Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
iPhone 3G S is FASTER than Palm Pre & iPhone 3G

A series of benchmarks have shown that Apple's latest iPhone is so fast that it outpaces not just the older iPhone but Palm's self-proclaimed speed champ, the Pre. Sales are also poised to break speed records as new estimates suggest that Apple will sell significantly more than 500,000 iPhone 3G S units this weekend.

Benchmarks give iPhone 3G S clear lead over old model, Pre

While many informal comparisons have been conducted to show just how much faster the iPhone 3G S is over its predecessor, a new series of tests on Friday has shown that many of Apple's claims are borne out not just against the iPhone 3G but the Palm Pre and the only currently available Android phone in the US, the T-Mobile G1.

In loading a series of complex websites over Wi-Fi, AnandTech has found that the 3G S is about 54 percent faster on average than the 3G and, in a few cases, is about three times faster. But it's also about 11 percent faster than the Palm Pre, which shares WebKit as a rendering engine, and is only slower in two out of nine tests. That lead only grows wider with the T-Mobile G1: as it's slower than the iPhone 3G, it's often twice as fast or more.

Load times for commonly available apps were less dramatic between iPhones but only exacerbated the gaps between the Pre and Apple's hardware. A 3G S is between 13 percent and 42 percent faster at loading these apps versus a 3G depending on conditions, but it starts these roughly between two and four times faster than a Pre. Again, the sole Android phone in the comparison is slower still in all but Google Maps.

iPhone 3G S web browsing times



iPhone 3G S app loading times



Almost all of the speedup is attributed to the Samsung ARM Cortex A8 processor at the heart of the new iPhone. Its clock speed gain is obvious, but it can also issue two instructions at once instead of the original iPhone's one and has more than twice as much cache. Palm is using an OMAP 3 chip from Texas Instruments that itself is considered fast.

iPhone 3G S sales likely to easily exceed 500,000: analyst

Just as the phone itself is fast, the iPhone 3G S should also outrun previous launch sales estimates, Piper Jaffray senior analyst Gene Munster said today in an investment note.

His research firm had originally predicted half a million units trading hands this weekend but now believes that figure is "conservative" based on early results. At the 5th Avenue Apple store in New York City, the analysts saw 350 customers in line. That was significantly less than the 540 in line last year, but above the 270 predicted last year.

On top of first-hand observations, Munster notes that the carriers themselves have also been very pleased and say that their early results have gone beyond expectations. AT&T's wireless chief Ralph de la Vega told CNBC that there were "hundreds of thousands" of pre-orders for the iPhone 3G before it went on sale. Outside of this, AppleInsider has heard of quick sellouts in at least the US and Canada.

Britain's O2, meanwhile, said that the iPhone 3G S had already sold more units by noon on Friday than the iPhone 3G had managed in its first 24 hours. Retail traffic was 10 times higher than usual, while web views were 150 percent higher.

Apple's performance is less than the million units it managed last year but is potentially impressive as only eight countries could participate on launch day where 21 had that option before. Subsequent launches in the next few weeks should have a much more tangible impact on Apple's overall numbers.

Source: http://appleinsider.com/
Source: http://www.anandtech.com/gadgets/showdoc.aspx?i=3587
 
Side by side over wifi, my 3Gs is significantly faster than my wife's 3G. We really notice the difference.

I agree! I had the 3G S and 3G side by side, on my college WiFi network, and the 3G S roasted the 3G speeds.
 
Updated its even faster!!!

It's not 11 percent, its much higher! :)

It's still amazing the big difference in application launch times.

"Update: Thanks to the many readers who have pointed out my incorrect wording of the 3GS' performance improvements. The tables in the article have been updated to reflect the correct percentages. I appreciate the corrections :)"

http://www.anandtech.com/gadgets/showdoc.aspx?i=3587
 
Application load times blows it away. Should get faster once 3.01 gets around. :)
 
So...what's new? The iPhone is still the best phone in the world for 2 years and going.

Yeah, an OS thats 2 years old and 2 revisions later beating out a brand new ver 1 OS. Yup, iPhone still stop dog! :rolleyes:
 
Yeah, an OS thats 2 years old and 2 revisions later beating out a brand new ver 1 OS. Yup, iPhone still stop dog! :rolleyes:

ROFL.

That is your position say what?

If that is the case then the iPhone should be slower than every nokia and samsung handset that was out before them?

