Become a MacRumors Supporter for $25/year with no ads, private forums, and more!

iPhone 4 Drop Test with Bumper Case

MacRumors

macrumors bot
Original poster
Apr 12, 2001
50,432
11,815
https://www.macrumors.com/images/macrumorsthreadlogodarkd.png

iFixyouri has performed a drop test on the iPhone 4 with one of Apple's bumper cases to see if there is much protection offered by the accessory.
We’ve have known for a little while now that iPhone 4 bumpers do not offer all of the protection needed because customers have called in an told us. Although it does not take a video by iFixyouri to inform you that dropping your new iPhone 4 on concrete is a bad idea, hopefully this video squashed any doubts as to the bumpers effectiveness.
The iPhone 4 was dropped from a natural standing height onto concrete. The iPhone 4 with bumper lasted only 3 drops before the front glass cracked. This was the same number of drops that it took to break an unprotected iPhone 4. It does appear the iPhone 4 hit the concrete face down for the last fall, so how it falls likely affects the chances of the glass breaking.

Unfortunately, there have been no comparison tests with more traditional cases, so we're not yet sure how much better protection a full case actually offers.

Article Link: iPhone 4 Drop Test with Bumper Case
 

MorphingDragon

macrumors 603
Mar 27, 2009
5,160
5
The World Inbetween
NEWS FLASH: Dropping your phone can break it!

News Flash: Cars crumple if you smash them into walls.

Its called testing for a reason, though its not uncommon for people to drop their phones.

---

IMO, I have found that leather + silicon is the best protector combo. (Leather by itself is fine)
 
Comment

ltldrummerboy

macrumors 68000
Oct 15, 2007
1,534
9
This doesn't surprise me. The bumpers only ever seemed to be a way to alleviate the signal loss problem.
 
Comment

Chaszmyr

macrumors 601
Aug 9, 2002
4,267
85
Presumably, the details of a specific drop (angle of impact, height of fall, speed, and surface it falls onto) are a lot more relevant than how many times the phone has been dropped. As such, comparing a single test like this to a single test of an iPhone being dropped until breaking without a case is nearly meaningless.
 
Comment

tofa.nheu

macrumors member
May 14, 2010
41
0
waste of time? waste of money LOL
give me free iphone 4 if your thinking of performing this "test"
STUPID
 
Comment

Kensai

macrumors member
Jun 3, 2010
43
4
Let's face it. iPhone 4 is a great smartphone, but it has some minor design issues they will probably iron out in iPhone 5.

Yes, dropping a phone on concrete will eventually break it, but it's almost unbelievable it happens so easily even with the bumpers. So it's safe to say we have a bumper design fail as well. As someone else above said, they were probably designed to alleviate the signal issues anyway.
 
Comment

cptdavep

macrumors newbie
Dec 15, 2008
11
0
Funny, I've never seen a sapphire shatter on contact with concrete... helicopter windows however most definitely do.
 
Comment

ValSalva

macrumors 68040
Jun 26, 2009
3,746
201
Burpelson AFB
The existence of bumpers just proves that Apple knew about the iPhone antenna issues before they released the iPhone 4. It provides just enough distance from one's hands and the antenna. What a coincidence. Apple now has a PR nightmare on their hands. And yet - the iPhone 4 still sells like crazy. Amazing.
 
Comment

BenjyD

macrumors newbie
Apr 20, 2006
24
0
Norwich, Norfolk, UK
waste of time? waste of money LOL
give me free iphone 4 if your thinking of performing this "test"
STUPID

The advertising value is enormous. A video, article and a link from multiple mac news sites for the price of one iPhone 4? That's an incredible deal for the website.

Of course, they're relying on sites so desperate for news that they think "phone breaks after being dropped multiple times onto concrete" is worth reporting.
 
Comment

igorleandro

macrumors member
Sep 19, 2008
54
0
Well, every material has a certain "bending". On impact, with a really fast capture camera you can see that a lot of "solid" things do bend and return to their original form after.

Glass is no exception, and honestly, the bumper "case" he had is just to protect from table scratches. If you ever carried your phone with keys you know pretty well what I'm talking about.

So, it lands flat, glass bends a bit which is ok, but then it hits concrete and breaks, big deal. You should have a real anti-shock case if you're that careful.

Why don't you drop it without a case on marble and say it breaks too easily then?

One day we might be able to have titanium with 99% transparency. Before that, you just can't be that stupid.
 
Comment

ri0ku

macrumors 6502a
Mar 11, 2009
952
0
Just avoid dropping your iPhone that way.


Sent from S.jobs iPhone 4 with titanium case.
 
Comment

G5isAlive

Suspended
Aug 28, 2003
1,097
1,653
got it. if you are going to drop your iphone, only drop it once, or maybe twice, never three times! Thanks for the informative story.
 
Comment

Fliesen

macrumors 6502a
Mar 30, 2010
758
2
Austria
bold statement:

"whatever you drop on concrete has a decent chance of breaking."

you just don't drop stuff on concrete, period
 
Comment

DickKnowsBest

macrumors member
Jun 24, 2010
37
0
Video at 1:51

"The signal just dropped down on it"

No no no no no. You're just holding it wrong. :D
 
Comment
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.