If you didn’t like the Sheath texture in the past I wouldn’t recommend it now. Most people either love it or hate it.I think I am going to go with Caudabe. I have been turned off Phone Rebel since the Orange Tough Ultra kit which is what I want has been out of stock for ages.
For those familiar with Caudabe cases, which would you say is the better case in terms of comfort in the hands and have a tight fit (I hate cases that are loose on the sides). The Paragon or the Sheath?
I had the Sheath a couple of years ago and I wasn't very fond of the sandpaper like feel of the case but I only tried it for a couple of hours I must admit, so maybe the feel of the case is something that takes getting used to.
I’d also warn against their cutout, which is uncomfortable. They’ve been promising CC button versions of their cases forever; they’re now saying end of April, but I wouldn’t bet money on it.
Whatever you decide, I feel you have to try various cases to see what works best for you. We’re all here stating our personal preferences, but you’ll never know what you’ll actually like until you try them yourself. That’s my $.02.