Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
This thing is so stupid. Image Dumbest idea ever.

Goodness. You think? Funny, IMO I hear dumber ideas here on a daily basis. And the only reason it isn't more often is that I don't visit the forums any more often than that.

Of course I want to walk around holding a cup in my hand, don't need my hands for more useful purposes.

I... you... you do realize that most people need a cup to drink out of, when they're, you know, at home, or at work, or something, and they want to consume a beverage. I mean, perhaps you store water in your hump or something? And when you want to fuel up you just shove a hose into your... watering port? (I'll leave it to the imaginations of everyone here just where that would be.)
 
Here's the most important question:

Can I put it in my dishwasher?



If it does I can finally stop using other people as my poison checkers!

But surely you also eat solid food... :confused:

----------

I actually dig this. I lost 35 pounds in the past 3 months just by counting calories accurately in all my food and drinks to know what was being shoveled into my body. For homemade items I have to manually calculate that, and enter that into an app, as well as manually adding every thing I drink.

You were on a diet, and you actually drank stuff with calories? I find switching to zero calorie drinks to be the first step in any diet.
 
Seeing as most people overeat their calories, I don't see the point of this. It's a fashion accessory and another thing that needs to be charged. Fat people can now pretend they are dieting by watching what they drink while shoving cookies down their chomper.

Well, if the 'judgmental cretin' crowd hates it, that must mean it's a good idea.
 
This thing is so stupid. Image Dumbest idea ever.

Of course I want to walk around holding a cup in my hand, don't need my hands for more useful purposes.

Certainly, typing these comments does not qualify as a "more useful purpose."

----------

Can it measure how much alcohol I have consumed? I have A hard time drinking enough booze, so it would be great to have a progress bar to help me reach my 24 beer per day goal. Imagine the convenience of not having to keep track of how many bottles of mouthwash, spirits, or wine I drink... This will free me up from keeping track and let me concentrate on finding new and interesting ways to ingest various alcoholic liquids.

I thought this was a joke, until I noticed where you were posting from. :D
 
If it was just a "how much am I drinking" smart cup, this would be in the same utterly ridiculous TMI category as all the other smart-[thing] junk like smart forks and whatnot.

However, the fact that it will apparently generate nutritional information for anything you put in it--including things that are not mass-produced--makes it a very, very cool bit of home nutritional science. (Assuming, of course, that it's accurate.)

Leaving health aside, just for the raw science of it, I'd be highly interested, for example, in what the actual caffeine content of the strong konacha that I have at dinner is compared to, say, kukicha or regular green tea. It's easy to find people saying how much caffeine green tea is supposed to have, after all, but that doesn't necessarily tell you anything realistic about how much is actually in that cup you just brewed.

Likewise, if I'm making my own smoothies or fruit or vegetable juice, knowing nutritionally what I've just mixed up would be at minimum interesting, and depending on how closely I watch my intake of various things could be quite valuable.

I'd almost buy one just for the chemical analysis fun of it.

I wonder how well it would work on homogenous soups... (if it does sodium, that could actually be pretty useful for homemade soup for people with high blood pressure).
 
Why aren't people scared all these informations will be saved by the company and then sent to google for the NSA so they'll know how to manipulate you with SMOOTHIES FOR GOD SAKE?
CAN'T YOU SEE THIS IS AN ILLUMINATI PLOT TO RULE THE WORLD ?????
 
I love the guy pouring beer into the cup. He looks at the cup, and it says "Beer", and he nods his head like, "Beer.. So that's what was in that can I didn't bother to read"..
 
But surely you also eat solid food... :confused:

----------



You were on a diet, and you actually drank stuff with calories? I find switching to zero calorie drinks to be the first step in any diet.

I switched to zero calorie drinks, but do smoothies / homemade protein shakes as breakfast and lunch replacements (try to avoid using pre-packaged ones for all the junk they add).

Apologize to anyone who doesn't care about my weight loss plan (which is everyone).
 
This looks like a solution in search of a problem, like most gadgets at Sharper Image type stores.

I really don't see a demand for this product by most consumers, although if you look beyond mass market the implications are interesting.
 
If this thing works as well as The Verge says it does in their test, this thing sounds pretty great. I don't get why all of the comments are so negative? Granted I only make home made smoothies and juices sometimes, but it sounds pretty neat. $99 is steep, but I've never heard of a product like this working so well (according to The Verge).

Maybe I am just with the wrong crowd and need to see a forum with those who love their gadgets and tech even just to play around with sometimes.

EDIT: do not like that they charge a cc immediately upon preorder! That's scary to me.
 
Last edited:
If this thing works as well as The Verge says it does in their test, this thing sounds pretty great. I don't get why all of the comments are so negative? Granted I only make home made smoothies and juices sometimes, but it sounds pretty neat. $99 is steep, but I've never heard of a product like this working so well (according to The Verge).

Maybe I am just with the wrong crowd and need to see a forum with those who love their gadgets and tech even just to play around with sometimes.

EDIT: do not like that they charge a cc immediately upon preorder! That's scary to me.

I'm just about to preorder mine now. Using a credit card so I know I'm safe and they're all a very friendly bunch of people. Have sent multiple emails and received responses very quickly answering all of my questions.
 
I've been sitting here for a while and try as I might, I can't think of a stupider idea than an expensive, resource-intensive device that tells you what you're drinking.

The inevitable "This is the stupidest idea/invention ever" and "why would anyone ever want one of these" comments always crack me up.

What percentage of the population runs? Of that percentage, how many would want "smart" running shoes that talk to their iPhones? Yet the Nike+ system is used everyday.

Everyone, and I mean EVERYONE on this forum drinks. Why wouldn't a supportable subgroup of them be interested enough in their hydration and/or caloric/nutrient intake via fluids to find it useful?

It may be a first gen product, and thus be overpriced, and have other shortcomings that may be overcome in the future. But the myopic "I don't have a need for it, so it's a stupid device." viewpoint just shows a lack of vision.

I'd bet you probably thought the idea of a hard drive based, $300 music player was stupid in 2001, also.
 
Everyone, and I mean EVERYONE on this forum drinks. Why wouldn't a supportable subgroup of them be interested enough in their hydration and/or caloric/nutrient intake via fluids to find it useful?

A fair point. But at what point do we say no to filling our landfills with stuff like this?
 
You were on a diet, and you actually drank stuff with calories? I find switching to zero calorie drinks to be the first step in any diet.

Common misunderstanding....

0 (zero), also a number.

----------

A fair point. But at what point do we say no to filling our landfills with stuff like this?

Why are there so many people here whose first reaction to various products is "landfill"?? Use the blasted thing, don't throw it away.
 
If this thing works as well as The Verge says it does in their test, this thing sounds pretty great.

Well, a demo in a controlled environment, with known components, is easy to fake - just have an employee in the background paying attention to what the reporter is putting in, and manually telling the cup/app what to display.

I'm hopeful, but suspicious, on this.

The fact that they charge the card is very worrying. But if you use a Visa or Mastercard, there is a fraud guarantee - you can challenge the charge if it turns out to be fake and they don't refund.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.