Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

Newtons Apple

Suspended
Mar 12, 2014
22,757
15,254
Jacksonville, Florida
That's an accident though. If it's in a holster, you could bump into something and cause some damage also.

A good bit of damaged phones are due to accidents.

His phone was in a holster and still bent. He claimed the room was somewhat dark and he walked directly into the edge at full walking speed and actually bruised his leg. Just shows that stuff can happen.
 

zone23

macrumors 68000
May 10, 2012
1,986
793
Hate to be that guy, but please.. there is no way your phone bent from taking cases on and off. I switch Apple leather cases all the time and my phone doesn't look like a boomerang.
 

michael9891

Cancelled
Sep 26, 2016
3,060
3,945
A good bit of damaged phones are due to accidents.

His phone was in a holster and still bent. He claimed the room was somewhat dark and he walked directly into the edge at full walking speed and actually bruised his leg. Just shows that stuff can happen.

Why did you originally quote my post? You made it sound like his phone was in a front jeans pocket. All I was saying to the other guy was it's not lucky I've had no damage in a pocket.
[doublepost=1500209863][/doublepost]
Soft shell holsters,yes,but the one I use is made from milspec aluminium alloy and carbon fibre,so I guess my leg will be crushed long before the holster.

Like I've just said above, phones are fine in pockets. I've no desire to walk round with a holster and a hard case. No need.
 

Newtons Apple

Suspended
Mar 12, 2014
22,757
15,254
Jacksonville, Florida
Why did you originally quote my post? You made it sound like his phone was in a front jeans pocket. All I was saying to the other guy was it's not lucky I've had no damage in a pocket.
[doublepost=1500209863][/doublepost]

Like I've just said above, phones are fine in pockets. I've no desire to walk round with a holster and a hard case. No need.

Because you said a phone is perfectly safe in a front jeans pocket. That is not true.
 

michael9891

Cancelled
Sep 26, 2016
3,060
3,945
Because you said a phone is perfectly safe in a front jeans pocket. That is not true.

Of course they are. As with anything, be mindful of what you do. It's perfectly safe to go for a walk to the shops. There's always a chance you could get hit by a car. So is it not safe to go for walk?
 
  • Like
Reactions: 44267547

michael9891

Cancelled
Sep 26, 2016
3,060
3,945
I have already ridden my bike 14 miles this morning and I was lucky and escaped death.

Completely missing the point. There's simply no need to baby your phones in heavy duty cases, holsters under normal use. And I'm not accepting that in over 1,000 days of having either a 6+, 6s+ or 7+ I've been lucky not to bend my phone because I keep it in my front jeans pocket. Not saying any more on it, I've got better things to do.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 44267547

44267547

Cancelled
Jul 12, 2016
37,642
42,494
Completely missing the point. There's simply no need to baby your phones in heavy duty cases, holsters under normal use. And I'm not accepting that in over 1,000 days of having either a 6+, 6s+ or 7+ I've been lucky not to bend my phone because I keep it in my front jeans pocket. Not saying any more on it, I've got better things to do.

True. Accidents can happen. But likely it comes down to user negligence in most cases. If somebody puts their phone in the back pocket and sits on it, and it bends , that's clearly the users fault. Phones just don't spontaneously bend unless there is some type of force applied somewhere. But I also carry my phone in my front pocket and have never had any issues with bending. I'm also a very cautious person And Treat my property with respect. And for the record, I do not use holsters or hard cases.
 

HallStevenson

macrumors 6502a
May 1, 2012
551
323
but I guess I need to be more careful when selecting cases going forward.
Thing is, you don't know until you have the case and try it. I had a Spigen "thin-fit" case on my HTC M9 that was an extremely tight fit and a pain in the *** to remove. I has a 2nd Spigen case that was a bit more rugged that I swapped with every 3-4 months or so. Anyway, I ended up breaking the thin-fit case trying to remove it. Admittedly, it cracked in the area of the vol-up/down and power button (on the M9, these 3 buttons are next to each other) where there were the cut-outs.
 
  • Like
Reactions: timeconsumer

wproct

macrumors 6502
Dec 4, 2014
460
170
Iowa
The thing is, other than reading reviews, you don't know how a case is going to fit or how difficult it is going to be to remove until you try it. I have tried quite a few different cases. One of them was a Speck clear plastic case, and that case was so difficult to remove, I honestly thought I was going to damage my Iphone 5s, and that is a very sturdy phone design. I like a case that is fairly rigid to add strength and protection to my phone, which is currently a 6s, but not too difficult to remove from the phone. My current favorite is the Magpul Bump case, and also it does not seem to allow dirt and dust to get between it and the phone so I don't have to remove it much anyway but it is easy to get off when you need to.
 
  • Like
Reactions: timeconsumer

Moneoa

macrumors regular
Oct 8, 2015
144
128
True. Accidents can happen. But likely it comes down to user negligence in most cases. If somebody puts their phone in the back pocket and sits on it, and it bends , that's clearly the users fault. Phones just don't spontaneously bend unless there is some type of force applied somewhere. But I also carry my phone in my front pocket and have never had any issues with bending. I'm also a very cautious person And Treat my property with respect. And for the record, I do not use holsters or hard cases.

Anyone in tech or IT knows the mantra well, “user error” 99% of the time lol
 
  • Like
Reactions: HylianKnight

44267547

Cancelled
Jul 12, 2016
37,642
42,494
Anyone in tech or IT knows the mantra well, “user error” 99% of the time lol

Which is mostly true. However, Which is why I stated user negligence is likely in most cases. But in this situation, if the case was difficult to remove, With enough stress applied, it bent the aluminum by accident trying to remove the case. This isn't your typical "I swam with my iPhone in the ocean" or "Dropped my iPhone and it's Not my fault" negligence, even though the user caused the bending inadvertently, which they acknowledged as well.
[doublepost=1500265832][/doublepost]
Buy looser pants.

Pants are not the issue here according to the OP, especially if a hard plastic case was used, the bending would be highly unlikely in a front pocket as already mentioned. The OP stated it was from removing the case that was difficult that caused the bending.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: timeconsumer
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.