Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Seems like alot of trouble for the developers for a mere .2 increase in screen size. Either go w/ a 4 inch screen or stick with 3.5 but fiddling around in the middle is just a waste :(
 
with a 3.7 inch display Apple is behind, right out of the gate once again.

4 inches is perfect but then again fanboys will say 3.7 is just right because Apple can do no wrong in their eyes.

When will Apple ever get their ****** right?
 
with a 3.7 inch display Apple is behind, right out of the gate once again.

4 inches is perfect but then again fanboys will say 3.7 is just right because Apple can do no wrong in their eyes.

The iPhone size is perfect. I rarely find myself wanting for more screen real-estate. It's a phone, it's supposed to fit in pockets / cupholders, etc. and fit snugly in all types of hands.

I'd say 4" is too big for a phone. I'll be happy if they don't feel the need to upsize.
 
with a 3.7 inch display Apple is behind, right out of the gate once again.

4 inches is perfect but then again fanboys will say 3.7 is just right because Apple can do no wrong in their eyes.

When will Apple ever get their ****** right?

They' cant
 
Seems like alot of trouble for the developers for a mere .2 increase in screen size. Either go w/ a 4 inch screen or stick with 3.5 but fiddling around in the middle is just a waste :(

Why is it trouble for them to do nothing?

That's exactly what they'll have to do for such a minor change.

Granted a few of them may decide to make some UI changes to maximize the use of that space, but the vast majority of them will do absolutely nothing to their software after a change like that.
with a 3.7 inch display Apple is behind, right out of the gate once again.

4 inches is perfect but then again fanboys will say 3.7 is just right because Apple can do no wrong in their eyes.

When will Apple ever get their ****** right?

Uhm, duh...6 inches is 'perfect.' Come on. You're critisizing Apple and yet you don't even know the perfect size yourself?
 
Old phone was the Droid X, and the 4" screen was the one (of many) things I didn't like about that phone. 4"screen for a phone is too big and a hassle. It becomes more of a small tablet.
 
Why is it trouble for them to do nothing?

That's exactly what they'll have to do for such a minor change.

Granted a few of them may decide to make some UI changes to maximize the use of that space, but the vast majority of them will do absolutely nothing to their software after a change like that.


Uhm, duh...6 inches is 'perfect.' Come on. You're critisizing Apple and yet you don't even know the perfect size yourself?

I had a Nexus One with a 3.7 inch display and even though it was bigger than iPhone's 3.5 it was still lacking in size. I also have currently have a device with a 4 inch display and it's perfect, put along side my iPhone 4 it's noticeably bigger, not too big and not too small 4.3 inches is just way too big and clumsy.

From experience 3.7 just doesn't cut it....it's an improvement over 3.5 but still too small.
 
Old phone was the Droid X, and the 4" screen was the one (of many) things I didn't like about that phone. 4"screen for a phone is too big and a hassle. It becomes more of a small tablet.

The Droid X has a 4.3 inch display, you're mistaken or just might not be telling the truth.
 
From experience 3.7 just doesn't cut it....it's an improvement over 3.5 but still too small.

I know quite a few people who have complained that the current iPhone is a bit too big.

I could see Apple doing a 3.7 iPhone. Or I could see them doing a 3.5 and 4.0 choice. But there's no way in the world they'll go to 4.0 as the only option for the iPhone. They'll lose just as many customers as they'd gain.

Sure, some people like 4.0 screens. But I find it hilarious to call that 'perfect' when I know many people who wouldn't buy it. How can something that loses some customers be called perfect? I'd go with 'different' as a better word.

A 4.0 iPhone is just like a 17" Macbook. I think it's useful and they'll probably make one someday. But to think it'll be the most popular option...that's wishful thinking.
 
I know quite a few people who have complained that the current iPhone is a bit too big.

I could see Apple doing a 3.7 iPhone. Or I could see them doing a 3.5 and 4.0 choice. But there's no way in the world they'll go to 4.0 as the only option for the iPhone. They'll lose just as many customers as they'd gain.

Sure, some people like 4.0 screens. But I find it hilarious to call that 'perfect' when I know many people who wouldn't buy it. How can something that loses some customers be called perfect?

