You drop anything on a surface like that with no case and it's going to scratch. I love how his beloved Galaxy came apart, ROTFLMAO! That cheap piece of plastic just popped right off that ugly brick!
As for the iPhone 5, I'm pretty impressed. I have my 4 in an Otterbox because I am clumsy and I do drop things, but even as clumsy as I am I've never even dropped my phone from the height of my ear standing. Out of my pocked all the time, or out of my purse, but that's been about it. I couldn't pre-order the 5 like I did the 4 because of timing, but it'll be mine in a few weeks. I can't wait!
BTW, even with that performance, mine will be in a case of some sort but seeing how well it holds up it might not be an Otterbox this time. I can't wait to get this phone!