Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
I think we can argue that they SHOULD be made to be droppable. They're a relatively small item we take everywhere we go and use often. It's inevitable that the average person will drop it occasionally.

I'd estimate I drop mine about twice a year and I consider myself fairly careful with my stuff. Life just happens. Thankfully it's in an Otterbox Symmetry so it's fine.
If we want those phones that they have to be made with plastic (including front glass).
And phones won't look pretty.
 
Glass is Glass at the end of the day, and it will break, no matter how "strong" Apple Claims it to Be. I wish they had returned the aluminum back from the older iPhones.
then people will say no wireless charging no iPhone for me :)
and i think old design aluminum phones were good for heat transfer too, compared to glass back now.
 
OK I'll do my best not to drop my Pro 14 Max. Do you guys think the Apple Silicon case is enough to protect an iPhone?
I keep telling everyone I know to consider the Tech 21 "shock proof" line of cases. If they don't have one for a Pro 14 Max out yet, I'm sure it's coming any time now. I've used them on the last few iPhones I've owned and they've all been dropped numerous times with no damage except some scuffing of the plastic translucent cases.

 
  • Like
Reactions: macos9rules
Drop tests are rather silly and wasteful at this point. It’s glass. They’re all going to break when dropped at the right height and angle- which when done on accident, is totally out of the user’s control. Get AC+ and go naked if you can afford the time and costs of covered repairs, or else just get a good case and call it a day. Scratch tests are more important to me because AC+ doesn’t cover cosmetic damage.
 
I keep telling everyone I know to consider the Tech 21 "shock proof" line of cases. If they don't have one for a Pro 14 Max out yet, I'm sure it's coming any time now. I've used them on the last few iPhones I've owned and they've all been dropped numerous times with no damage except some scuffing of the plastic translucent cases.

That’s a great case, but there are plenty of much cheaper alternatives that work just fine for drop protection. I drop my phones at least a few times a week and they’ve never sustained damage when in a decent case. I usually get the cheapest I can find on Amazon with good reviews and they’ve all provided sufficient protection.
 
Pointless test. They will crack differently every time they drop so it's impossible to say anything meaningful with drop tests.
Not sure I completely agree.
Whilst they will crack differently the end goal is to have no cracking at all which would be difficult to ascertain without a drop test?
 
Is that PhoneBuff thing actually a genuine video, or just a series of ads for a phone case loosely bolted together?
 
Oh, so these youtube princesses still do these pointless tests? :D Didn't know it is still a thing. Hows angry birds charting in app store top charts? :D
 
Not sure I completely agree.
Whilst they will crack differently the end goal is to have no cracking at all which would be difficult to ascertain without a drop test?
They're obviously going to break when dropped. They're covered in glass. If they become semi unbreakable, we'll be beaten over the head with that in the media hype from it.
 
Is that PhoneBuff thing actually a genuine video, or just a series of ads for a phone case loosely bolted together?
Oh, it's absolutely a genuine video; you can tell by the fact that it's on YouTube and has a play button. I totally know a video when I see one!

Ooooooohhhhh -- you meant to say a genuine analysis... didn't you? 😆

But more seriously; even with the obvious advertising tie in, I actually see some value in demonstrating that all of those "other" drop test videos that other people do are largely missing the point, by not actually performing a direct comparison between an uncased and a cased cell phone. It's good to remind people that there's legitimate value in putting a protective sleeve around that beautiful glass body, even if it does obscure that beauty just a bit. (Personally I prefer to use a clear silicone case.)
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.