You're mistaken, remember most Apple users are like you and love whatever Apple produces.
 
You're mistaken, remember most Apple users are like you and love whatever Apple produces.

So since I don't want a 4" iPhone and those people are 'like me' then they wouldn't want a 4" iPhone so what you're saying is that you're wrong and they won't like whatever Apple produces.

So you've basically changed your mind, then?
 
Size

Had a Droid X and liked it, but it did feel big in my pocket. My IPhone 4 feels just right. I don't miss the extra screen size in the Droid.
 
Old phone was the Droid X, and the 4" screen was the one (of many) things I didn't like about that phone. 4"screen for a phone is too big and a hassle. It becomes more of a small tablet.
My Atrix is similar in size to an iPhone 4 and it houses a 4" display just fine.
The issue with the iPhone is a lot of wasted space around the screen.
Even the Atrix has about 4mm of wasted space on the sides of the screen.

I can see Apple maintaining the same height and width form factor of the iPhone 4 while having a 4" screen in there.

Atrix 117.75mm tall x 63.5mm wide

iPhone 4 115.2mm tall x 58.6mm wide

The differences are a matter of a few millimeters.

The Droid X was a beast at 127.5mm tall x 65.5 mm wide

All three are within a millimeter in thickness, so that is pretty much a non-issue.
 
Wirelessly posted (iPhone 4: Mozilla/5.0 (iPhone; U; CPU iPhone OS 4_3_2 like Mac OS X; en-us) AppleWebKit/533.17.9 (KHTML, like Gecko) Version/5.0.2 Mobile/8H7 Safari/6533.18.5)

JD914 said:
I know quite a few people who have complained that the current iPhone is a bit too big.

I could see Apple doing a 3.7 iPhone. Or I could see them doing a 3.5 and 4.0 choice. But there's no way in the world they'll go to 4.0 as the only option for the iPhone. They'll lose just as many customers as they'd gain.

Sure, some people like 4.0 screens. But I find it hilarious to call that 'perfect' when I know many people who wouldn't buy it. How can something that loses some customers be called perfect?

You're mistaken, remember most Apple users are like you and love whatever Apple produces.

Personally, I'd prefer a 3" iPhone with the same resolution, and definitely wouldn't want a 4" one as a preference. However, if that's the only size they do, I'd get it because I would rather compromise on a screen size I don't particularly like than the entire phone.
 
Wirelessly posted (iPhone 4: Mozilla/5.0 (iPhone; U; CPU iPhone OS 4_3_2 like Mac OS X; en-us) AppleWebKit/533.17.9 (KHTML, like Gecko) Version/5.0.2 Mobile/8H7 Safari/6533.18.5)



Personally, I'd prefer a 3" iPhone with the same resolution, and definitely wouldn't want a 4" one as a preference. However, if that's the only size they do, I'd get it because I would rather compromise on a screen size I don't particularly like than the entire phone.

You might want to rethink a 3" screen. Typing it on it would difficult regardless of how small your hands are. I say this because I had a 2.9" touchscreen phone & it was a pain to use.
 
In my opinion 3.7" would be perfect because look at the screen compared to the size of the phone. That screen size on that small of a phone makes the screen look bigger in my opinion.
 
i call fake. First, the people who were given the photo are very skeptical. Second, why is there just the one photo of the phone and then when it comes to comparison it shows an iphone 4 and just the screen part. If the provider of the pictures truly had the iphone 4s or 5 or whatever it will be called, wouldnt they take a picture with the two instead of the way they did it. My guess, they photoshopped one picture and were lazy on making another one. The screen part might be real though, but that would be easier to photoshop.
 
with a 3.7 inch display Apple is behind, right out of the gate once again.

4 inches is perfect but then again fanboys will say 3.7 is just right because Apple can do no wrong in their eyes.

When will Apple ever get their ****** right?
lol
I love it.
"It's not what I want. If you disagree, you're a fanboy!"
Hard to argue with "logic" like that


I care more about the overall size and fit in my pocket than the screen size. I wouldn't mind a bigger screen just to make the keyboard a little easier to type on. But I don't care about a bigger screen for anything other than that.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.