOS or Apple. App developers have had plenty of time to correct their app UIs for the windowing controls. And I think some must either be encountering user error based things, or rare bugs. Because I run the developer betas (dramatically ups my risk of encountering major bugs), and also use it as my daily driver (further ups my risk of encountering major bugs), yet I have rarely encountered a single bug, and nothing that was unusable…
That said, I feel like I’ve read the same comment many times now: that there are definitely no bugs and that everything works perfectly. When people say that while others are clearly describing problems or changes they dislike, it starts to feel like the discussion turns into just dismissing those experiences rather than engaging with them.
Some people genuinely like the changes, and others don’t. Both are valid reactions. But when the conversation is just the same “there are no issues” or “people are exaggerating,” it ends up invalidating what others are seeing on their own devices.
I can clearly see that things have changed dramaticaly and I expect that opinions about it will differ on whether those changes are good or bad. What would be helpful is hearing from people who updated to 26.3 or 26.4 and can describe whether anything improved or changed in their experience.You guys seem dead set from the 26.00 beta onwards that this is the best thing ever. Could we also hear from the other side without having them shot down?
Right now the conversation to be had feels nothing like an actual discussion and more like people repeating that everything is perfect or that complaints are only hyperbole. That doesn’t really help anyone figure out what’s actually happening across different devices and setups.
Personally, I’m hesitant to update because I don’t want to risk breaking a workflow that currently works for me, so what i’m saying is I would love to read more about both sides’ experiences and I feel that would be genuinely helpful to all.