I don't understand your point?

The 3GS and Pre came out almost at the same time, and apparently the 3GS is markedly faster. It is a fair comparison and speaks volumes.

You can wish it away all you want but it is what it is. Do you think Apple will stop improving the iphone and improving the OS while Palm catches up?

Do you think the 3rd generation Palm Pre in 2 years will be as significantly upgraded as the iPhone was?

I love the eyeroll emoticon. Anytime I see it I can pretty much be sure that the person posting is not bright. It is a great warning sign, "Bad information and faulty logic ahead!" Not sure why the two are connected, but they are.
 
Yeah, an OS thats 2 years old and 2 revisions later beating out a brand new ver 1 OS. Yup, iPhone still stop dog! :rolleyes:

Exactly. But with all you just said, what the facts currently? The iPhone is the best phone out. (Widespread consensus)
What was it a year ago? iPhone!
Two years ago? iPhone!
Next Year? iPhone!


Let me lay out the facts bud.
---------------------------------------
Pre comes out with new software update, not as fast as 3GS but narrows the margin.
A week later the iPhone re-broadens that margin with it's own software.
-----
Repeat for a year.
------
The Pre 2 is released and is better than the 3GS
The iPhone 4G comes out a week later and is better the Pre 2
 
He won't get it. The Palm Pee was touted as the iPhone Killer. This was to show that some PC guys can't just walk in and do what Palm can do. Well Apple didn't walk in, they flew right over and waved bye bye.
 
ROFL.

That is your position say what?

If that is the case then the iPhone should be slower than every nokia and samsung handset that was out before them?

I don't understand your point?

The 3GS and Pre came out almost at the same time, and apparently the 3GS is markedly faster. It is a fair comparison and speaks volumes.

You can wish it away all you want but it is what it is. Do you think Apple will stop improving the iphone and improving the OS while Palm catches up?

Do you think the 3rd generation Palm Pre in 2 years will be as significantly upgraded as the iPhone was?

I love the eyeroll emoticon. Anytime I see it I can pretty much be sure that the person posting is not bright. It is a great warning sign, "Bad information and faulty logic ahead!" Not sure why the two are connected, but they are.

Don't mind them, I guess going by that logic Nokia phones should all be faster than iphones since they have been making phones for years. Palm has also been making phones for years, its just they sucked which is why they are in the position they are.
 
In my location the Pre is faster than every iPhone that there is out. 1g, 3g, and 3gs because ATT sucks in my area. I will take Sprint over ATT any-day. I have 3G now with Sprint and would blow any iPhone out of the water it every aspect except opening applications unless they require a data connection then I would blow them away as well. On top of this my plan is $70 a month cheaper for more services. So for me, until Apple decides to quit dealing with one company(AT&T). As much as I love Apple and the iPhone, the Pre suits every need I have and actually have grown to like some things about it better than I did the iPhone. Please don't sit there and down the Pre when everyones needs and wants are different. In my case the Pre serves me perfectly. Again, I had the iPhone for 2 years.
 
The Apple fanboi at work hasn't upgraded (he was thinking about holding out until next year's offering. ) and he had his 3G side-by-side with a 3GS. The difference was amazing. I think he probably went down to the Apple Store this weekend. ;)
 
In my location the Pre is faster than every iPhone that there is out. 1g, 3g, and 3gs because ATT sucks in my area.

If AT&T were bad in my area, I would probably consider a Pre. Fortunately, the big three networks (VZW, Sprint, AT&T) are about equal where I live and frequently travel, so I'm good. AT&T 3G has always served me well. And given the horrid customer service and billing experiences I've had with Sprint, I would never willingly go back.

Sprint and Palm have both made some pretty bad mistakes, and both need to fight to survive. It's no wonder they teamed up.

On top of this my plan is $70 a month cheaper for more services.

Oh really? Because the Sprint website indicates that a "Simply Everything" plan is required for a Pre, which when you compare to iPhone plans, they come out at about the same price. Actually, with my FAN discount, I'm paying less than I would on Sprint for the Pre. Certainly a far cry from $70 more per month.

Anyway, best of luck with your Pre.
 
Hmmm my 3G is just as fast as the 3GS!

Well I just did a test myself on WIFI like the first post link and I can says that on every web site I got the same speed as the 3GS with my 3G.
122% faster then 3G NO WAY

Charlie C
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.