Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.

FLIphone

macrumors newbie
Original poster
Jun 28, 2009
9
0
Do you need the data plan for the iphone? I'd rather not have it and save the money
 
Data services are very tightly integrated into the iPhone. I suspect if you don't have a data plan, they will bill you per KB of data transfer you use. So if you accidentally go to maps, safari, the app store, etc. have fun paying the large bills.

And in the US, you need a data plan to activate unless you jailbreak. You might be able to call AT&T and say you are no longer using your iPhone and ask them to remove the data plan but I don't know what they do when they detect it being used again.
 
Data services are very tightly integrated into the iPhone. I suspect if you don't have a data plan, they will bill you per KB of data transfer you use. So if you accidentally go to maps, safari, the app store, etc. have fun paying the large bills.

And in the US, you need a data plan to activate unless you jailbreak. You might be able to call AT&T and say you are no longer using your iPhone and ask them to remove the data plan but I don't know what they do when they detect it being used again.


What does jail break mean. Damn I've heard theres so many ways to do it I just cant figure out how
 
AT&T requires a data plan.

If you cancel it and claim not to be using your iPhone, AT&T will put it back on your plan when it detects that you're using your SIM card in the iPhone.


Jailbreaking is hacking the iPhone so that you can use it in ways other than Apple officially allows.
 
AT&T requires a data plan.

If you cancel it and claim not to be using your iPhone, AT&T will put it back on your plan when it detects that you're using your SIM card in the iPhone.


Jailbreaking is hacking the iPhone so that you can use it in ways other than Apple officially allows.

Anyway to stop ATT from detecting my phone?
 
Wirelessly posted (Mozilla/5.0 (iPhone; U; CPU iPhone OS 3_0 like Mac OS X; en-us) AppleWebKit/528.18 (KHTML, like Gecko) Version/4.0 Mobile/7A341 Safari/528.16)

What's up with all you cheap people not wanting the data plan for the iPhone? That's practically 50% of the iPhone experince if not more.... Sheesh!
 
I suppose if you just use it for email and maybe the occasional web page, it would end up being cheaper without the plan. You'd have to be really careful though. Within the first few hours that I had my phone, I had already downloaded about 16 MB of web pages and app updates. That's about $160 right there. :)
 
AT&T requires a data plan.

If you cancel it and claim not to be using your iPhone, AT&T will put it back on your plan when it detects that you're using your SIM card in the iPhone.


Jailbreaking is hacking the iPhone so that you can use it in ways other than Apple officially allows.

This is absolutely correct, after spending a total of 3 horus on the phone with two CSRs. If you get it turned off, they will turn it back on to pay per use automatically ($1 per 100 KB). They can only remove charges once. It is impossible for CSRs to turn off data or block it on an iPhone, even if you convince them to. I posted a thread just a minute ago about my experience with this.

And to those who always have to chime in about why you would ever want a data plan turned off, think about it, many people are in different situations and have their reasons.
 
This is absolutely correct, after spending a total of 3 horus on the phone with two CSRs. If you get it turned off, they will turn it back on to pay per use automatically ($1 per 100 KB). They can only remove charges once. It is impossible for CSRs to turn off data or block it on an iPhone, even if you convince them to. I posted a thread just a minute ago about my experience with this.

And to those who always have to chime in about why you would ever want a data plan turned off, think about it, many people are in different situations and have their reasons.

Isn't it clearly stated that a data plan is required for the iPhone? Every package you can buy for the iPhone comes with the data plan and you cannot remove it unless you call and argue. Its a data-centric device. Don't like that? Get an iPod.
 
This is absolutely correct, after spending a total of 3 horus on the phone with two CSRs. If you get it turned off, they will turn it back on to pay per use automatically ($1 per 100 KB). They can only remove charges once. It is impossible for CSRs to turn off data or block it on an iPhone, even if you convince them to. I posted a thread just a minute ago about my experience with this.

And to those who always have to chime in about why you would ever want a data plan turned off, think about it, many people are in different situations and have their reasons.

I don't get your point. AT&T requires a data plan, which is clearly stated when you get the iPhone. I understand your situation and your reasons, but that doesn't change that fact.
 
The data plan costs $1 per day (or less in months with 31 days).

If that is out of your price range, then the iPhone is not for you.

People need to start living within their means.
 
No Data Plan on Wife's 3gs

First, I would not have an iPhone without a Data Plan, but wanted to share what happen to us. We upgraded her 2g (original phone with $20 data plan) and my 3g to the new 3gs iphones. They were mailed to us so I registered them myself via iTunes. My 3gs (from 3g) had no problem. However, her 2g did not upgrade the data plan to the $30 per month. It just dropped the data plan. So she had no data plan. What happened was she would get a error every time she tried to use data (mail, stocks, weather etc) which said did not have a network data plan. I did not notice this for a while because when at home we are on the Wifi Network and I was not with her when she was having problems away from home. She does not really use data as much as I do.

Anyway, I had a iPhone with NO Data Plan and it would not allow any data activity. Also, when I logged in to check her phone it showed the new phone model (black 3gs 16gb (even though it is a 32gb)) without a data plan.

While talking to AT&T they added the data plan and I was good to go.
 
I don't get your point. AT&T requires a data plan, which is clearly stated when you get the iPhone. I understand your situation and your reasons, but that doesn't change that fact.

It wasn't required up until the 3GS. With the 3G you could turn it off legally if you paid full price, and with the 2.5G you could turn it off whenever. I know this since I was able to turn off my data plan just fine with no problems after talking to a CSR about it, and AT&T workers.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.