Become a MacRumors Supporter for $50/year with no ads, ability to filter front page stories, and private forums.
Update for all of you. I went to the Apple Store today and I spoke directly to the manager (as AppleCare suggested) and he very kindly offered to replace my phone for "cosmetic" reasons however it would be the last time my phone is replaced unless there is a hardware fault. Very nice of him to do that because I know I was being a absolutely beyond nitpicky about the home button.

However, the other problems I experienced are without a doubt, manufacturing defects that definitely should have been replaced.

Yup that's what they usually do. Every product has a one-time exception. Hope this one is good! Is it perfect?

dL
 
This is why I never accept a replacement device for a phone within the 14-day return window. I was recently offered an express replacement for a defective 6, but I rejected that and opted to return for a refund. You never know what they will send you, and it might be worse than what you had. I'd rather place another order so I can have the 14 days to inspect it. Sorry you had such a bad experience.
 
Last edited:
Hi everyone,

While some of you might not believe my unfortunate story, I really need to vent my frustrations and receive feedback on what I should do.

BEWARE: Wall of text incoming.

So my story starts with me pre-ordering my iPhone 6 through the online store. While I was saddened that I had to wait 1 week after the launch date to receive my phone, it didn't bother me too much. However, disappointment struck as soon as I opened the box.

My first iPhone 6 had a scratch on the screen STRAIGHT out of the box. It was directly below the front camera and appeared to be underneath the oleophobic coating. Meaning, the panel was scratched in manufacturing before the coating was even applied. Pretty unacceptable if you ask me knowing Apple's reputation for quality.

So, I called the online store customer service and I requested for a replacement to which they obliged. HOWEVER, for some reason, the rep told me that I'm not allowed to go a local apple store to replace it since I bought it online. I would have to order a replacement through the online store. This seemed very odd to me but I went along with it since it was an express replacement option.

One week later, I received my replacement iPhone 6 and disappointment again. I had a faulty lock button! It was wobbly and had sort of a "double click" action instead of that solid click I love from Apple products.

So, I called support again; this time choosing Apple Care support. The rep was amazing and explained to me that I was actually allowed to go to a local store for a replacement and so, she set me up with a special case number to replace my phone at my local Apple Store.

One week later, I went and replaced my phone. All the buttons worked. Everything seemed well so I went home. Unfortunately, that night I discovered a single dead pixel right in the center of the screen! So, I make another appointment at the apple store set for the next week which leads to today...

At the Apple store today, they agreed that my phone had a dead pixel but they would not be replacing my phone. Instead, they would replace the screen. I was a bit upset but I had no choice but to settle for it.

Two hours later, I received my "fixed" phone and lo and behold, there's freakin dust under the replacement panel. It was a tiny speck in the lower left corner that was hardly noticeable but I was still upset. The rep was very apologetic at this point and offered to give me a replacement. A free replacement, wow, that's great I thought. So, I agreed.

Too bad my third replacement had an iffy home button. While it works, it doesn't have that solid click and produces a very weird sound as if it's "crackling". It's hard to describe but I told the rep and he insisted that he couldn't feel or hear a difference. He "assured" me "100%" that the home button is just like that and wouldn't be a problem which meant he wasn't bringing out another replacement phone. However, I hated the crackly feel and sound to it (definitely abnormal) so I said I would rather just use my "old" iPhone 6 with the barely noticeable speck of dust.

However, he said that the replacement process already went through so I would HAVE to take this faulty phone instead of my LESS faulty old phone! I told him I would rather deal with a speck of dust I can't see instead of a terrible home button that I would have to experience every 10 minutes. But alas, I still had to take the replacement.

So here I am with my fourth iPhone 6 with a terrible crackly home button and I have no idea what to do anymore. I love the functionality of the iPhone 6, and Apple customer service has been great but the fact remains that I still don't have a 1000 dollar iPhone 6 that works as intended. What should my next step be in this case?

TL;DR: I've had to replace my iPhone 6 three times and replace the screen once, yet I still have a faulty iPhone 6 that the Apple store refused to acknowledge as faulty and replaceable. What should I do?


Take your money somewhere else.
 
This story sounds kinda weird but at the end of the day quality control has gone down. I bought a Sony Vaio laptop for $1700 in December and it was running really hot and the fan was super loud. Additionally, the screen had a smear and the list if other crap continued. I refunded it and got a new one with a dead pixel. I just kept it many others have returned theirs multiple times.
Yesterday, I applied a tempered glass screen protector to my 5s it took me OVER an hour because I cannot tolerate dust specs under my screen. So although I agree the OP has the worst luck and may be even picky he has every right to return. However, the smart move is to ask for a refund and then buy another.
 
Last edited:
Yup that's what they usually do. Every product has a one-time exception. Hope this one is good! Is it perfect?

dL

Yes. As far as I can tell, this one doesn't have any problems. Hoping it stays that way. Only took 4 tries!

I've learned my lesson now though. Next time I get a faulty Apple device, I'll return it, instead of playing the replacement lottery...
 
please, every launch there are sob stories here of new account people exchanging iphones a dozen times and how apple's quality standards are crap. yet i've never met a person who has actually done this

Well, you haven't MET me, but I did have dead oixel issues with the 3GS. I opened three units in store. It was like glitter across the screen (no just one or two is my point).

Not saying this thread is legit, but my story was. You can choose to believe it or not. Either way just adding to the discourse.
 
Register on MacRumors! This sidebar will go away, and you'll see fewer ads.